On a lazy summer afternoon in Carnegie Mellon University’s quad, a handful of ultimate frisbee players run drills, students lounge and read in the grass and the odd runner huffs and puffs past.
Then, a great “skirl!” splits the air.
The frisbee players miss a catch and pause to stare. Birds take flight from nearby trees. The squeal eventually settles into a steady drone as drums join in to pound out a beat, and eight bagpipers begin playing in tight unison, slowly gaining speed throughout a jaunty march tune.
A dozen members of the Carnegie Mellon Pipes and Drums had gathered for a final, informal stateside rehearsal before jetting off to Scotland to compete in the World Pipe Band Championships in Glasgow on Aug. 16.
View this post on Instagram
The global contest brings together more than 200 bands from all over the world and will pit the CMU ensemble head to head with musical groups from Sweden, France, Oman, Australia and more.
The prize? Bragging rights, mostly.
CMU’s band formed in 1939 and includes an amateur, multigenerational mix of 28 pipers and 16 drummers, a blend of current students, alumni, faculty and staff. This will be the ensemble’s first time attending “worlds,” as the contest is called.
During their final rehearsal, they played through their competition tunes, a set of three marches and some medleys, with one band member checking the pipe’s pitches with a tuner at the beginning to ensure that everyone was on key. Members worked together to tighten rhythms and harmonies, stomping in place at times to help keep a beat.
“There’s only nine notes,” said Chris Nolin, currently the band’s oldest alum and erstwhile “band mom.”
“How hard could it be, right?” she added, laughing.
Skirl of bagpipes
There’s an old Scottish saying about the bagpipes: “To the make of a piper go seven years of his own learning and seven generations before.”
Nolin, who graduated from CMU 40 years ago with a degree in chemistry, picked up the bagpipes seven years ago when she was looking for a new hobby to help cope with empty nest syndrome after her children left home for college.
She’d previously learned the French horn, trumpet, trombone and piano, but called the pipes “the hardest instrument I’ve ever learned.”
Like other novices, she started out with a practice “chanter,” which she described as “kind of like the recorders you get in grade school.”
She learned piping tunes and fingerings and embellishments on a chanter alone before buying a complete instrument with bag, drones and chanters. Its cost can range from around $1,000 used to nearly $10,000 new. Pipers blow air into the bag and use their arms to squeeze the air through the different pipes to create a continuous sound, adjusting pitches with the chanters.
Nolin studies with Andrew Carlisle, Carnegie Mellon’s “director of piping” and an artist lecturer in bagpipe who oversees the school’s bagpiping majors and also teaches private lessons.
Carnegie Mellon is the only university in the U.S. to offer bagpiping as a major, in part due to the Scottish heritage of steel magnate Andrew Carnegie, the school’s founder.
“This will be the experience of a lifetime for these players,” said Carlisle, a soft Irish brogue coloring his speech.
He serves as a judge on the North American bagpiping competition circuit and has been to worlds 30 times.
Chap a lip
Bagpipe bands are given a grade from 1 to 5 in competitions based on the difficulty of music and their execution, with 5 as the lowest and 1 the highest.
CMU’s band is in the middle of the pack, a grade 3. It will compete against 23 other grade 3 bands in Scotland.
“We’ve been checking them out on YouTube. They’re pretty steep competition,” said Nolin.
There are about 14 grade 1 bagpipe bands entered in worlds, according to the website.
There is not a qualifying round to enter, but a band needs to have been formally graded by a recognized competition previously.
“If you want to make a good go of it as a U.S. band, you have to be doing well in the North American circuit,” said Carlisle, who lives in Shadyside.
“The standard is higher in Scotland and UK than in the U.S.”
During the competition, Carlisle will serve in a role somewhere between band manager and coach — helping keep up morale and making sure everyone is in tune and ready for the competition.
Judges listen for tuning and balance between the pipes’ drones and chanters and for precision of rhythm. Are the notes played exactly together? Is the phrasing and expressive quality coming through? Is the music at the right tempo? These factors all play a role in a band’s grade.
Due to the number of grade 3 bands, there will be a qualifying heat and a final round. The band will play 5 minutes or less in each round.
“When we’re marching up to the line, we play our hype tune that gets us all psyched up for marching on,” Nolin said.
“I have to close my eyes take a deep breath and hold it, just envision, let the breath out, and then we go on.”
The band arrives in Scotland more than a week before the World Pipe Band Championship to compete in the European Pipe Band Championship in Perth as a warmup on Aug. 10.
The grade 1 band wins a trophy called the “spike” that they get to keep for the year. The winning grade 3 band gets to put their name on a large wooden cup and take a photo but not take it home.
“It’s a bit like the Stanley Cup,” Nolin said, adding that the proper good luck wish for a bagpiper isn’t “break a leg,” but “chap a lip.”
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.