After nearly three decades, Dark Star Orchestra has become something few tribute bands ever achieve: not just a re-creation of the original band experience, but a living extension of it.
With the passing of Bob Weir in January, the Chicago-based band now stands among the top stewards of the Grateful Dead catalog with Joe Russo's Almost Dead (JRAD) the only other one that’s close.
Dark Star began on Nov. 11, 1997, two months after the death of Jerry Garcia and six months before Weir and the other Dead survivors launched the first post-Garcia spinoff band, The Other Ones.
What set DSO apart from other Dead tribute bands — and there were far fewer at the time — was its practice of re-creating full Grateful Dead concert sets.
Its rise has been gradual and steady. The band first came to Pittsburgh in 1999 to play Graffiti, the 500-person capacity Oakland club. Over the years the crowds have grown as DSO has hit the Station Square Amphitheatre, Mr. Smalls and Stage AE indoors, where it returns Thursday for its ninth straight appearance.
The only member remaining from the original 1997 lineup is singer Lisa Mackey, who handles the Donna Jean Godchaux parts.
Keyboardist Rob Barraco joined the band in 2005, bringing his experience of stints with Phil Lesh & Friends, The Other Ones and Chris Robinson’s New Earth Mud. That same year, Dark Star Orchestra added guitarist Jeff Mattson, who had also played with Phil Lesh & Friends and with Barraco in the long-running Dead tribute band Zen Tricksters.
Barraco joined DSO full time in 2007, the same year he released the solo album “When We All Come Home,” which featured seven songs co-written with Grateful Dead lyricist Robert Hunter.
In a recent phone interview from Boston Logan International Airport, Barraco talked about possibly revisiting those songs with his other band, Skeleton Krewe.
He also discussed the DSO’s process of archiving and varying setlists. On the last trip to Pittsburgh, in 2024, DSO played the Dead’s show from Aug. 30, 1978. The time before that must have been a grab bag because DSO encored with “Love the One You’re With,” which the Dead only played once, in 1983, and the rest of the set does not match that show.
What are you expecting this tour to be like?
Well, kind of like any other tour we're doing. I am endlessly on tour. I just got off tour with my other band, Skeleton Krewe, and so I'm going right back on tour. I had two days home. I expect that we're going to have really large crowds. Since Bob passed away, it seems people are really coming out. They need the music and the healing and as we do, too.
Where were you guys when that news came about?
I was home when it happened. We were supposed to be in Jamaica but canceled because of the hurricane.
It was a Saturday night. How did the news hit you?
I was sitting at the table just about to eat dinner, and I just happened to open my phone and saw it. And I looked at my girlfriend, I was like, “I think Weir just passed away.” So I started to look further, and sure enough .... I had no idea he was that ill. They kept it very quiet.
Did anyone know that he was ill at all?
People knew. There was a lot of chatter, because he didn't look very well, and so there were a lot of rumors, but I never heard any official anything. [In Skeleton Krewe], I play with Jay Lane, who's the drummer in Dead & Company, and I asked him, “Hey, what's up with Bob?” He’s like, “He's nothing, as far as I know.” But that was the company line, you know. They tried to keep it quiet.
You spent a lot of time with him. What was it like being on stage with him?
Oh, it was fantastic, man. Like Phil, really big ears, excellent at having the musical conversation, being in the moment. He was great at it and generated some gorgeous playing. I mean, he was inspirational, and he was just generally a really nice guy and a real trickster. He was a jokester, for sure. But yeah, I loved Bob. He was great and always gracious any time I saw him.
So the community is definitely hurting in a big way...
Yeah, there's no doubt. I mean, I think people are looking at it like, “Wow, all the principals, the whole front line of the Dead is gone.” I mean, even include Donna in that, who passed away last year. So I think people are grieving that, but, you know, the thing about this community is, as far as I can see, it's in perpetuity, man. This thing is going to go on and on. The music is going to live no matter who plays it. I mean, how many Grateful Dead cover bands are there in this country? There's hundreds and hundreds, and people go and dance and have a great time and it's all about the music.
I remember talking to Phil after Jerry died and he said, “This is repertoire.”
Right. His exact quote is, he always told me, “This is repertory.” Repertory is exactly that, it's music. It's music that's going to be around, you know, Bob says 300 years. Who knows? 1,000 years. Who knows? But you know, I'm really happy that Dark Star is keeping that alive, especially the way we do it.
How does this feel for you guys now, being the leading group in this community?
So some people have told me. I mean, JRad’s around and there are other bands, but we've been at it for so long. Next year's gonna be our 30th year. I've been in the band going on 21 years, and it feels really good to be part of the community and to generate that healing. I've always thought that music is a healing force and I feel really privileged to be part of that.
I noticed that Brit Floyd went from playing clubs to theaters to now playing arenas. There's probably going to be a Grateful Dead tribute band that's going to do that.
Right now, our comfort zone … we just sold out two nights at the Fox Theater in Oakland, a gorgeous place that holds around 3,000 people. We almost sold out the Greek Theatre in Berkeley, which holds close to 8,000 and we sold out Red Rocks, which has close to 10,000. Our sound engineer, Carter Michaels, always said, “You guys are gonna play Madison Square Garden.” And we'd always laugh, you know, “Yeah, right, right, right,” but, you know what? It’s not out of the realm of possibility.
