I don’t look to the Pittsburgh Symphony as a bellwether of the city’s arts health out of any sort of preference for Stravinsky over Sondheim or Shakespeare.
It’s because it’s the flagship performing arts organization in the city, albeit with a couple of caveats.
At $34.6 million, the symphony has the largest budget of any performing arts organization.
It’s true that the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust is a larger organization with about a $64 million budget, but it does not hire local talent to produce its shows — it presents touring Broadway productions and other shows from around the country and the world.
The symphony pays its own players, all of whom become honorary Yinzers over the years.
The symphony also has the strongest artistic reputation of these organizations. Its European tours can be thought of as a kind of benchmark for other large American orchestras, and there are numerous professionals who compare the PSO favorably to better-resourced ensembles. I’ve done it myself after attending orchestra concerts in Philadelphia and Cleveland, for example.
That’s a lot of preamble to say that what happens at the symphony matters to the vitality of Pittsburgh’s performing arts, and a recent announcement of the symphony trumpeting “healthy financial results” and a surplus of $2.3 million offers a glimpse into its financial health.
I’ve long argued that an orchestra’s finances directly impact its artistic ability and prestige. Budget determines salaries, and salaries are still the largest single factor in determining what caliber of talent an orchestra is able to attract.
So let’s break it down.
Financial crescendo
The first thing to know is that the symphony’s fiscal year tracks with its performance season, which runs from Sept. 1 to Aug. 31.
All nonprofits are required by law to post audited financial documents; the PSO’s press release represents an effort to get the good news out and also shape the narrative by releasing information early.
The next thing to know is that nonprofit performing arts have always been subsidized to one degree or another throughout history. Ticket revenue covers only a fraction of the cost of putting on art. The rest is made up by donations and a little bit of public funding.
The symphony’s news is good, but let’s not get carried away. The $2.3 million surplus, for example, is attributed to special, one-time fundraising initiatives and strong ticket revenue.
Like Pittsburgh Ballet Theatre, which the Post-Gazette also analyzed recently, the symphony is experiencing a small incremental growth in the percentage of its budget covered by ticket sales, from 22.2% in 2024 to 23.5% in the fiscal year that ended in August.
The remainder was covered by 52.8% donations and 23.6% in endowment draw and other investment income.
That’s a key stat because it means the symphony is relying less on donations.
Additionally, the symphony’s announcement proclaims that ticket revenue has reached its highest levels since before the COVID-19 pandemic.
Ticket revenue for the previous season was $9.48 million, a 17% increase over the fiscal year that ended in 2024.
Total attendance also grew by about 5% year over year, bringing total paid admission to orchestra concerts to a little more than 165,000. Many of these were first-time purchasers. The number of concerts the orchestra performs is about the same as in the pre-pandemic seasons.
This is all in addition, of course, to the numerous fine performances by the musicians themselves, which can get lost in discussions of the budgeting and equations of the performing arts business.
A couple of key musician appointments in the violins and winds have the orchestra sounding in excellent form, lately, at least to my ears, and right before they are set to test their mettle in Carnegie Hall in New York City in December.
Between the lines
Breaking down these financial figures, however, reveals some nuances that wilt a little of the rosiness of this announcement.
Here’s the key: Ticket revenue can go up even while attendance remains static or diminishes.
This can happen if an organization raises ticket prices across the board or for specific events.
Across the board, the symphony has raised its average price by only 2% since 2019, a spokesman said. The symphony still charges only $25 for its lowest price zone, before fees. (The symphony was able to provide a clarifying email but not an interview before publication of this story.)
However, the average price paid for a ticket has increased by a little more than $15 compared to 2019.
The symphony explains this gap by pointing to higher demand performances of live-with-film soundtracks to movies like “Lord of the Rings” and “Star Wars” as well as special appearances by guest stars like cellist Yo-Yo Ma and pianist Lang Lang.
These special, big-name performances are where the majority of attendance growth occurred.
Attendance of regular classical concerts during the year is another matter, however, and a worrisome one at that.
When asked about attendance so far this season — which will end in August 2026 — the symphony said that “the attendance for fall concerts has been similar to last season.” Also, “Fall concerts typically have lighter sales than the remainder of the season.”
Average attendance for classical concerts was around 50% or less so far this fall in Heinz Hall, which seats 2,676.
In real numbers then, many concerts are drawing around 1,338 or fewer listeners. That’s certainly not a small number of people, but it is lower than the pre-pandemic seasons and has not shown signs of rebounding.
This matters because the classical subscription concerts are considered the “main” offering at a symphony orchestra, the performances of historical and new, serious concert music. It is what the musicians dedicate the most energy and time to and what the orchestra builds its artistic identity upon.
Further slides in attendance here will bear further scrutiny.
Perhaps America’s orchestral model is simply evolving, and this represents a shift in the formula toward fewer, more impactful performances rather than the 20 weeks of classical subscription programming that still forms the backbone of the season. Other orchestras around the country are certainly experiencing similar trends.
All of these ensembles are constantly investigating what it means to provide value to their respective communities in ways that bring in both audiences and donations enough to maintain their artistic caliber.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.