There was so much buzz around Mumford & Sons when they first arrived on these shores in 2013 as brash, foot-stomping folk-rockers with the grandeur of U2.

Was it a fresh new sound — the British Avett Brothers — or the stuff of parody? Was it just slightly cooler than Nickleback?

The consensus was about 50-50 on that, and probably hasn’t moved on Mumford, which has adhered to the formula these dozen years.

On Sunday at PPG Paints Arena, they were back for the first time since 2019 and the first time as a trio, having parted ways with one of their MVPs — banjoist/guitarist Winston Marshall — as he did not adhere to their values.

Advertise with us

The banjo of Matt Menefee, on “Run Together,” was the first sound we heard when the band took the stage with seven touring members backing the core of frontman Marcus Mumford, bassist Ted Dwane and keyboardist Ben Lovett.

They immediately generated a massive arena-rock sound from the volume of the rhythm section backing the acoustic guitars that were loud and fantastically crisp.

Those expecting a heavy dose of the long-awaited fifth album “Rushmere” — as in, those at the early shows — were surprised to find that Mumford was keeping that 2025 project to a minimum, and even adding newer material.

“There’s beauty in this pain,” Mumford sang on the “Rushmere” title track, and that was undeniable as the band stormed through its set with quiet intros building into mountainous crescendos.

They scaled those heights on the driving “Hopeless Wanderer” and “Roll Away Your Stone,” exploding into furious bluegrass jams, and on the cathartic sing-along choruses of greatest hits “Little Lion Man” and “The Cave.”

Advertise with us

With a fit-looking Mumford on the kit, they hit us with a horn section, a la The E Street Band, on “Lover of the Light.”

“Truth,” also from “Rushmere,” was a change-up as a scorching hard rocker complete with a Cream-y electric guitar riff and pyro to accompany the line “There's a fire in the almost places.”

They cooled things down by taking the B Stage for stripped-down versions of “After the Storm” and “Guiding Light,” prompting Mumford to joke about the band messing with deep cuts and old stuff.

There didn’t seem to be complaints about that, because, damn, these fans loved this band.

They went back to the main stage for “White Blank Page,” with some barbershop-style harmonies, but Mumford didn’t stay there long. He didn’t just jump down to the pit. He went all the way up to the concourse level in the back to belt out “Ditmas.”

Advertise with us

You may have seen Mumford listed as doing “Rubber Band Man.” A bluegrass cover of The Spinners song would have been awesome. It wasn’t that. But it was a keeper — tender with a nice acoustic flow.

The same goes for “A Conversation With My Son, Gangsters, and Angels,” a new song that they used as a soaring sendoff.

In between, they rocked electric with “The Wolf” behind a pyro shower, gathered around one mic for “Timshel” and absolutely raised the roof with the big hitter, “I Will Wait.”

Mumford endeared himself more to the crowd late in the show, talking about their outing to Tom’s Sports Bar to watch football and offering his sympathies on the loss to the Bengals.

Sunday night ended up being a win for everyone present, even if they went in thinking it wasn’t cool to like Mumford & Sons.

Advertise with us

Set list

Run Together

Babel

Rushmere

Little Lion Man

Hopeless Wanderer

Advertise with us

Lover of the Light

Believe

Truth

B-Stage

After the Storm

Advertise with us

Guiding Light

Main Stage

White Blank Page

Ditmas

The Cave

Advertise with us

Roll Away Your Stone

Rubber Band Man

The Wolf

Encore

Timshel

Advertise with us

Awake My Soul

I Will Wait

A Conversation With My Son, Gangsters, and Angels