Picking the best series in an era of about 500 scripted series proves extremely difficult, not just because there’s a lot of quality television but, seriously, how does any critic have time to watch it all?
Short answer: No one person does.
Even when a TV critic today watches some of a series for the purposes of writing a review, there’s often not time to return to the show because more new programs come along that need to be watched.
So consider this a list of favorites from 2018 seen in their entirety (or close to it) and shows worth seeking out if you haven’t seen them yet.
1.“The Good Fight” (CBS All Access): This “Good Wife” spinoff began well enough but really came into its own in season two when the focus returned to Diane Lockhart (Christine Baranski) and responded to current political events that made the show timely, engrossing and often darkly funny.
2. “Better Call Saul” (AMC): As this prequel creeps closer to the events of “Breaking Bad,” it only becomes more devastating for the potential carnage that will befall those who enter the orbit of Jimmy McGill/Saul Goodman (Bob Odenkirk) — especially devoted Kim (Emmy-worthy Rhea Seehorn).
3. “The Americans” (FX): Dasvidanya to TV’s best portrait of a marriage that also happened to be the story of Russian spies in 1980s America.
4. “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” (Amazon): With all the dark-themed series, it’s refreshing to have a one-hour comedy (with drama) as delightful and as beautifully shot as this confection from Amy Sherman Palladino, who was responsible for the similarly toned “Gilmore Girls.”
5. “Homecoming” (Amazon): Julia Roberts made the move into television with this twisty thriller with a Hitchcokian vibe and engrossing visuals courtesy director Sam Esmail. Both suspenseful and at times quite funny — especially when Ms. Roberts’ Heidi had to take phone calls from her awful boss, played perfectly by Bobby Cannavale — “Homecoming” proved an easily digestible binge with its 30-minute episodes. The show gets bonus credit for casting Stephan James (“Shots Fired”), who more than holds his own opposite Ms. Roberts.
6. “One Dollar” (CBS All Access): The yinzeriest, Western Pennsylvania-set series yet (those accents!), “One Dollar” suffered from a decided lack of buzz, but it managed to capture social class issues usually left on the sidelines in scripted programming. The passing dollar bill conceit was hit or miss, but the characters, their relationships and choices rang true, as did a denouement that was far more satisfying/believable than if the show had gone with a trite serial killer. The streaming service announced this week that the show has been canceled.
7. “Escape at Dannemora” (Showtime): Sometimes a little too languid in its pacing, “Escape” proved an acting triumph for star Patricia Arquette, who became a mousy prison employee in the hands-down best performance of the year.
8. “The Expanse” (Syfy): In an era of slow burn series, this one, which moves to Amazon for its upcoming fourth season, may be the slowest. But “The Expanse” paid off elements established in its pilot in season three by bringing disparate characters together and concluding the story’s initial movement.
9. “Pose” (FX): Producer Ryan Murphy’s drama about transgender characters in 1980s New York might seem audacious and avant-garde, but once you get past the runway shows and get to know the characters, “Pose” becomes an extremely relatable show about characters regardless of their gender identity.
10. “This Is Us” (NBC): Sure, this partially Pittsburgh-set hit can sometimes devolve into soapy shenanigans (the dead brother who’s really alive), but the character relationships often enough ring true, and the show’s devotion to its setting (the Immaculate Reception in the season premiere; the tag at the end of the episode that followed the Tree of Life shootings) continue to win over viewers even when the plotting isn’t up to snuff.
Honorable mention: “The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story” (FX), “Atlanta” (FX), “Barry” (HBO), “Castle Rock” (Hulu), “The Chi” (Showtime), “Counterpart” (Starz), “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend” (The CW), “The Good Place” (NBC), “The Handmaid’s Tale” (Hulu), “The Haunting of Hill House” (Netflix), “Jack Ryan” (Amazon), “The Kids are Alright” (ABC), “Killing Eve” (BBC America”), "The Looming Tower” (Hulu), “Masterpiece: Little Women” (PBS), “McMafia” (AMC), “9-1-1” (Fox), “One Day at A Time” (Netflix), “Patrick Melrose” (Showtime), “The Romanoffs” (Amazon), “Saturday Night Live” (NBC), “Succession” (HBO), “Vida” (Showtime), “You” (Lifetime).
Of local note: ‘Extreme Love’
WE tv’s “Extreme Love” (10 p.m. Dec. 28) explores “unusual real-life relationships,” and the debut episode promises a Pittsburgh connection.
Here’s how the network describes a couple featured in the first episode, “Kyle & Marg,” from Pittsburgh: “Everyone has a type, and grandmas just happen to be Kyle’s. Although he is deeply in love with Marg, his 91-year-old girlfriend, Kyle, 31, is not a one-woman man. Enter the competition: Annie, a 68-year-old side piece. As long as Kyle is around, no one’s nana is safe. What will happen when he introduces his 91-year-old girlfriend to his mom?”
A WE tv publicist declined to give the participants’ last names or where in the region they reside citing “confidentiality reasons.”
Further afield, Investigation Discovery’s “The Lake Erie Murders” (9 p.m. Dec. 30) miniseries explores murder cases in cities adjacent to the Great Lake, including at least one case in Erie, Pa.
Kept/canceled
BET canceled “Hit the Floor” after four seasons.
Comedy Central canceled “Detroiters” after two seasons.
Epix renewed “Get Shorty” for season three; Amazon did the same for “Goliath.”
Channel surfing
The Hollywood Foreign Press Association announced a new award for the Golden Globes that will be given annually to an honoree beginning with the Carol Burnett Award’s namesake at the 76th Annual Golden Globes (8 p.m. Jan. 6, NBC). … Sally Wiggin’s last time hosting WTAE’s “Chronicle” — this one devoted to Pittsburgh holiday traditions — before retirement will air at 9 p.m. Dec. 21 on Channel 4. ... Carrie Ann Inaba is expected to replace Julie Chen on “The Talk.” … Kathy Lee Gifford will leave the fourth hour of NBC’s “Today” after a 10-year run. … Carrie Blazina, a former Penn Hills resident, will be a contestant on “Jeopardy!” (7 p.m., Dec. 20, NBC). Ms. Blazina, 26, is a 2010 graduate of Penn Hills High School and works as a multiplatform editor at The Boston Globe. ... CBS’ “A Home for the Holidays,” an annual special celebrating families who have adopted from foster care, celebrates its 20th anniversary (8 p.m. Dec. 21) with updates on three families previously featured and a profile of one new family.
Tuned In online
Today’s TV Q&A column responds to questions about “Mom,” “Judge Judy” and digital subchannels. This week’s Tuned In Journal includes posts on “The Flash.” Read online-only TV content at http://communityvoices.post-gazette.com/arts-entertainment-living/tuned-in.
TV writer Rob Owen: rowen@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2582. Follow RobOwenTV on Twitter or Facebook for breaking TV news.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.