The night before Roma Torre and four others on the news team went public with their discrimination lawsuit against New York cable news network NY1, she found comfort in remembering her mother.

“I was really freaking out,” said Torre, 61, who grew up in Mt. Lebanon while her mother, legendary KDKA-TV anchor Marie Torre, worked in Pittsburgh.

Earlier in Marie Torre’s career, as a reporter in New York City in 1959, she was sentenced to 10 days in jail for refusing to reveal her source for a column about actress Judy Garland. There was the possibility that even after she was released from jail, Marie Torre could have been sent back. Roma was 8 months old at the time.

“I just thought of my poor mom, the night before she was to report to jail, how awful it must have been for her. And I started to identify with her, not that my situation is anywhere near that [circumstance].

Advertise with us

“I really felt a kinship with my mother; the fact that she was able to hold it together and go to jail and stand up for her principles enabled me to do this with my head held high.”

Marie Torre died in Monroeville in 1997 of lung cancer. Generations of Pittsburghers will remember her as a trailblazing journalist — the first female anchor for the station — who paved the way for the next wave of women anchors at KDKA, including Patti Burns.

In the lawsuit filed in Federal District Court earlier this summer, Roma Torre, Kristen Shaughnessy, Vivian Lee, Amanda Farinacci and Jeanine Ramirez contend that after Charter Communications bought Time Warner Cable three years ago, the newswomen, all between ages 40 and 61, were systematically “marginalized.”

A spokesman for Charter Communications has responded in a statement: “We take these allegations seriously, but the lawsuit has no merit. We plan to defend against these accusations.

“It should be noted that they are all still also gainfully employed and on air regularly. NY1 is a respectful and fair workplace, and we’re committed to providing a work environment in which all our employees are valued and empowered. We are proud that at NY1, 57% of our on-air talent are women, 55% of our on-air talent are over the age of 40 and 25% of our on-air talent are women over 40.”

Advertise with us

Roma Torre was not only a news anchor but also a longtime theater critic whose reviews were featured on NY1’s “On Stage” program.

Before Charter Communications took ownership, she was on the air from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. “I was sort of woven into the newscast in the morning at 10 and we would overlap with the morning anchor ….

“As the day wore on, it became all me at noontime, and it was all me until 4 o’clock in the afternoon.”

Her late-afternoon reports would then overlap with others until 6 p.m.

Her current assignment has her appearing at varying spots: live for an hour at noon but then moving to another set to record stories that won’t appear until after 3 p.m. By 5 p.m., when the evening anchors arrive, Torre is finished.

Advertise with us

Torre, who writes the bulk of, produces and anchors her segments, said the new management made her feel devalued in myriad ways, including limiting her access to getting her makeup done in the mornings.

In a business where older male anchors supposedly lend “gravitas,” she said, women are expendable. In 2017, when NY1 reached its 25th anniversary — Torre was one of its first hires — there was little hoopla, according to the lawsuit.

But the next year, the station did throw a virtual party for Torre’s co-anchor, Pat Kiernan. Kiernan was a 20-year veteran at NY1.

“They actually had food trucks they hired to travel all around town, with banners touting the fact that the great Pat Kiernan has been with NY1 for 20 years, and isn’t that a wonderful thing?” she said.

“For me, it was crickets.”

Advertise with us

“Initially, I thought it was just me,” she said. “That it wasn’t an age thing, that they just didn’t like me. I jumped through hoops trying to prove my worth over there.”

But stories from colleagues began to create a common thread: older women, less air time.

“In journalism, it’s all about information. And with age comes depth of knowledge that should make us more valuable as journalists. Sadly, that line is blurred now between news gathering and entertainment.

“I feel I’m in my prime. I think I’m at the best I’ll ever be because I’m able to comment on a breadth of issues that I have absorbed in over 30 years in the business.”

A mom like no other moms

Advertise with us

Growing up in Pittsburgh, Roma Torre would realize Marie wasn’t like most of the other moms at school.

“I did take it for granted that my working mother was kind of the norm, but that was until all my friends had their moms take them to Girl Scout meetings and piano lessons and all that.

“Both of my parents were always out pretty late. We had a housekeeper who always did that sort of typical mommy stuff.”

She said that quality time with Marie more than made up for quantity of hours: “My mother was my best friend.” And a role model.

Roma Torre set out to become an actress. But her enthusiasm cooled after she decided she would not play nude scenes.

Advertise with us

“She took me out to dinner one day and said, ‘Look, not that I ever wanted to see you doing nude scenes on a screen, but the fact that you are limiting yourself in your chosen profession means maybe you ought to reconsider your career goals.’”

So for Torre, news became her new passion. After taking a few journalism courses, she landed a job in April of 1984 at the CBS affiliate — as the news director’s secretary. (“So close and yet so far,” she said.)

She took the station’s newswriting test the following year under an assumed name and was offered a freelance gig. At the appointed hour, she walked into the news director’s office and said, “I am Kathryn, reporting for duty.”

“They were not happy with me at all and basically said, ‘You cannot quit your job.’”

For two years she was a secretary on weekdays and worked as a newswriter on the weekends.

Advertise with us

Eventually she found work on-air, where many have remarked on her resemblance to Marie.

“I cannot tell you how happy I am when somebody writes to me and says, ‘You look so much like your mother, you sound so much like your mother.’ That always makes my day.”

Torre said she realizes the lawsuit might make it appear she and the other women are just jealous that their roles have been diminished. In fact, she added, “Pat has been elevated to the status of being, essentially, king of the newsroom, and I’m OK with that, really.

“It’s just that while he’s king of the newsroom, I am, like, a peon.”

Pittsburgh attorney Caroline Mitchell was a longtime litigator in employment discrimination suits; she no longer does trial work. She said that companies — be they news networks, airlines, hospitals — don’t have the right to choose employees based on what they feel to be “customer preference.”

Advertise with us

“In the old days, the airlines all wanted young chicks in tight skirts [as flight attendants],” she said. “That was ruled as a form of sex discrimination.”

In a similar vein, patients can’t request they not be treated by a woman or an African American doctor. Yet bringing in younger women to read the news is an increasingly common trend in both local and national television news.

The perceived demotion of a broadcast journalist might not be obvious, Ms. Mitchell said. It’s often death by a thousand cuts, “all those little things that wear you down, like water dripping on a stone.”

The challenge for both sides of the suit, she said, will be in the discovery of documentation. The details of how NY1 operates and the plaintiffs’ roles in delivering the news will be a crucial part of the equation.

Torre said she has been heartened, and surprised, that many in the NY1 newsroom reacted positively after news of the lawsuit broke.

Advertise with us

“We were cheered by our own colleagues in our newsrooms and other newsrooms as well, and by other people from all over. Not just the country but over the world were reaching out to us, giving us so much support.

“I was just so shocked that we had that kind of reach.”

Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or @MariaSciulloPG.