I saw “A Bronx Tale” on Broadway in 2016, and it felt like the most New York thing to do for two friends from Brooklyn who grew up Yankees fans (I can hear the boos from here). We loved it — the story that we knew from the movie, woven into a musical featuring Alan Menken music and Sergio Trujillo choreography..

When the show failed to get any Tony Awards recognition, despite enthusiastic reviews, it continued on Broadway for more than a year. This “Bronx Tale,” I thought, will travel well when it heads out on tour.

‘A Bronx Tale’

Where: PNC Broadway in Pittsburgh at the Benedum Center, Downtown.

Advertise with us

When: 7:30 p.m. Thursday, 8 p.m. Friday, 2 and 8 p.m. Saturday and 1 and 6:30 p.m. Sunday.

Tickets: $33-$115, https://trustarts.org/production/63007/a-bronx-tale, 412-456-6666.

Fast forward to present day, and “A Bronx Tale” has arrived in Pittsburgh. The production at the Benedum Center doesn’t quite match the fond memories of that first time around, but it does deliver on the promise of a familiar story elevated into an entertaining musical by an all-star creative team.

The polished book by Chazz Palminteri comes from the actor-writer’s autobiographical one-man show and the movie that he starred in with Robert De Niro (the latter gets co-directing credits with multi-Tony winner Jerry Zaks). You can’t help but think “Jersey Boys” as the show starts out with a group of young men doo-wopping alongside a street lamp and under the sign for Belmont Avenue. And, with Menken involved, the opening also echoes his “Little Shop of Horrors,” with a narrated song-and-dance musical journey through the Italian neighborhood of protagonist Calogero’s youth.

Even if you are unfamiliar with the film, “A Bronx Tale” may still seem like something you’ve seen before: Belmont Avenue is the domain of feared and revered mobster Sonny (shades of “The Sopranos”), who takes “C,” as he calls 9-year-old Calogero, under his wing (“Goodfellas,” anyone?). C.’s father, Lorenzo, a bus driver, finds himself in a tug-of-war for his son’s future, struggling uphill as C is seduced by the charismatic Sonny, and the wealth and power he wields.

Advertise with us

A theme that runs throughout is Lorenzo’s creed: “The worst crime is wasted talent.”

The first act moves swiftly through all of these themes, but nothing matches that opening number, where we feel the pulse of the street through music and dance, and the tag team of Alec Nevin as teenage Calogero and Trey Murphy as his baseball-loving child self.

Jeff Brooks’ Sonny has all the goods as a mob boss who rules with an iron fist but has a soft spot for the kid. The song “Nicky Machiavelli,” in which Sonny declares, “It ain't about love. It's fear,” is all you need to know about how he deals with anyone who crosses him. Lorenzo (2015 “American Idol” winner Nick Fradiani, in his first musical theater role), is all about love — and he finds himself losing the battle for his son’s heart.

Roiling to a boil are prejudices over boundaries, with the Italian kids locked in a Jets. vs. Sharks territorial battle against their black Webster Avenue neighbors.

With racism and reason working against them, Calogero and his black classmate, Jane (Kayla Johnson), can’t keep their eyes off each other. The Webster Avenue teens are introduced in a second-act opener that will remind people why Trujillo finally won a Tony this year (for The Temptations musical “Ain’t Too Proud”), but that momentum drops off considerably until Sonny shows his support for C in the most memorable tune by Menken and lyricist Glenn Slater. “One of the Great Ones” is my current earworm, in a good way, and the number includes one of the great pieces of advice, from Sonny to C, about whether Jane is, indeed, one of the greats.

Advertise with us

Jane passing the test gets a big reaction from the audience, but not as big as an early scene that drew cheers from the Pittsburgh audience — young C crying when Bill Mazeroski’s home run beats the Yankees for the World Series crown in 1960. Baseball is a thread throughout “A Bronx Tale,” from father-son games of catch to Mickey Mantle’s big salary to bats used for purposes other than the game.

The urban sets by Beowulf Boritt evoke urban living for people whose lives are lived out on stoops and fire escapes and street corners. It’s a busy cityscape that burns with red brick and wiseguys who say “deez” and “doez” a lot and who have names like Eddie Mush, JoJo the Whale, Rudy the Voice and Frankie Coffeecake.

The show takes some twists and turns as Calogero tries to date Jane and the racial tensions reach a breaking point among their families and friends. If you saw the movie, you know what’s next, but if not, you may have a shock or two waiting.

In the struggle for C’s future, this part, at least, we know — Palminteri is an Oscar-nominated actor and award-winning writer who has not wasted his talent.

Sign up for the PG performing arts newsletter Behind the Curtain at Newsletter Preferences.