OK, it’s not a normal night when the Pittsburgh Symphony’s principal oboist plays from a box seat, much less when she’s harmonizing with a large video recording of herself.
Placing musicians in creative positions around a room is a surprisingly mature tradition. Not in the “wow, your great grandmother was born in the 1800s?” kind of way — it’s a practice that dates back to Biblical times, when Psalm recitations followed a call and response format.
The practice is called “antiphonal” singing or playing, and while it’s commonly associated with religious music, it also appears regularly in other types of music, including Western classical music. On Friday, the Pittsburgh Symphony, joined by The Mendelssohn Choir of Pittsburgh and led by music director Manfred Honeck, opened its performance with a work that dates all the way back to 2021, Chicago-born composer Reena Esmail’s “RE/Member,” a meditation on the ritual of returning to business as normal. The program continued with other contemplative works, Johannes Brahms’ “Song of Destiny,” New York native Adolphus Hailstork’s 1994 “Lachrymosa,” and French composer Gabriel Faure’s 1888 “Requiem,” a musical setting of a Latin Mass.
It was a beautifully introspective evening, if a bit oversaturated.
Faure’s “Requiem” provided a dreamy cornerstone for the performance; it’s a transparent, luxurious surrender to death by a devout agnostic. The orchestra’s balances were superb, every line audible, with soprano Jeanine De Bique providing an exceptional, potent take on the “Pie Jesu” movement.
Faure’s “Cantique de Jean Racine,” written years earlier, provided a fascinating counterpoint to the “Requiem,” while Brahms’ “Schicksalslied” (“Song of Destiny”) gave a compelling musical depiction of repose and suffering, of heaven and hell, finishing with a reprisal of the serenity of the opening. A word of caution: many of the wind chords took a moment to settle in pitch or weren’t quite together.
Read More
Of the two American works on the program, Hailstork’s “Lachrymosa,” which included antiphonal, off-stage clarinets and bassoons, fit best with older works, conjuring a murky intensity. But both felt a little tacked on, regardless of their individual qualities. Esmail’s piece is somewhat palindromic. It opens with solo and returns to the same solo at the close, now with live performance — again, our word of the day — of antiphonal oboe decorating the melody now, beautifully performed by Cynthia Koledo DeAlmeida. Esmail filled out the middle with fanfares and fragments.
There was a clear logic in the program, but I found the evening somewhat overwrought, in need of trimming back or of greater contrast. Faure’s “Requiem” is exquisite — it would have been more profound if less obscured, even diluted, by the other works on the program.
For an evening of musical meditation, this idea of “less is more” could have been better taken to heart.
This concert repeats Sunday at 2:30 p.m. at Heinz Hall. Tickets begin at $25 at pittsburghsymphony.org.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.