The last time Mumford & Sons came through Pittsburgh, in March 2019, they were the original foursome that had been together for a dozen years: Marcus Mumford, Ted Dwane, Ben Lovett and Winston Marshall.

On Sunday at PPG Paints Arena, we’ll be seeing the British folk-rock band for the first time without Marshall, leaving the banjo work in the capable hands of touring member Matt Menefee, whose resume includes work with Ricky Skaggs and Bela Fleck.

When musicians leave a band, it’s usually because of drugs, ego, money, marriage or the tried-and-true “creative differences.”

Marshall was the rare case of irreconcilable political differences. Those differences resulted from a tweet in March 2021 praising a book by journalist Andy Ngo, “Unmasked,” that was critical of antifa, which has been a hot issue in the news of late with the Trump administration declaring it a terrorist organization.

Advertise with us

Marshall, who considers himself a “centrist,” faced immediate backlash when the tweet trended. Three months later, he departed the band with a statement that said in part, “I could remain and continue to self-censor, but it will erode my sense of integrity. Gnaw my conscience. I’ve already felt that beginning.”

He has since become a popular podcaster, advocating for free speech and populism, and hosting the likes of Jordan Peterson and Candace Owens.

He doubled down after Trump won in 2024, writing for Fox News, “The decisive wipeout of Vice President Kamala Harris was a rebuke of the stale misandristic Democratic Party and everything they represent: woke; envy; censorship; bureaucracy; elite sanctimony; corporate collusion and war.”

He also faced off against U.S. Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., in an Oxford Union debate on whether populism was a threat to democracy.

The Mumford incident all happened post Jan. 6 when former President Joe Biden was in the White House.

Advertise with us

While there may have been a slight cooldown during that stretch, since the beginning of Donald J. Trump’s second term, you cannot scroll through social media without encountering a political post, many from members of our local music community.

The question for those coming from the left, which is a vast majority in the music scene around these parts: Could they have played in a band with Winston Marshall, and what is the impact of social media takes on their audiences?

“Being in a band is being in a marriage,” says Eric Weingrad, who fronts theCAUSE and Reuben’s Painted Mandolin, two groups focused on the work of the Grateful Dead and Jerry Garcia-based outfits.

“[MAGA] is a cult that is based on nothing but lies, a house of cards. So if somebody in my band were to fall into that, I probably wouldn't be able to share the stage with them on a nightly basis. I’d put it to the band, like, ‘What do you guys want? What does everybody wanna do?’”

Weingrad, a prolific anti-MAGA poster, notes that, if anything, his political posts are a plus for the bands.

Advertise with us

“It's mostly positive,” he says. “Truthfully speaking, in the Grateful Dead world, the bulk of the people have liberal ideals or they have libertarian ideals. You know me, I’m a flaming liberal.

“One of the guys who sits in with Reuben's Painted Mandolin is libertarian and we have honest-to-goodness, polite discussions about things. His beliefs differ from mine, and when we can talk about that stuff. When it comes to the nonsense of what's going on in this cult, no, then we can't have it. But the reactions that I typically get most of the time are either polite disagreement from people or it's like, ‘Yeah I support that.’”

When it comes to antifa being anti-fascism, which is hotly debated, Chris Fafalios of the pop-punk Punchline understands where Mumford & Sons were coming from.

“What would be a reasoning to NOT be against fascism?” the bassist says. “That's kind of where it's a little puzzling to me. I don't know the specifics of the Mumford & Sons thing, but as far as being in a band with a MAGA person? Me? No, I couldn’t be in a band with someone like that. My band for the most part is pretty left-leaning.

“Our drummer, Cory Muro, is more of a libertarian-type guy and he and I have some good conversations, always in good faith and with love.”

Advertise with us

Like the Dead community, the punk scene is clearly left-leaning, so he sees little backlash to anything that he posts on socials.

“I've never had a single person say anything,” Fafalios says, “and I just think it's because I've always been outspoken about what I think. I think if someone would've been turned off to our music because of that, it would've happened 15 or 20 years ago. It's funny that I really haven't ever experienced that. I'm sure maybe it’s happened, but it wasn't like I was confronted by someone who was like, ‘I liked your music and now I don’t.’

“It seems like the rock world is pretty left and it's few and far between that you see the Kid Rocks and Lee Greenwoods.”

A few months after Marshall left Mumford, drummer Pete Parada was dismissed by The Offspring for refusing to take the COVID-19 vaccine. He has since been active on X supporting the efforts of U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s MAHA movement.

The blues world has an older base where there might be a little more diversity of opinion.

Advertise with us

“I’ve had some people object to my posts,” says bluesman Billy Evanochko, who actively bashes MAGA on Facebook. “I had a club that won’t book me anymore because of it. But I don’t mind losing that audience. I use my platform to speak up and speak out for those that can’t.

“As a veteran, I support anti-fascism,” he says, adding that the MAGA movement is a threat to the Constitution.

As for sharing a stage with a Trump-loving band member, “No, I wouldn’t,” he says. “I had a musician show up with a MAGA hat and I just won’t do it.”

Mumford & Sons play PPG Paints Arena at 7 p.m. Sunday with Stephen Sanchez and The Barr Brothers. Tickets are $53; ticketmaster.com.

Reuben’s Painted Mandolin is at the Thunderbird Music Hall, Lawrenceville, at 8 p.m. Friday with Favorite Band. Tickets are $21 advance; $27 at the door.