So there you were on Friday, enjoying your morning coffee and checking in on what was happening on X — the Wild West of social media — and WHOA, HEY, WHAT’S THAT?!

It was Ye. Kanye. West. He was at it again.

Reinstated by Elon Musk, after having been banned in 2022 for posting a swastika, Ye was on a full-blown ALL CAPS rant: the JEWS, the JEWS, the JEWS, Hitler this, Hitler that, beefing with Dave Chappelle, lots of indecipherable stuff.

Former Steeler Le’Veon Bell was among those to jump in, X-ing, “aye Elon, I know we all for free speech and what not.. but this dude ‘Ye’ is PUSHIN’ it bro.”

Advertise with us

He was getting a pass until his stream of graphic porn took Ye down.

It’s been about three or four years of this with Ye, and about 15 since the first public madness. Beyond the human tragedy, the cultural one is that Ye is tough to dismiss. He’s one of the greatest talents of the century, with a series of albums — “College Dropout,” “Late Registration,” “My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy,” pick your favorite — practically embedded in the DNA of  millennials.

To discard those albums would be like a boomer throwing away “Dark Side of the Moon,” “Layla” or “Born to Run.”

Oh wait, that’s happening, too.

The past decade, in particular, has been brutal, with the left-right MAGA culture war, the #MeToo movement, the pandemic. The political environment has become so divisive, and has laid bare the personal lives of so many stars, it’s become a greater task to separate the artist from the art.

Advertise with us

Taylor Swift didn't do anything crazy but just got roundly booed at the Super Bowl. Carrie Underwood, even more of an icon of middle America, is facing wrath for doing what Jackie Evancho did before her — performing at the inauguration of Donald Trump.

Over there in hip-hop, if there were favorability ratings, Snoop Dogg, loved by even your great-grandma, was probably at the top. Until January, that is, when he reversed his Trump ban of 2016 and played an inauguration party. Nelly was right there with him.

From Snoop to Nuge

Snoop is a new arrival on the DNP (do not play) list for Pittsburgh DJ and promoter Edgar Um.

Responding to my Facebook post asking friends what artists they can no longer listen to or support because of politics or misdeeds, Um noted, “Ye has been cancelled for years. I will not play music made by anyone who supports this treasonous orange grifter.”

Snoop is also in the doghouse for Pittsburgh bluesman Billy Evanochko, whose DNP list is loaded with MAGA people.

Advertise with us

“Kid Rock, for starters,” he noted. “Not that I was ever a huge fan, but I respected how he bridged rap with rock ’n ’roll, and now he’s just [a jerk].

“Also, off the top of my head: Carrie Underwood, Lee Greenwood, Jason Aldean, Rascal Flatts and Gavin DeGraw. They can kick rocks. And Snoop. Been a longtime fan and now I just feel like he’s full of [crap] and a hypocrite.”

Kid Rock was one of the few rockers backing Trump during the first run in 2016. In the spring of 2017, he turned up at the White House with Sarah Palin and Ted Nugent for what liberals saw as an “Idiocracy” nightmare.

When it comes to problematic, Nuge is legend: For the weird draft-dodging story, the “Jailbait” accusations, the guns, the Barack Obama comments that prompted a visit from Secret Service. And that's not all.

“There is all the obvious racist stuff,” Mike LaVella, formerly of the Pittsburgh hardcore band Half Life, said of Nugent. “But on an episode of Anthony Bourdain he talks about how he hates ‘fat people’ and how disgusting they are and all that, which, I mean, how stupid do you have to be to not realize that you just completely alienated a portion of what’s left of your fanbase?”

Advertise with us

“Not that he has much to listen to, but Kid Rock turns my stomach,” noted Andy Booth, a retired Mt. Lebanon wedding DJ. “Ted Nugent, same. And all of those country ‘stars’ who went full-on MAGAt are automatic skips.”

Shut up and sing?

Van Morrison and Eric Clapton, Hall of Famers and titans of classic-rock radio, became skips for people when they railed against the going pandemic narrative. Claiming nerve damage from the AstraZeneca vaccine, Clapton was ripped for spreading “vaccine hesitancy” and “misinformation.” Morrison jumped in and condemned the lockdowns, then collaborated with Clapton on “Where Have All the Rebels Gone?,” a protest song calling out their peers for staying silent.

