TV Q&A with Rob Owen
Post-Gazette TV writer Rob Owen answers reader questions online every Friday in Tuned In Journal blog at post-gazette.com/tv. Here’s a selection of recent queries.
Q: What happened to WPXI weekend anchor Marlisa Goldsmith? She hasn't been on now for a few weeks. — MATT VIA EMAIL
Rob: Goldsmith recently departed WPXI-TV to return to her former station, the CBS affiliate in Little Rock, Ark., where she will be an evening news anchor.
Q: I see “The Good Fight” is now on CBS. Is this the same show that was on CBS All Access? Will it now be on CBS all the time? How many seasons were on All Access? — FRAN VIA FACEBOOK
Rob: CBS is airing reruns of the first season of “The Good Fight” that previously premiered on the subscription service CBS All Access. These episodes will be edited for time and content so they won’t be the full episodes that are available on CBS All Access.
At this point, CBS plans to air only the first season as a promotion to try to entice viewers to subscribe to CBS All Access to watch season two and three. A fourth season is expected to premiere in 2020.
Q: I have a question that must be phrased delicately: Who decides when it's time to cancel a TV show even if it is popular? For example, we don't need agent Gibbs of “NCIS” being wheeled about in a wheelchair or Det. Benson of “Law & Order: SVU” collecting an old-age pension. — ERIC VIA FACEBOOK
Rob: In most cases, network executives decide when a series will end. Sometimes it’s the cast of a show — or in the case of “The Big Bang Theory,” the whims of one cast member, Jim Parsons — but most of the time it’s a call made by network executives when a series is no longer financially viable, not when it is creatively out of juice.
Q: Can you comment on shows like the “Criminal Minds” and “NCIS: Los Angeles" putting on stories that are illogical as far as common sense allows? There seems to be no way some of their storylines can exist. The “NCIS: Los Angeles” program recently had a male pinned to a wall by a car, and he was still able to function for the whole show without dying as he is talked to by an NCIS agent, and there is no one trying to free him in this condition. “Criminal Minds” has been going downhill, too. WHERE IS LOGIC IN THESE SHOWS?
I do not know if any other viewers think these shows have become odd, but I do. — BOB, CORAOPOLIS
Rob: In all honesty, I don’t watch any of the shows Bob mentions because they’re, as Bob suggests, not really worth my time.
Procedurals do tend to be more “TV real” than absolutely realistic. And perhaps as these shows age, the writers grow less concerned with the finer points of realism in favor of just churning out more stories.
Ask TV questions by emailing rowen@post-gazette.com, including your first name and location, or submitting the form at post-gazette.com/tv.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.