One recurring question from viewers deserves another look: Why is the background music on TV shows drowning out the dialogue?

A lot has changed since I first addressed this question in a 2001 column, particularly when it comes to TV sets. The rollout of HDTV sets coupled with the advent of Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound for the home changed the way sets manage sound.

Back in 2001, local audiologist Catherine Palmer said the most common type of hearing loss is found in the frequencies where dialogue is most likely to be heard.

“When you first wrote the article, ‘The West Wing’ was driving patients into the clinic. In the past few years, it’s been ‘Downton Abbey,’ ” said Ms. Palmer, director of audiology and hearing aids at UPMC.

Advertise with us

She said once someone has some hearing loss (even mild high frequency hearing loss), anything that degrades the speech signal (noise, poor or different pronunciation, etc.) impacts listeners’ ability to process words quickly as the dialogue moves on.

And while hearing loss could be the culprit, lousy speakers also can be to blame. TV manufacturers focus on improving picture quality, but the quality of TV set speakers has declined.

“The sound in television manufacturing has always been a secondary concern,” said WPXI director of engineering Otto Schellin. “Televisions keep getting smaller and thinner and thinner, and as a result they don’t have as much room to have nice, physically large speakers that can reproduce the whole spectrum of sound more accurately.”

Speaker placement also can be a problem.

“I have had two patients in the clinic in the past week talking about TV listening difficulties and realizing that their TV’s speakers were in the back of the TV,” Ms. Palmer said. “It would be hard to imagine a worse place to present sound than away from the listeners.”

Advertise with us

Another issue is how sound is delivered. Most prime-time programs are presented in 5.1 surround sound, which is intended to be heard through multiple speakers that one finds in a home theater setup.

“If you don’t have six different speakers, which is a 5.1 system,” Mr. Schellin said, “the TV has to figure out how to do a down mix and take those six channels and put them in two [speakers] in stereo and oftentimes it will just mix everything together so you can’t distinguish between the dialogue [intended for] the center channel.”

What can a viewer do, other than to get a hearing test and/​or invest in a potentially expensive home theater system?

Oregon Public Broadcasting suggests manually altering a set’s sound by either switching the setting from stereo to mono or by turning off the TV’s surround sound.

Mr. Schellin said he encourages viewers to fiddle with the settings on their TV sets and if that doesn’t work, consider resetting their TV to the factory defaults, if that is an option, and with the understanding that such a move will wipe out any individualized settings a viewer made to their TV.

Advertise with us

“[If you are watching over the air] you might have to do another channel scan to reset all your channels,” he said.

A CNET/​com article from 2012 suggests plugging in a pair of computer speakers (http://​www.cnet.com/​news/​a-cheap-and-easy-fix-for-crummy-hdtv-speakers/) may resolve the problem.

Some audio experts recommend the purchase of a sound bar as an intermediate step between using the TV’s speakers and spending the money to upgrade to a surround sound home theater system.

“This gets around the problems … assuming you purchase a good quality sound bar and aim it at the listeners,” Ms. Palmer said. “I think for some people, it is very frustrating to feel like you need to buy an additional piece to add to your already expensive — and advertised as ‘state of the art’ — television.”

TV writer Rob Owen: rowen@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2582. Follow RobOwenTV on Twitter or Facebook for breaking TV news.