“I bought all of Clapton's music and saw him many times,” noted Mike Usman, a psychiatrist in Glenshaw, “but not since his dumbass anti-vax comments. Same holds true for Van Morrison, but I wasn't as big a fan beforehand.”

On the flip side, social justice warrior Jason Isbell and the Foo Fighters were among the artists praised and blasted for pushing the vaccine. Tom Morello still battles fans daily who think there was a vax mandate on the Rage Against the Machine reunion tour.

Remember when Bruce Springsteen played the No Nukes concert in ’79 but didn’t want to say anything.? He entered the political fray in ’84 when he called out Ronald Reagan (right here in Pittsburgh). Some of the “Bruuuuce’s!” turned to “boooos” in 2001 when he played the protest song “American Skin (41 Shots),” and then some people just bailed on him for his endorsements of Democrats.

Advertise with us

Springsteen got some mentions in the Facebook thread along with Pearl Jam, for similar endorsements, Roger Waters for his pro-Palestinian activism and Cat Stevens for his support of the fatwa against Salman Rushdie.

John Katic of Iron City Rocks has some advice for up-and-coming artists: “When you open your mouth and microphone to your political ideas, you immediately risk alienating 49% of your audience (left or right). If you're Bono or Nugent you can afford that.”

“Any performer who has to politicize things, unless you want to run for some sort of office, just perform your music and shut up about anything else,” said George Gilliam, a semi-retired Whitehall bartender.

Or, on the other hand, speak up! Diddy, R. Kelly and various felons are off the playlist for Pittsburgh rapper Frzy, but he’s also cooled on artists who “play Switzerland.”

“Lil Wayne will be like, ‘What do you mean? Racism doesn't exist. Never happened to me,’” Frzy says. “Those are some things I think that will stop me from being able to enjoy someone's music, no matter how talented they are.”

Advertise with us

Can we still listen to ...?

When it comes to sexual misdeeds, alleged and otherwise, you could probably wipe out half of your record collections. The backstage exploits of Led Zeppelin, The Rolling Stones, Aerosmith and Motley Crue, for starters, are legendary, and sometimes right there in the songs. But most people still support those bands without hesitancy because it was a different time.

People are less forgiving of Pittsburgh’s own Anti-Flag, whose frontman Justin Sane was accused of sexual assault, and Ryan Adams was accused of sexual harassment in the #MeToo wave by a number of women, including Phoebe Bridgers and ex-wife Mandy Moore. Adams denied it at first, then issued an apology in July 2020, but the damage was done.

“I used to love him a lot, but now, in light of his behavior, his songs are just creepy,” noted Jack Duluoz, a Pittsburgh-area teacher.

“Ryan Adams had his ‘me too’ minute. But I still love his music,” noted Tris Ann Gaydos, formerly of the band Barbed Wire Dolls.

Scott Briceland has conditions: “I used to love Ryan Adams. Once all of the allegations came out about him I kind of stepped back. Now I still listen, but will not support anything new.”

Advertise with us

He added, “I don’t agree with Ted Nugent on anything politically and he is an all-around terrible human, but ‘Stranglehold’ still slaps!”

Thomas Little, a former Pittsburgher working in customer service, goes a step further.

“I played the cancel game for a while until I realized that I was just punishing myself. Nugent's first five LPs were amazing. Kid Rock's ‘Devil Without a Cause’ is great, etc. New Rule: I will appreciate anyone's music as long as it was recorded before they become [jerks].”

Getting back to Ye, if you’re looking to apply that New Rule to him, here are your options: The Katrina comment was 2005 (after “College Dropout”), the Taylor Swift incident was 2009 (after “808s & Heartbreak”), the anti-abortion stance was 2013 (“Yeezus” era) and the first swastika was 2022. That takes us up to all 10 albums except the new one on the way.

Taking the long, and tolerant, view is jazz pianist Scott Anderson, the son of former Post-Gazette movie critic George Anderson.

“The history of all art, including music, maybe especially music,” he noted, “is the story of a lot of bad people doing terrible things. There wouldn’t be much to listen to if you limited yourself to artists who never let you down.”