Poet Ella Wheeler Wilcox was mistaken when she wrote: “Laugh, and the world laughs with you; weep, and you weep alone.
In a brutal week for free speech, both cartoonists and late-night pundits were still searching for meaning and, yes, humor shortly after alleged Muslim terrorist killings at the Paris office of satire magazine Charlie Hebdo. There was a sense of solidarity almost immediately: After news broke Wednesday morning, sketches from professionals and amateurs alike began appearing on Twitter with the hashtag #jesuischarlie (”I am Charlie“).
“There has just been a flood of reaction,” said Rob Rogers, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial cartoonist and president of Pittsburgh’s ToonSeum. “I think that reaction has been so great because the terrorists’ aim was to stifle satire, stifle free expression.”
One of the most re-tweeted cartoons was that of Australian David Pope. A black-hooded man with a smoking rifle stands by the prone body of another man, his pens and paper scattered on the ground. The gunman’s response: “He drew first.”
Another was by Dutch cartoonist Ruben L. Oppenheimer. A plane flies toward two giant pencils, a scenario eerily echoing the World Trade Center attacks.
If taking up paper and pen was a collective response by artists, Americans as an audience also turned to late-night talk shows for, if not an explanation, then at least a smile.
Reactions Wednesday night varied from poignant (TBS’s “Conan“) to nonexistent (CBS’s “Late Show With David Letterman,” NBC’s “The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon”). Leading the way was Comedy Central’s “The Daily Show With Jon Stewart.”
“I think we all agree that 2014 was not a great year for people,” began Mr. Stewart. “Our hearts are with the staff of Charlie Hebdo and their families tonight. I know very few people go into comedy as an act of courage.”
Calling the attacks a “stark reminder that for the most part, the legislators and journalists and institutions that we jab and ridicule are not, in any way, the enemy,” he added, “Our goal tonight is not to make sense of this because there is no sense to be made of this.”
Incredibly, he said, his staff came across the perfect and perfectly weird video segment to bridge between tragedy and what served as a comic parable: “Nazi cows.”
Following a British news clip about cows “originally bred as a master race of belligerent bovines” during the Third Reich, the show threw to cast member Aasif Mandvi for a sketch that wasn’t really about cows, but of ridding society of “toxic ideologies.”
Conan O’Brien finished his Wednesday monologue with “all of us are terribly sad for the families of those victims, for the people of France and for anyone in the world tonight who now has to think twice before making a joke.”
The good news/bad news for Mr. Kimmel was having Bill Maher as a guest. Mr. Maher, whose HBO show, “Real Time With Bill Maher,” returns tonight, appeared frustrated that the host had carried on with jokes and business as usual without having yet mentioned what happened in Paris.
Settling into his chair, he immediately said “You’re the host, you’ve got to tell them the bad news.” After Mr. Kimmel recited what was known of the attacks, Mr. Maher, a self-described ultra-liberal, continued “And we have to not avoid who did this. Who did this, Jimmy?”
Tropes about court jesters being offed by unimpressed kings exist because yes, the practice of comedy can be risky. From ”South Park“ to ”The Interview,“ threats against writers and artists are nothing new. But carrying out those threats on a peaceful street in Paris came as a shock.
“I think, on one level, cartoonists are always on alert,“ said Mr. Rogers, who did a TV interview for Al-Jazeera Thursday and drew his own “Je suis Charlie” for Thursday’s Post-Gazette.
“But at the same time, we all know what we do is meant to get a reaction. We are used to getting angry emails and angry phone calls, so I don’t think most of us are worried about this kind [of reaction.]”
Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1478 or @MariaSciulloPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.