In the summer of 2003, Punchline spent a month in Chicago recording their full-length debut album for Fueled by Ramen, the Florida-based label that broke Jimmy Eat World and had just released the debut album from their friends Fall Out Boy.

Working with Fall Out Boy producer Sean O’Keefe, the young Belle Vernon band — then consisting of singer-guitarists Steve Soboslai and Paul Menotiades, singer-bassist Chris Fafalios and drummer PJ Caruso — emerged with “Action,” a bouncy pop-punk record that lived up to the title.

Sputnikmusic called it “a strong pop punk album that most people will like even if they don't like pop punk.”

The high school friends, all in their early 20s, had been road warriors for years and now they had a record on a prominent label and radio play for a single, “The World.” They even went to Japan.

Advertise with us

Then came a setback. Six months into the album cycle, Menotiades left the band.

“So, it's like our fan-favorite album and he left the band and we kind of had to close the chapter on this album, because he sang all over it,” Soboslai says. “That was the height of our being out there touring with bands like Fall Out Boy and the height of our chance, I guess you could say. With him leaving the band, we got sent into this tailspin that we didn't really see coming and although we stuck together, I think that kind of got us off track a little bit.”

Punchline did manage to bounce back two years later, with “37 Everywhere,” another fan favorite, with Greg Wood taking the place of Menotiades.

Punchline is now marking the 20th anniversary of “Action” with a vinyl release and a tour that stops Saturday at the Roxian Theatre that will feature the band playing the album in its entirety. There will also be an “Action”-themed beer from their friends at Dancing Gnome in Sharpsburg.

Menotiades will be back on vocals and guitar alongside Caruso, who left in 2009, as he fills in for current drummer Cory Muro (who is busy touring with his other band, Lakeview).

Advertise with us

This is not the first reunion with Menotiades, who rejoined Punchline from 2009 to 2013 after the departure of Jon Belan, who now fronts Gene the Werewolf. One of the sparks for this reunion was the podcast A Band Called Punchline.

“We started making the podcast like a year ago and each episode covers one of our albums,” Soboslai says. “It's documentary style, highly edited, and just from doing that, we really got all of the original guys talking again. Not that we weren't talking, but for the first time, we were getting into a lot of things that we never really unpacked from back in the day — some unintentional therapy you could say.

“And I think it's just really made us aware how cool it is for our band to still be friends and show up and play and laugh about the same inside jokes from our first tours and whatnot. So it's been an exciting time.”

They talk about the wild times on the “Action” tour and the lack of adequate management to break the band bigger at the time. They also talk about the well-hidden drug problem that prompted Menotiades to leave right before they were about to go on stage in Albany in January 2005. Now, he’s a full-fledged member again, as Punchline forges ahead with three guitars.

“We've always, as a band, been unable to deny adding more harmonies and guitar parts to our albums,” Soboslai says. “It works really well because there's plenty of other parts that weren't being played to be played. I love it. It feels like we're such a force as a five piece. We all sing, so it just feels like a party up there.

Advertise with us

“I've definitely always been the guy who, any time I see a band with three guitars, I'm like, ‘Guys, you don't need three guitars.’ But us,” he says with a laugh, “I think we're doing great.”

The show is at the Roxian Theatre at 7 p.m. Saturday with Hot Rod Circuit, Eternal Boy and Heading North. Tickets start at $35.25; roxiantheatre.com.