When the lights go down and the curtain comes up, there’s a moment of dread among traditional theatergoers. How long before a glaring screen or blaring ringtone takes the spotlight away from the stage and brings the magical Fourth Wall tumbling down?
In an age when more people worldwide own cell phones than toothbrushes, according to Forbes.com, some of us have surrendered to the inevitable disruptions. Others are finding innovative ways to maintain control over the artistic experience and keep disruptions to a minimum.
Now imagine you arrive at a live theatrical performance and you’re handed a cell phone.…
Yes, that happened at “Project Amelia,” a Bricolage production in a theater of the immersive kind. Since smartphones were integral to experience, participants were given smartphones and allowed to hold onto their own phones.
The devices were slipped into pouches created by the company Yondr. The design locks out the user but does not block incoming texts and calls. The idea is to “help you turn off your phone and tune into life,” the company says. A Bricolage team member was always in position to unlock the pouch should a patron leave the experience and need to use the phone.
Bricolage had considered using a downloadable app for its original story about a groundbreaking artificial intelligence, but decided that an app would still allow use of those pesky personal devices.
“The idea was it would block any cell phone usage during the show and it would still allow them to see if there was a call coming in. But to use it, they would have to go get it unlocked,” said Bricolage principal creative and co-founder Tami Dixon.
The tech also avoided complaints she and others have heard before: “’What if it's the babysitter?' 'What if it's an emergency?' 'I'm a doctor ...' [The Yondr pouch] allows for that. It just doesn't allow you to randomly use your phone,” Dixon said.
Yondr has had its moments on Broadway recently. In September, in a story titled “Theaters’ New Way to Silence Cellphones: Lock Them Up,” the Wall Street Journal reported the use of the pouches at Lin-Manuel Miranda’s “Freestyle Love Supreme,” a show that combines improv and hip-hop, and during Dave Chappelle’s limited Broadway run earlier this year.
Chappelle’s anti-device stance can be traced to a rough night in Hartford, Conn. For a 2013 comedy tour stop at First Niagara Pavilion in Burgettstown, the famously fragile comedian had signs posted throughout the arena that read: “No cellphones, texting, tweeting, heckling, talking, cameras, recording devices of any kind during the show. Violators will be ejected. Thank you for your cooperation."
That was before Yondr came on the scene. Actor Donald Glover, who sings as Childish Gambino, has used the tech at his concerts. “I wanted to give people an experience,” he is quoted on the company's website. “I think telling people to put their phones away really forces a person to be present.”
Art interrupted
Cell phone use in theaters is one of those first world problems that may seem trivial — unless you have spent hundreds of dollars to see a much anticipated performance, and the person with a screen addiction is directly in your sight line.
The big three issues of cell phone interruptions at live performances are:
• Artists’ rights.
• Distractions to performers and fellow patrons.
• Acceptance at other performance venues, particularly by younger people.
From artists’ perspective, it’s not just about the rights to their work, which can be pirated for sale or posted online for all to see. There also are elements of control in delivering a peak performance.
“Because immersive experiences are highly curated, we look at every aspect of how we engage our audience. From point of sale to their survey, we wanted to have a clear framework that is was in our hands,” Bricolage’s Dixon said.
For its more traditional offerings, such as “Midnight Radio” shows, Bricolage simply asks patrons to put away their cell phones. “But people who can't be away from their phone for 90 minutes ... are going to be panicked, and they're not going to have a good time anyway.”
.@joshuahenry20 joined the fight against phones in the theatre at last night's performance of @TheWrongMan. https://t.co/Smme6PIVpG
— BroadwayWorld (@BroadwayWorld) October 2, 2019
Dixon said Bricolage “hasn’t experienced anyone being blatantly rude or obnoxious. You pay money to come and see a show. We hope that your attention will be on the product that we are creating for the audience.”
Etiquette for everyone
A few high-profile incidents this year have kept cell phone usage in theater in the spotlight.
Proof that celebrities are not like the rest of us came when “Slave Play” playwright Jeremy O. Harris defended pop star Rihanna for walking in late — the start was held for her arrival — and texting him during a preview of the Broadway show.
While the singer was roundly criticized on social media, Harris wrote on Twitter that her music was his muse.
“The patron saint of the play I wrote is literally a pop star, fashion icon and Demi-goddess named Rihanna. Her words are all over it. She’s a ninth character in the play. When Dionysus is coming, you hold the curtain.”
However, at a Sunday matinee of “Slave Play” earlier this month, ushers shined flashlights on people with their phones still on minutes before the play began, asking them to put them away.
Another publicized case occurred Sept. 28 in Cincinnati, when one patron took matters to an extreme.
Violinist Anne-Sophie Mutter, appearing with the Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra, stopped her performance to confront an audience member in the front row who was using a cell phone to record the concert. The patron continued to record until an orchestra official had her escorted out.
The Cincinnati orchestra’s rules of cell-phone use, according to cincinnati.com, state phones are allowed during performances but must be on silent. “Non-flash photography is encouraged during moments of applause, but audio and video recording are not allowed.”
Mutter later told The New York Times that she was distracted to the point of being “totally out of the flow.”
“I feel violated in my rights, of my artistic property,” she added.
The Heinz Hall policy on cell phones may vary with the performers or the performance. “in general, the use of still, video and digital cameras or audio recording equipment is prohibited at all times in the concert hall,” said Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra spokeswoman Julie Goetz. “This policy is meant to enhance the experience of the audience and performers, as well as adhere to copyrights.”
The PNC Pops series has a “relaxed” photo policy, for which audience members are permitted to have cell phones on during a performance in order to take photos. At the MGC Classic series, audience members are asked to turn off and silence their cell phones during the performance, although some classical music performances (such as the RADical Days concert) have relaxed photo policies. Visiting artists may allow and even encourage tweeting, with hashtag suggestions flashed on video screens.
There are no new policies added by the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust regarding cell phones, and Yondr bags or similar products have been used only when a tour brings them to a Trust venue.
“What has changed over the last year is that our screening can detect laptops, so we’ve been enforcing that as a prohibited item,” said trust spokeswoman Robin Elrod. She suggested a look at TrustArts.org/Safety as a reference for all prohibited items.
Tech technicalities
The locked pouch system of keeping phones silent has limitations. For one thing, it’s up to the patron to put it on silent before locking it up.
Fred Frances, Bricolage’s audience and box office manager, noted that, “There were a few people who, for reasons of accessibility, were allowed to keep their phones.… People who use their phones to boost their hearing through ear pods, we let people use their phones for those type of reasons.”
The Downtown company has experimented with “tweet seats” — back rows where people could tweet to their hearts’ content — in their more traditional black-box space on Liberty Avenue. The Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra was one of the earliest adopters of tweet seats from which patrons can carry on what organizers called “digital conversations.”
The orchestra abandoned the practice when they found that their audience was not particularly engaged on Twitter.
Dixon declared the use of Yondr pouches, for the immersive experience, a success.
“A lot of times in the past we have used lockers … but people are always very resistant about their phones. They’ll say, ‘Yeah, take my keys, take my wallet, but not my phone!’”
The tech also avoided another potential problem for distracted patrons.
“It was an environment with a concrete floor,” Frances said, “so it kept a lot of screens from being broken.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.