It’s been less than a week since the national tour of “Hamilton” finished its Benedum Center engagement. On Friday, a different sort of historical musical will be taking its place.
“Beautiful: The Carole King Musical” is set to bring its latest national tour to the Benedum Friday through Sunday. The show chronicles the early life and career of Carole King, who rose to prominence writing hit songs for other artists before taking the music world by storm with her 1971 album “Tapestry.”
It features performances of many songs she was at least partially responsible for and also portrays the tumultuous relationship between King and Gerry Goffin, her first husband and onetime songwriting partner. Sara Sheperd, a utility player on the original Broadway production of “Beautiful,” is taking center stage on the national tour as the show’s main figure.
“Every time you step into the part, you’re stepping into a well-oiled machine ...,” Sheperd, 36, told the Post-Gazette. “To be able to step into her shoes eight times a week is the coolest thing ever. It’s a full-circle moment.”
Sheperd is a Toledo, Ohio, native whose path to a musical theater career began at age 5 when she started participating in shows put on by Toledo Repertoire Theatre. Her mother is from Pittsburgh, and Sheperd said she would often visit the Steel City as a kid to visit her grandmother.
After attending the University of Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music for musical theater, Sheperd moved to New York City and three weeks later booked her first Broadway gig in the ensemble of “Cry-Baby: The Musical.” That show closed quickly, but Sheperd soon found her way onto the national tour of “Legally Blonde: The Musical.”
Read More
After a brief professional lull, she joined the Broadway production of “Beautiful” as a swing, dance captain, and understudy for the roles of King and her mother, Genie. She spent about six years with “Beautiful” on Broadway from its earliest stages until it closed in October 2019. When the COVID-19 pandemic hit in March 2020, Sheperd took a step back and allowed herself to relax for a bit.
“It was just nice to chill out for a second,” she said. “Eight shows a week for six years is a long time missing family and holidays and all that.”
It didn’t take much convincing for Sheperd to accept the opportunity to play King on the national “Beautiful” tour that kicked off in November. Although much of the tour took place while omicron variant cases were spiking, Sheperd said she’s felt safe and like her company, she was taking COVID-19 safety seriously. There have been the occasional positive tests, but so far the tour has only had to cancel one show because of COVID-19, Sheperd said.
Despite being immersed in “Beautiful” for most of the last decade, Sheperd has yet to get sick of constantly hearing King’s songs. She was familiar with King’s work but didn’t realize just how many songwriting credits she had amassed before breaking out as a solo artist with “Tapestry.” For example, she had no idea before joining “Beautiful” that King and Goffin co-wrote the 1962 hit “The Loco-Motion.”
“They’re the most joyous songs,” Sheperd said. “It’s amazing to listen to and be able to sing every night. ... The more I get to perform them every night and I hear those lyrics, they sort of hit differently and even a little harder.”
At this point, Sheperd has learned that she must maintain “a little bit of a disconnect” while on stage to avoid feeling any extra pressure while performing such famous and beloved songs. That allows her to concentrate on playing King’s journey from a wide-eyed 16-year-old to a renowned artist. It’s “an actor’s dream to get to go on a full arc like that,” Sheperd said.
Nobody ever asked Sheperd to imitate how King sounded, which made the prospect of playing someone so accomplished feel less daunting. That allowed her to focus on playing King as a fully formed character who experienced plenty of highs and lows on her way to musical superstardom.
“I love leaning into her power when she can finally find her voice and the idea that she can triumph out of something so sad,” Shepherd said. “That aspect of her really makes me tick.”
This weekend will mark Sheperd’s first time performing at the Benedum. She’s gotten a kick out of audiences at other tour stops showing their enthusiasm for their favorite songs in the form of, say, applauding the second they hear the first note of classics like “It’s Too Late.”
Those spontaneous reactions make Sheperd feel like “we’re having this collective moment together,” and she hopes to inspire even more of them at the Benedum.
“Even if you don’t think you know Carole King’s music, I guarantee you probably do,” she said. “And if you don’t, regardless, you’ll walk out as a fan. ... If you want to feel some joy, come to this show.”
Tickets for “Beautiful” are currently on sale for $33-$110 via trustarts.org. The Pittsburgh Cultural Trust is still requiring that everyone over 2 years of age stays masked while inside any of its venues. Anyone attending Cultural Trust performances must also show proof of COVID-19 vaccination or a negative test along with a current photo ID upon entry.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.