BEVERLY HILLS, Calif. — Go ahead and engrave an Emmy with Patricia Arquette’s name: Her ability to disappear into the character of Tilly Mitchell in the partially filmed-in-Pittsburgh Showtime drama “Escape at Dannemora” (10 p.m. Sunday) is easily the most awards-worthy performance of the year.

Ms. Arquette, the star of the late prime-time drama “Medium,” is virtually unrecognizable as she shucks all vanity to play a mousy, desperate-for-attention prison employee. TV shows most often rise or fall based on the quality of the writing, but in “Dannemora,” Ms. Arquette’s performance proves the most captivating. Whenever she’s on screen, viewers will be rapt.

A seven-part limited series, “Escape at Dannemora” smartly and efficiently sets up the story in the first episode, introducing the characters involved in a real-life prison escape from 2015.

It’s also that rare TV event that manages to weave exposition seamlessly into the dialogue without it sticking out like a sore thumb. Credit writers Brett Johnson, Michael Tolkin and Pittsburgh native Jerry Stahl and director Ben Stiller — yes, comedy actor Ben Stiller, directs this series — with creating a smart, realistic drama with believable characters brought to life by dynamic performances, particularly from Ms. Arquette and co-stars Paul Dano and Bonnie Hunt.

Advertise with us

The story, previously told in a 2017 Lifetime movie, begins after the prison escape as the inspector general of New York, Catherine Scott (Ms. Hunt), arrives at the Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora, N.Y., to interview Joyce “Tilly” Mitchell (Ms. Arquette). The series then flashes back to show how Tilly became involved sexually with prisoners David Sweat (Mr. Dano) and Richard Matt (Benicio Del Toro, doing his usual, mush-mouth Del Toro thing). Early episodes establish the characters, including Tilly’s sad sack husband played by Eric Lange, whose lumpy Lyle is a perfect complement to Ms. Arquette’s perpetually dyspeptic Tilly.

Ms. Arquette deploys a perfect upstate New York accent and creates an aggrieved personality that’s entirely believable. Her nonverbal noises — little sound tics that sometimes emerge as soft giggles — and her eye movements in some scenes are less a performance than an embodiment of a specific character whose disappointments in life foment desires that get the better of her.

If “Dannemora” has a weakness, it’s the show’s slow, meandering second episode, but after that the limited series moves at a good clip in episodes that further explore the relationships among the characters as well as their backgrounds. The finale, clocking in at an hour and 40 minutes, offers a breathless, tension-filled denouement.

Making ‘Dannemora’

Filmed from August 2017 to March 2018, “Escape at Dannemora” mostly shot in New York state, but the limited series decamped to Pittsburgh in October 2017, filming locally for two weeks (not enough to qualify for a Pennsylvania Film Tax Credit).

Advertise with us

Why Pittsburgh? Because the “Dannemora” production could make use of the now-closed SCI Pittsburgh (formerly known as Western Penitentiary).

“We got so lucky because the prison had just been decommissioned … and everything was basically still intact,” said director Stiller (“Reality Bites”) following a Showtime press conference at the Television Critics Association summer 2018 press tour. “We shot sequences in tunnels and access ways that were incredible.”

The scenes shot in Pittsburgh — mostly outdoor exterior scenes inside the prison walls — match seamlessly with scenes filmed outside the walls of the real prison in Dannemora, N.Y.

“Dannemora” writer Johnson said while most prison interiors were created on a soundstage — the cells, cell block and tailor shop — the prison courtyards are largely from the Pittsburgh shoot, including a scene of a snowy day shot in 70-degree weather using fake snow. The production also used SCI Pittsburgh’s mess hall for scenes and landed a helicopter inside the prison walls in the finale when New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo (Michael Imperioli, “The Sopranos”) arrives following the prisoners’ escape.

Mr. Johnson and series co-creator Mr. Tolkin were writing on Showtime’s “Ray Donovan” at the time the real-life prison break occurred. Mr. Johnson had missed the prison escape while attending a wedding when a friend called and told him to turn on the news.

Advertise with us

“I got so excited I forgot to return the tuxedo and found it in my car six months later and got charged, like, $700 by Men’s Wearhouse,” Mr. Johnson said.

Ultimately, the show’s script was based largely on the New York inspector general’s 175-page report on the event.

“It had everything you’d ever want, every sex scene that would ever be in the show, them talking about murder,” Mr. Johnson said.

Ms. Arquette said she worked with a dialect coach to get the accent — a cross between New Yorkese and rural Minnesota — just right. Filming in Dannemora, N.Y., also helped inform the character.

“For me, it felt kind of desolate,” Ms. Arquette said. “All these people were just working in the prisons. And there wasn't a lot to do. Also the intense cold of that area made me feel like, well, my character is kind of bored and wants to feel alive.”

Advertise with us

The role also included exploring themes not generally glimpsed in popular entertainment.

“To be able to do character work and explore human sexuality as a middle aged woman with not a kind of body that Hollywood is used to, I thought was a really interesting conversation to have,” Ms. Arquette said. “To have a character that puts [herself] at the top of the list. She takes care of her damn needs before anybody or anything else. And I didn't experience that growing up. I haven't had a lot of models like that in women. I'm not saying we should do that.”

Channel surfing

Amazon's “Bosch,” in production on its fifth season, received an order for season six this week. ... Cable’s Discovery-owned Velocity gets rebranded as MotorTrend Network on Nov. 23. ... WPXI's coverage of the annual Downtown Pittsburgh “Holiday Parade” will air 9-11 a.m. Nov. 24. ...Netflix canceled “The Good Cop” after one season.

Tuned In online

Advertise with us

Today’s TV Q&A column responds to questions about “Chicago Fire,” Hallmark Channel Christmas movies and “Jeopardy!” Read online-only TV content at http://communityvoices.post-gazette.com/arts-entertainment-living/tuned-in.

TV writer Rob Owen: rowen@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2582. Follow RobOwenTV on Twitter or Facebook for breaking TV news.