How much can any single musician change the sound of the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra?

The short answer is that it depends on the role they play.

Principal positions — “first chair” in high school orchestra terms — tend to have regular solos, and the orchestra’s sound and style of playing will be noticeably different when they aren’t performing or a new player takes over. Plus, their leadership style can certainly impact the precision of a section and its cohesion with the rest of the ensemble.

A section player in the strings, woodwind or brass section — “second” chair — may not individually change the sound significantly. Part of their job is to blend in with their principal player’s sound.

Advertise with us

Orchestras are hierarchical and representative — a meritocratic republic, if you will.

So when, on Wednesday, the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra announced a trio of new appointments, including two principals and an assistant principal, it’s likely that the ensemble will indeed sound different next season.

First up is Julia Harguindey as the new principal bassoonist, the lower-pitched anchor of the woodwind section. Harguindey was most recently the principal bassoonist of the Nashville Symphony and Santa Fe Opera Orchestra. She replaces Nancy Goeres, who had played with the orchestra since 1984. Harguindey starts in September.

Next, the orchestra has appointed Zhenwei Shi as principal viola, a position that has been open for more than seven years. In the interim, Tatjana Mead Chamis, who joined the orchestra in 1993, served wonderfully as acting principal. Shi was most recently principal viola at the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra. He also starts in September.

Finally, Michael Banks started his tenure as assistant principal bass in May. He will serve as an alternate principal when principal Nicholas Myers is unavailable or not playing. Banks earned his bachelor’s degree from The Juilliard School in New York City and his master’s degree from The Colburn School in Los Angeles.

Advertise with us

The two principal positions are “titled” chairs, meaning that they are specifically endowed.

Principal players negotiate a higher salary than the orchestra’s regular base of around $110,000, with the endowments helping to sponsor the overages. Sometimes, an orchestra will hire from within a section and promote a musician to a principal role, but these players must still “win” an audition due to union rules.

The higher salary is due to the increased responsibility for principal players, which include interfacing with other principals and the conductor as a point person for the section and taking regular solos.

So, how noticeable will the changes be next season? Without a direct back-to-back comparison, it won’t be easy to notice. Listeners who attend regularly may spot the new faces and notice subtle changes during concerts, and the ensemble’s overall cohesion is very likely to increase with these key roles filled.

But, as is so often the case in classical music, the differences will be pleasurably subtle.

Advertise with us

These are not the only appointments the orchestra has announced recently. The symphony has a two-year fellowship program in honor of Paul J. Ross, the first African American player to win a job with the orchestra back in 1965.

The two new fellows this year are trombonist Jacob Ogbu and bassist Christian Harvey.

The fellowship is intended to help diversify the American orchestra field by providing musicians “identifying as Black or African American” with professional opportunities as they audition for full-time orchestral jobs, according to the symphony’s website.

The fellowship’s exact future is unknown in light of the federal government’s push to curtail DEI programs. One possibility is that the racial requirement is eliminated to comply with federal policies and language.

The Pittsburgh Symphony also recently lost its principal flutist, Lorna McGhee, to the Boston Symphony Orchestra. Additionally, the orchestra’s English horn position — prominent due to the distinctive sound of the instrument — has been open since Kyle Mustain departed in 2023. The principal percussion position role has been open since Andy Reamer retired in 2024. There are also a handful of section roles.

Advertise with us

An orchestra’s sound is never precisely set. It remains an organic, evolving entity, an artistic creature greater than the sound of any one member.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.