Rolling Stone isn’t the rock ‘n’ roll Bible that it was in the ’70s and ’80s, but, still, it's hard to resist the click when it drops a new list.
The latest from the mag clinging to life looks back 50 years to The 75 Best Albums of 1975 and, as usual, there’s a lot of rejiggering.
Rolling Stone has always loved Bob Dylan, and his “Blood on the Tracks” — perhaps the greatest breakup album of all time — tops the list. The album that opens with “Tangled Up in Blue” ranked No. 16 on the list of the “500 Greatest Albums of All Time” and rose to No. 9 on the 2020 list.
If you were to guess at No. 2 would you say Bruce Springsteen’s “Born to Run” or Patti Smith’s “Horses”?
It’s the latter. Smith’s brash debut, opening with the line “Jesus died for somebody’s sins, but not mine,” ranked at No. 44 in 2003 and then No. 26 in 2020.
“Born to Run” was No. 18 in 2003 and No. 21 in 2020. (If anyone cares, I can see a lot of “Blood” vs. “BTR” debates for that top spot.)
But look at the quantum leap made by Parliament’s “Mothership Connection 3” to land at No. 2. The album, which Rolling Stone’s Brittany Spanos wrote was “as foundational to funk as it is to pop music, becoming widely sampled in hip-hop for decades to come,” ranked at No. 276 in 2003 and 363 in 2020.
On the one hand, it’s good that Rolling Stone updates these lists as new writers enter the room. On the other hand, it does render them inconsistent and ephemeral.
There are two points of local interest. The debut album by Crack the Sky — the prog band that formed in Weirton, W.Va., and had a second home in Pittsburgh — was left off, despite the glowing review it received when it came out.
Stephen Holden wrote, “Like the first albums of Steely Dan, 10cc and the Tubes, Crack the Sky's debut introduces a group whose vision of mid-’70s ennui is original, humorous and polished.” He called it “one of the year’s most impressive debuts.”
Rolling Stone did not forget about it in 2015, ranking it No. 47 on the list of the 50 Greatest Prog Albums of All Time, writing that Crack the Sky “created an outright classic with their kaleidoscopic debut.”
The other 1975 debuts that make the list, besides “Horses,” are Heart’s “Dreamboat Annie” (41), Emmylou Harris’ “Pieces of the Sky” (37) and Steve Hackett’s “Voyage of the Acolyte” (65), the first solo record from the Genesis guitarist. And, no, it was not on the Best 75 Prog list.
The other point of local interest is Betty Davis, the funk queen from North Carolina who spent her formative years in Homestead.
She makes her Rolling Stone list debut with her sexually charged third album, “Nasty Gal,” which was reviewed unfavorably by critics and even condemned by the NAACP for its explicit lyrics upon its release. It’s ranked here at No. 34, one slot above “Agharta,” the double live album by the man who helped launch her career, her former husband Miles Davis.
Rolling Stone’s Larisha Paul writes, “Nasty Gal marked an effective end to the funk and soul musician’s career, aided by cultural backlash and suits in boardrooms. But it was always our loss, never hers.”
It doesn’t seem like it was great for her. She was dropped by her label, Island, and then spent a year in Japan, some of that living with silent monks, and then moved back to Homestead in 1980 to live with her mom before passing away in 2022.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.