Once upon a time there was a baby doll who was adopted by actors. He traveled the country, enchanting everyone he met. Fans followed his every move on social media and eventually on Broadway. And, as with so many great names of musical theater, the legend was born right here.

“I have a Pittsburgh story for you,” was how Matthew Gardiner began the tale.

The associate artistic director of Signature Theatre in Arlington, Va., was chatting about his sparkling production of “Sunday in the Park With George” and his time at Carnegie Mellon University when he offered up the unusual case of Twan Baker. It starts at Pittsburgh CLO during the summer of 2009, when the star-studded cast of “Into the Woods” fell under the spell of a prop doll.

Tony-nominee Hunter Foster and Brynn O’Malley played the Baker and The Bake’s Wife, parents to a baby who is key to the story.

Advertise with us

“They fell in love with this doll, and they named it Twan Baker and started a Facebook page,” Mr. Gardiner said. “It has been the prop baby in four productions of ‘Into the Woods’ and ... it’s the baby Brynn is holding as Dot in ‘Sunday in the Park With George.’ ”

Ms. O’Malley completes a luminous turn in the dual role of George Seurat’s mistress Dot and grandmother Marie in “Sunday in the Park” Sept. 21, before returning to Broadway for the new musical “Honeymoon in Vegas.” As she did for the New York production of “Annie,” she plans to have baby Twan with her,

“Our goal is to get him into bigger and better shows all the time. We want more and more famous people to hold him … and our goal is to eventually have him end up in the Smithsonian,” the actress said like a proud parent.

Twan’s humble beginnings start in the CLO prop shop headed by Marty Savolskis. “In a way, you can call him the obstetrician,” said stage manager Karen Meek, who figures the head was already at the shop and the bean-bag body was created for the production.

“People don’t realize how often babies appear in musicals, and I think Twan brings that to light a little bit,” Ms. O’Malley said by phone before a “Sunday in the Park” performance last week. “There’s a baby in almost every musical, even if it’s just the woman pushing a stroller through the square. You quickly discover when you are playing a role like The Baker’s Wife or Dot how important that prop baby is. You’re playing a lot of really heavy emotional scenes and if you’ve got a crummy little piece of plastic with no weight to it in your arms, it’s hard to make a real connection with it.”

Advertise with us

The prop provided by CLO felt right in her arms, and co-stars Mr. Foster and Ms. O’Malley would admire their “baby” while waiting for a mutual entrance. Ms. O’Malley decided he needed a name.

“I said something like, ‘What would be the most unlikely name for our offspring?’ And Hunter just closed his eyes and went, ‘Twan,’ and then he became Twan Baker, because he was the Baker’s child. It was really just a joke to start,” the actress said.

A persistent myth is that Twan’s adventures began when he was kidnapped from Pittsburgh, but those in the know say no way. “Brynn came to me and asked if she could take him and I said, ‘Of course,’ because he was family,” Ms. Meek said.

Mr. Foster and his wife, Jen Cody, who played Red Riding Hood for CLO, took custody for a trip to New England, where Mr. Foster continued to post pictures with Twan, and Ms. Cody got him a part in “All Shook Up.” Then Ms. O’Malley began a monthlong “Into the Woods” at Kansas City Rep, where “they handed me an awful prop baby.” She called for Twan, and he has worked steadily ever since, including a return to CLO for “Fiddler on the Roof” in 2012.

“It’s pretty amazing the amount of attention he’s been getting, but it’s exactly what we always wanted,” Ms. O’Malley said. “We get a little aggressive about putting him in things, and I got lucky when I came to Signature that they already knew all about him and they were like, ‘We absolutely want to use him.’”

Advertise with us

There have been some scary moments in the five years Twan has been hard at work. After “Annie” on Broadway, he was booked to move down the street, to appear with Mr. Foster in “The Bridges of Madison County.” Instead, the Baker baby was accidentally shipped to a warehouse. Ms. O’Malley credits “stepmother” Cody with his safe return. “She went on a Twitter war, she sent out Amber Alerts, and eventually they got him back just in time.”

The lesson learned was transfers are now handled by the actors, but Mother Baker would make an exception if another call came from Karen Meek.

“ ‘Into the Woods’ was a magical production,” Ms. Meek said. “I think it’s hilarious and wonderful that Twan has become this inside Broadway joke and has more famous friends than God, and it all started at Pittsburgh CLO.”