Stephen Schwartz may have composed and written the lyrics for “Godspell,” but he attributes much of the show’s lasting success to the “genius” of playwright John-Michael Tebelak.
After all, “Godspell” originated as Tebelak’s master’s thesis at Carnegie Mellon University. Schwartz, a 1968 CMU graduate, was brought on to write the music and lyrics. The show is structured as a series of parables, and Schwartz used lyrics from hymns in many of the songs. More importantly, he used the humor in Tebelak’s parables as inspiration for those equally joyous musical numbers.
Godspell Rehearsal
“It was both celebrating and disseminating the basic lessons in an extremely comic and entertaining way,” Schwartz told the Post-Gazette.
“Godspell” made its New York City debut in 1971 and has since become a staple of regional theater nationwide. On Tuesday, Pittsburgh CLO will debut a 50th-anniversary production of “Godspell” that will run through Sunday at Downtown’s Benedum Center. Tickets are $29-$85 via pittsburghclo.culturaldistrict.org. Yes, 2021 was technically its 50th anniversary, so blame the COVID-19 pandemic for forcing Pittsburgh CLO to wait a year.
“’Godspell’ is an iconic musical that for many people is locked in the culture and fashion of the 1970s, and while some of that sensibility is an intrinsic part of the show, we asked ourselves: What makes ‘Godspell’ relevant and compelling for today’s Pittsburgh audience?” Pittsburgh CLO executive producer Mark Fleischer said in a statement to the Post-Gazette.
“This creative team has answered that call with imagination ... while remaining centered on a message of the power of love — which we all can embrace."
Read More

This production will be directed by Gabriel Barre, who has decades of both Broadway and local theater experience. Barre has known Schwartz since his time in the original 1986 Broadway cast of “Rags,” another show that Schwartz wrote the lyrics for. Schwartz’s son, Scott, once served as Barre’s assistant. Barre described the “Wicked” composer and lyricist as “an accessible and warm person” who was happy to have his brain picked on how to best do “Godspell.”
Unlike many musicals, “Godspell” doesn’t require a big set, lavish costumes or expansive cast. There are only 12 actors in the ensemble, and Barre’s version will have “the city itself influence the physical production,” he said. The action will take place on an abandoned Pittsburgh playground. Barre also said that a “high percentage of the cast” are actor-musicians, and many will play their own instruments on stage.
His “Godspell” will be “revisiting the show through a 2022 lens,” and Barre thinks anyone will be able to enjoy it regardless of their familiarity with previous versions.
“You don’t have to be Christian to appreciate the show in any way,” he said. “Ultimately, it all distills down to, ‘Do unto others.’ ... If people simply followed that advice, the world would be a different place. There hasn’t been a time since the show was written when that message didn’t need to be heard.”
The cast includes multiple current Carnegie Mellon students, including Susana Cordon, a 20-year-old rising junior from Durango, Colo., who will also appear in the CLO’s “Sister Act” later this summer. All the characters in this “Godspell” are nameless players, and Cordon will be portraying “Player 10,” whom she described as an observer in this disparate bunch “coming together to feel a little less alone.” She’ll also be playing guitar and ukulele during the show.
Community is a big theme in “Godspell.” There will be a bit of audience participation, which Cordon recognizes isn’t always fun for those who just want to sit back and enjoy a show. She promises, though, that it’s crucial for the overall “Godspell” experience.
“I think it does it in such a fun, playful way where it breaks that fourth wall,” she said. “It brings that comfort level of, we are not above you, literally or figuratively. ... I think it casualizes it and is like an invitation for the audience to be loud, cry and hang out with us for the next two hours.”

Steven Taylor Jr., a 20-year-old New York City native and rising senior at CMU, will play the role of “Player Four.” He agreed with Cordon that watching “Godspell” is “not the same as going to a Sunday service where you’re being taught,” which is what makes the audience engagement so significant.
His father was an actor, and Taylor grew up seeing photos of him as Jesus Christ in a regional production of “Godspell.” He appreciates that the broadness of how the musical was initially designed makes room for some “very unique interpretations,” and he thinks this one will be no different.
“We as humans and Americans, specifically in Pittsburgh, have the opportunity and challenge of redefining community for ourselves,” he said. “I think ‘Godspell’ is something that tackles that.”
Schwartz credited the show’s “improvisation and contemporary cultural references” as part of the reason for why it’s still fresh. Though he’s busy creating “new and revised” songs for not one, but two “Wicked” movies, Schwartz hopes he can make it back to Pittsburgh for this 50th anniversary “Godspell” production.
“Given the personnel putting it on, I’m expecting it be a really first-rate production that’s funny, entertaining and moving,” he said. “It never hurts for us to be reminded of the lessons from time to time, especially given the society we live in, how divided we are.
“‘Godspell’ is about the opposite of that. If it can do a little teeny bit to heal some wounds or encourage people to do so, that would be a good thing.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.