Confetti wasn’t the only thing aloft amid the columns of The Pavilion at Star Lake by the end of the night on Wednesday — so was a band member of The Lumineers.
The lawn of the outdoor venue was washed completely in white dresses and denim when the alternative folk duo took to the stage with a jam-packed 27-song set.
A video animation of a cassette tape projected across the venue’s screens catapulted the audience of around 17,000 to their feet. The anticipation continued until the Denver band sauntered out to opener “Same Old Song,” spotlighting the band’s biggest assets: Wesley Schultz’s fantastic live vocals and the multi-talented musicians backing him.
The opener from their debut, self-titled album, “Flowers in Your Hair,” led smoothly into the 2016 hit “Angela,” backed by cheers and claps along to the verses. Mercifully, the weather cooperated, staying at a cool sub-80 degrees. And the beautiful night did not go unacknowledged by Schultz as the full band behind him seamlessly changed instruments between songs.
In this quick lull, he took a beat to acknowledge his history with bandmate Jeremiah Fraites — 20 years of making music together and five studio albums — before beginning “You’re All I Got” and “Asshole,” both from February’s release, “Automatic.”
“You should be suspicious of those who present themselves as perfect people,” Schultz said of the inspiration behind “Asshole.” “The other side of that coin is embracing people who present themselves as ragged and tell you the truth when no one wants to hear it — they are your truest friends.”
Their next few songs bounced between years with “Gun Song” and “Donna” before debut tracks that sent the band stratospheric in 2012, “Ho Hey” and “Dead Sea” off the band’s first album. During the latter, Schultz reached the vocal peak of the night at its triumphant climax, resulting in a standing ovation that briefly stalled the show.
Schultz later walked through the packed audience during “BRIGHTSIDE,” the band members onstage taking point as he sang with fans around the lawn. He returned to the stage with “Sleep on the Floor,” a stomp-and-clap along with an instrumental break that exploded with a large burst of golden confetti over the entire covered audience.
There was no shortage of big hits throughout the night, but new tracks received plenty of attention as well, including “Automatic” and “Plasticine,” released earlier this year.
Schultz teased the refrain on “Ativan” and called the origin a “what if” that came to fruition, spicing up what could’ve been a “boring” love song by turning it into a “seduction” by an antidepressant.
They kept the slow pace on stripped-back “Slow It Down,” which left Schultz and Fraites alone on stage with no backing band, just a guitar, tambourine and the latter’s characteristic fedora.
“This next one, [Slow It Down], we wrote in my kitchen and recorded in my living room,” Schultz said. “That you guys know these songs, it blows my mind.”
The frontman said this crowd is the largest they’ve seen in Pittsburgh, where they hadn’t played since 2022.
But they quickly returned to their classic folk rock sound, an enthusiastic sing-along to “Ophelia” and a special version of “Big Parade,” augmented on the Automatic tour by each band member (including rarely-singing Fraites) leading a different verse. A mid-song take on the “mannequin challenge” and several raucous dance breaks furthered the commitment to making every second of the show as engaging as possible.
The end of the setlist saw a fan-favorite mashup of the Rolling Stones’ “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” and Lumineers track “Leader of the Landslide,” and a tribute to Schultz’s late brother Samuel in the form of a “New York State of Mind” cover.
Sandwiched in between was a special guest appearance by Pittsburgh native musician Read Connolly on “Gale Song,” who then remained onstage through the rest of the show.
“Sam loved music; this is a song we sang together,” Schultz said of his brother, who passed in May, and the song from Billy Joel’s 1976 platinum record “Turnstiles.” “I feel lucky to play music and get some of this out of me.”
The final notes were kept short and sweet — “Cleopatra” and “Stubborn Love” closed out the set as band member Stelth Ulvang took his turn traipsing barefoot through the lawn and dangling from the architecture of the venue, keeping the crowd's focus alongside a touching video montage of the tour until the band finally left the stage.
Earlier in the night, Hippo Campus set the stage well for the main act with nearly an hour of experimental indie-rock fun, opening with their 2024 releases “Madman” and “Paranoid” as the audience slowly filtered onto the lawn.
Hailing from Minnesota, the quintet made good use of the stage, interacting with passionate fans in the pit and front rows on early hits “Baseball” and “South.” The members weren’t afraid to play with their sound during the 11-song setlist, frequently autotuning live vocals on tracks like “Tooth Fairy” and “Boys,” and adding energetic guitar and trumpet solos to raise the hype on stage and in the crowd.
Setlist:
Same Old Song
Flowers in Your Hair
Angela
You're All I Got
A.M. RADIO
Asshole
Gun Song
Plasticine
Donna
Ho Hey
Dead Sea
BRIGHTSIDE
Sleep on the Floor
Gloria
Ativan
WHERE WE ARE
Slow It Down
Strings
Automatic
Ophelia
Big Parade
Leader of the Landslide / You Can’t Always Get What You Want
Salt and the Sea
Gale Song (with Read Connolly)
New York State of Mind (Billy Joel cover)
Cleopatra
Stubborn Love





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.