Local theatergoers have eagerly awaited the Broadway musical “Hamilton,” which runs at the Benedum Center through Jan. 27.

But the last time Alexander Hamilton visited Western Pennsylvania, frontier farmers despised him so much that he needed a six-man security detail on horseback when he rode out of  Pittsburgh in November 1794. Hamilton aroused the locals’ ire by creating the federal excise tax on whiskey, prompting the violent Whiskey Rebellion. The young nation needed revenue to pay off debts incurred during the American Revolution.

In Western Pennsylvania and many other states, farmers turned excess barley, corn and rye into whiskey that they drank, sold at a profit and even used to barter for other goods. Many farmers refused outright to pay the tax; some tax collectors were tarred and feathered or became the literal target of gun-toting militants.

Congress approved the whiskey tax in 1791 but Hamilton lobbied for it a year earlier in a 1790 report. He wrote, “The consumption of ardent spirits ... is carried to an extreme. Should the increase of duties tend to a decrease of the consumption ... the effect would be, in every respect desirable.”

Advertise with us

Richard Bell, an associate professor of history at the University of Maryland, talks about Alexander Hamilton and and the touring Broadway musical the founding father’’s life inspired in a talk titled “Hamilton Remix: History Meets Show Biz.” The historian speaks at 7 p.m. Jan. 10 in the Heinz History Center in the Strip District.

The Broadway show succeeds on many levels, Mr. Bell said.

“I love the fact that audiences have embraced this show. I think it’s a masterpiece and great work of art. Even though I have pointed and critical questions to raise, I am not trying to dump on this musical,” he said.

Lin Manuel-Miranda, the show’s creator, tackled a monumental task by turning Ron Chernow’s 700-page biography about a complicated man into a three-hour show, the historian said.

“The show gets a lot of things right and not just simple stuff like names and dates. How Congress works, how presidents were elected before the 12th Amendment and why congressmen kept dueling in this period,” Mr. Bell said.

Advertise with us

The musical, Mr. Bell added, “covers a massive amount of ground. It continues past the American Revolution” and explains how America got a constitution.

But the musical also misses some chances to be more nuanced, Mr. Bell said.

The show casts the American Revolution as “a simplistic struggle between good guys and bad guys. I would say that even if I didn’t have a British accent,” said Mr. Bell, who was born in London.

In the show, loyalists to King George III are portrayed as “stuck up, conservative, stupid and wrong,” Mr. Bell said. In 1776, he added, the year Congress signed the Declaration of Independence, about one-third of American colonists wanted to break away from England, another third were loyal to the British crown and another third were neutral or undecided.

The musical leaves audiences with the impression that there was no alternative to independence.

Advertise with us

“It is very odd to suggest that 13 little colonies on the other side of the ocean can somehow thrive as an independent country against the only superpower in the world,” Mr. Bell said.

The musical’s characterization of women, Mr. Bell said, “is very narrow, focusing only on a few elite women and painting them as if they had feminist leanings.” Elizabeth Schuyler, who married Alexander Hamilton in 1780, and her sisters “lived in a gilded cage.” A better example of an 18th century feminist, he added, would be Abigail Adams.

Alexander Hamilton is shown as an immigrant who pulled himself up by his boot straps, Mr. Bell said, but “his politics are more complicated than that back story suggests.”

In fact, the historian said, Hamilton “devoted much of his adult life to putting obstacles in the way of immigrants. The financial system he brings into being during [President George] Washington’s administration succeeds in putting structural economic inequality at the center of the American economy. The rich get richer under Hamilton’s financial system. It becomes harder for people on the bottom rungs of the economic ladder to claw their way up.”

President John Adams persuaded Congress to pass the Alien and Sedition Act of 1798, with the goal of silencing Irish immigrants, who were his harsh critics.

Advertise with us

Hamilton supported that law, Mr. Bell said, and suggested “that people who don’t pledge loyalty to the president should be deported.”

Thomas Jefferson, Hamilton’s political polar opposite, opposed the Alien and Sedition Act and that was one reason why he was elected president in 1800.

The Broadway cast of Hamilton is multi-ethnic and multi-racial but, Mr. Bell said, “It also obscures the fact that there are no black characters in the show.”

Many of the show’s characters — Washington, Madison, Jefferson and Elizabeth Schuyler — had slaves.

“It would arguably be an even more interesting musical if it put enslaved black people in dialogue with the singing and dancing slave holders we see up on stage,” Mr. Bell said.

Advertise with us

The Heinz History lecture is $18 for adults and $9 for visitors age 17 and under; the fee includes admission to all museum exhibits.

Marylynne Pitz at mpitz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1648 or on Twitter:@mpitzpg