It’s impossible to talk about the Pittsburgh CLO’s upcoming production of “Into the Woods” without sounding like Bill Hader doing his famous “Saturday Night Live” character Stefon.

This show has everything: Bethel Park native, “High School Musical: The Musical: The Series” star and CLO alumnus Joe Serafini as Jack; Broadway talent galore in key roles; locally based actors pumped to be back on stage at the Benedum Center; an intricately crafted Milky White cow puppet; and Sally freakin’ Wiggin as the Giant.

This star-studded rendition of Stephen Sondheim’s 1987 musical sendup of fairytale storytelling will be taking over Downtown’s Benedum Center Tuesday-Sunday. Tickets are available for $29-$86 via pittsburghclo.org.

“Into the Woods” marks a major homecoming for both Serafini and Manu Narayan, a Delmont native and seasoned Broadway actor who will be playing The Baker opposite Patti Murin, the original Anna in Broadway’s “Frozen,” as The Baker’s Wife.

Advertise with us

“I feel like any excuse I get to come back to Pittsburgh, I’m always eager to do that and see my family, and come back to support the CLO,” Serafini, 25, told the Post-Gazette. “It was such a big part of my childhood, performing shows with them.”

Joe Serafini and the teen ensemble perform "We're All in This Together" from "High School Musical" as part of Pittsburgh CLO's 2021 "Broadway Musical Celebration" at Acrisure Stadium. (Matt Polk / Pittsburgh CLO)

“Into the Woods” follows a litany of characters based on classic fairytale archetypes as they all venture, well, into the woods in hopes of having their greatest wishes fulfilled. The Baker and his wife desperately want a child; Jack wants to avoid selling his best friend, a cow named Milky White (Lu Zielinski); Cinderella (Kyla Stone) wants to attend the ball; and The Witch (three-time Tony Award nominee Carolee Carmello) wants to regain her youth and beauty.

Fun Fact: This is Serafini’s first Benedum show in more than a decade and his second time playing Jack after a brief stint as the brash, giant-baiting young man in a CLO Academy version of “Into the Woods” when he was just 15.

“To now get to play it in this setting as an adult and with this amazing cast, it’s a dream come true and feels like I’m fulfilling my inner child in a way,” he said.

Narayan’s Baker is the show’s main figure who goes from anxious prospective father to a reluctant giant slayer in two hours. Of greater concern to him than the character itself, though, is the CLO allowing a BIPOC actor to lead one of its summer productions. He has encountered politically charged things around this region that “are a little frightening to me,” and he’s looking forward to reminding Pittsburghers “that people who look like me are Americans.”

Advertise with us

“No amount of wanting me to look a certain way is going to change that,” he said. “Whatever my take is on The Baker, hopefully it’ll be compelling enough for people to see. What’s most important is seeing someone that’s not necessarily an American majority in a lead role, especially in a place like Pittsburgh that’s so special — and we want to keep it that way.”

So do all the Western Pennsylvania-based performers appearing in “Into the Woods.” It was the first show Christine Laitta, a Green Tree resident who plays Cinderella’s stepmother, ever saw on Broadway, and she’s thrilled to be doing her “first professional Sondheim” alongside such a talented cast and crew.

“When you find a place that feels like home, not just Pittsburgh itself but this company, you cross your fingers and say all the prayers because you want to come back and work in a company where you can flourish and be with amazing people,” she said. “Everyone brings their own honesty and their own spin to it. There are lovely choices that people are making.”

Wiggin, a WTAE-TV anchor and reporter from 1980-2018, couldn’t be more ready to portray the Giant who terrorizes everyone in the show’s second act. “Into the Woods” is only featuring her voice, but you can bet Wiggin will be having the time of her life on opening night.

“I am so honored to be a part of such a special production,” she said. “I am nothing close to being a giant, in any way, shape or form! That is why I love pretend!”

Advertise with us
Actor Lu Zielinski rehearses with the Milky White puppet before Pittsburgh CLO's upcoming production of "Into the Woods." (Pittsburgh CLO)

In 2009, the Pittsburgh CLO put on “Into the Woods” with a cast of Broadway veterans that included Hunter Foster as The Baker, Brynn O’Malley as The Baker’s Wife, Jennifer Cody as Little Red and Beth Leavel as The Witch. Both the 2009 and 2023 shows also share a prop coordinator in Marty Savolskis, a Munhall native who been working with the CLO every summer since 2002 in between gigs on Broadway shows like “Wicked” and “Beauty and the Beast.”

Savolskis is psyched to have “a Pittsburgh boy at heart” like Serafini back in the CLO fold after his rise to fame via Disney. Besides the cast, he believes that part of what sets this “Into the Woods” apart from its 2009 CLO iteration is that this one is being presented to Pittsburgh theatergoers in the aftermath of COVID-induced shutdowns.

“There’s a lot of death and tragedy in this show, but there’s a lot about moving forward,” Savolskis said. “That’s the takeaway in my mind, finding that new day and that new light.”

One of this show’s most fascinating creations has to be the aforementioned Milky White puppet built by Allison Park resident Lisa Leibering. Traditionally, the oft-traded cow is usually either a static prop or played by an actor in a cow costume. This Milky White, though, will be controlled on stage by Zielinski, a Jersey City resident appearing in her first Benedum show.

Playing Milky White has been a longtime dream of hers, though she never expected it would involve operating a cow puppet with “flirty” eyelashes, flexible back hinges, a neck that can look around and a mouth that “opens enormously wide.” Zielinski feels like she’s on the verge of getting “Incredible Hulk arms from puppeteering” that she intends to take advantage of for full comic effect.

Advertise with us

“It’s my life’s purpose to make someone else laugh every day,” she said. “If this is my opportunity to get Pittsburgh to laugh at me, hell yeah!”

Manu Narayan, left, Robbie Fairchild and Max von Essen sing a medley of songs from "An American in Paris" as part of Pittsburgh CLO's 2021 "Broadway Musical Celebration" at Acrisure Stadium. (Matt Polk / Pittsburgh CLO)

The “Into the Woods” cast hopes to make Pittsburghers feel a wide range of emotions during the show’s Benedum run.

“It can speak to people, like Shakespeare, at every walk of life,” Narayan said. “’Into the Woods’ has so many wonderful storylines and characters that it can really hit you at every stage of your life differently. So there’s a reason to come see it no matter what.”

Laitta brought up Pittsburghers’ love of BOGO (buy one-get one) deals, and that “this is the ultimate deal” for theater and fairytale lovers in the sense they will be treated to “every story smashed together.” Narayan knows his hometown and joked that former Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger will be playing The Baker one night this week and that Pittsburghers will just have to show up every night in order to catch him.

Serafini is excited to be bringing what he recalled Murin referring to as “Sondheim’s most accessible show” to his hometown. The CLO is giving yinzers “an easy opportunity to go right Downtown and see it with this cast,” Serafini said before Narayan, not willing to let the joke die, immediately chimed in with: “And Ben.”

Advertise with us

Let’s end on a more sincere note courtesy of Melessie Clark, a Greensburg resident playing Cinderella’s stepsister, Lucinda.

“It’s your favorite fairytales, but you get so much depth and there’s so much meat to it,” she said. “It goes beyond the surface of just being children’s stories. Bring the kids, the grandkids, the babysitter — bring them all!”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxel222.