How does the process work for you guys playing the full sets?
So the way it works is one of our drummers, Dino English, he has an amazing database. So he'll start with one particular town on the tour, let's say it's Pittsburgh, and he'll see what we played the last couple of times we were there — maybe the last three times — and determine that we have to do a particular show.
So maybe the last time we were there, maybe we played an ’82 show, so this time he’ll pick a ’77 show. This is hypothetical. So now we have that setlist for the ’77 show, and then he works front and back, forward and backwards, for the whole tour to see what each of these towns has. And then — this is the arduous part of it — he has to make sure that we are not repeating the same songs night after night, to keep it fresh for us, and that each place we're playing gets something different.
So we have two formats. We do a show format where we re-create a show from a particular era. Now, what does that mean? It means we set our gear up exactly the way they did. We have the sounds they had. We know exactly what that sound sounds like, but we improvise every note. Our version of the show and their version of the show are two completely different things. We take ourselves on a journey and, in turn, we take the audience on a journey, and that's how it works.
And then some nights we do what we call an elective set. Let's say the last three times we were in a city we played shows, well, it's time for an elective. Elective means we make up our own setlist, and then that's where the fun really is, because we get to juxtapose different years together, like I might do a Pigpen tune in the first set and a Brent [Mydland] tune in the second set, or vice versa, stuff like that. They’re real fun because you can put together jams of stuff that the Dead never did and, if they did, it would have worked — or not. You never know.
You're not playing note by note, but if you pick a ’77 show, you're playing in that mindset of that year?
Exactly. It would be no fun to try to play it note for note. It would also be impossible
Brit Floyd can do that because Pink Floyd was true to their studio versions.
Yes, exactly. The Dead never played the song the same way, twice — ever. That's why it's so cool that we can do this because we're not doing it exactly the style they did it.
Do you have a particular era that you get most excited to play?
Oh yeah, ’72 to ’74, especially fall of ’72. That's my favorite era, right there. Those shows are deep. They're speaking another language. Even though they were starting to play hockey arenas and stuff, it was still a small setup. In ’73, they start building the wall of sound, slowly, and so things became more massive as time went on. And by ’74, of course, they had the wall of sound, which is a gigantic, ridiculous sound system, which I got to see a couple of times, which was pretty cool.
The sound that they had by the fall of ’72 was pretty much like what they sounded like in Europe but with an expanded vocabulary. They had some new songs, and their playing as a unit was just getting more and more advanced and trippy,
Because the Europe ’72 was from earlier in the year, right?
Right, and they had to make the adjustment without Pigpen, because he had to retire, basically, and then he died the following year. So their sound changed, and they had to fill that void. And they did it in a pretty profound way.
When did you first see them?
My first show was 3/28/72 — very last show they played in New York before they went to Europe. I was a kid.
So that might also explain why you feel more attached to that year as well.
Yeah, sorta, in some ways a little bit nostalgic, but also as a musician, and when I listen to the overall catalog, I find that that speaks to me more — the one drummer thing, especially, because being a jazz-trained musician, playing with one drummer, you can turn on a dime. It's not that easy when you have two drummers, so you can go to some more exotic places when you do it that way.
You were a musician when you first saw them?
Yeah, I've been a musician my entire life. I started playing guitar when I was 6, switched to keyboards at 11, and I got it right away, man, especially when I saw them. That's when it would hit me, because they're playing the songs from the record — take a song like “Cumberland Blues.” I'm like, “Wait a minute, this is completely different.” And then, of course, once we started getting bootlegs and you could hear different versions of the same tune, you’d be like, “Oh my god, every one is different!” That’s mind-blowing, that realization.
Just to circle back real quick, did the Grateful Dead do that kind of research in terms of not repeating songs in a city?
No, not at all. They just went out there every night and did what they did. And they were constantly evolving, so, you know, year after year they would come back to a place, they would sound different.
Do you expect John Mayer to continue on with this somehow?
I have no idea. I would think he would, but who knows? I heard these rumors about Dead Forever, but I think they're just rumors at this point. But it wouldn't surprise me if he did.
I think an annual celebration would be good.
I think so, too.
I don’t know if he’s the guy to carry them.
I don’t either, but, look, people love him, and that accounts for something. There's no doubt he's a true musician. And you know, he does it his way, which works on some level.
I read that you had written some songs with Robert Hunter that you were looking to record.
Yeah, The Skeleton Krewe, we do all that Robert Hunter stuff that I wrote, and I want to record all of it with them because it’s closer to what I had imagined when I wrote the songs. I used studio musicians when I did the CD with all these songs and even though it came out fabulously well, this band gets closer to the ideal for me, so we're actually planning on doing some recording this spring.
Is there anything else you wanted to say?
I would just say we’re looking forward to this show, and we’ll play our hearts out. We always do.
The show is at 7:30 p.m. Thursday at Stage AE, North Shore. Tickets are $48; axs.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.