When I start spouting off about leitmotifs or other bits of music theory at parties, people tend to get a bit glassy eyed and edge away slowly.

Fair enough.

But talk to them a bit about how the music in their favorite movie actually reflects the film’s internal logic and they light up faster than a Wagnerian funeral pyre.

In the first “Lord of the Rings” film, for example, which the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra is performing live-with-film this weekend, there is a five-beat brass tune that sounds whenever the wicked wizard Saruman is plotting his little Middle Earth industrial revolution in the fortress of Isengard. The tune is aggressively mechanical, clanging percussion emphasizing the irregular beat pattern — ONE two three FOUR five ONE two three FOUR five etc. — while the horns sound a factory-like alarm.

Advertise with us

Music traditionally divides into multiples of two or three, the rhythm here is a symbolic perversion of the natural order. The Isengard music stands in complete contrast to the music of the hobbits in the Shire, which features a ubiquitous, pastoral melody in a traditional four-beat pattern that composer Howard Shore dresses with folk instruments like the fiddle, the penny whistle, the guitar and — here’s one for rare renaissance instrument bingo — the hammered dulcimer.

It’s a bit on the nose, really. Natural, symmetrical, consonant music equals heroic. Irregular, dissonant, asymmetrical music equals evil, musical embellishments that help give the film’s characters texture and depth.

These are leitmotifs, or bits of melody that affix to a character or location in a film. They are a historically operatic idea, with the term coined by the dastardly but brilliant German composer Richard Wagner.

On Friday, the Pittsburgh Symphony’s performance was Herculean. These film score performances, which have become ubiquitous due to their popularity, are no easy feat. Film composers do not write scores meant to be performed in a single read through, but dozens or hundreds of individual “cues” that are recorded piecemeal in a sound studio.

Under the direction of Swiss conductor Ludwig Wicki, the musicians brought the score to life with plenty of idiosyncrasies and personality, bringing a fresh take to Shore’s melodies that breathed new life into a 24-year-old film that still defines the fantasy genre. If they sounded a touch tired or less precise by the end of the three-hour performance, it’s eminently forgivable.

Advertise with us

Slightly less forgivable, though not the orchestra’s fault, was the sound mixing, which I found obnoxiously micromanaged. An element of amplification to balance the orchestra with the film’s recorded dialogue and sounds is necessary, but the constant balance shifts and volume adjustment to certain instruments and sections simply isn’t necessary for an orchestra of this caliber, as it’s proven time and again with other live-with-film performances. That’s on the production team.

Shore’s other themes include: a noble melody for mentions of the city of Gondor, which features heavily in the trilogy’s third film; a chromatically daring adventure tune for the fellowship; eerie vocal cues for the elvish cities, beautifully rendered by The Mendelssohn Choir of Pittsburgh and the Junior Mendelssohn, the Pittsburgh Symphony’s regular choral companion. The list continues.

Each leitmotif has its own nuances, but they build to a work of art that is unquestionably operatic. It’s even in the name, “The Lord of the Rings” and Wagner’s famous “Ring Cycle” of four operas draw from some of the same Nordic myths.

This does not mean that folks who enjoy attending the symphony’s live-with-film performances would immediately enjoy a full-length opera or even a non-film orchestral offering. But the similarities in composition can help penetrate some of the opacity of “classical” music, and bring a deeper level of nuance to each film’s creation. You certainly don’t need to know this to enjoy the spectacle, but the world of composition is at least as varied and rich as the world of Middle Earth, to those willing to undertake the journey.

No volcanoes required.

Advertise with us

There are a handful of tickets still available for the performances Saturday at 7 p.m. and Sunday at 2:30 p.m. at pittsburghsymphony.org. The symphony also announced that it will screen and perform “The Two Towers” in June 2026.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.