As a spiritual leaning, self-described non-Christian band from Tallahassee behind wildly popular, multi-platinum, post-grunge albums written when some listeners had already grown weary of genre vocalists' yarling, Creed was labeled by the pious and the pragmatic alike.

In many ways, Creed has always been an easy target.

But for the sold-out Pavilion at Star Lake crowd spilling out over the lawn Saturday night amid the band’s Summer of 99 Tour to witness a force that for many shook them early in their formative years with subtly Eastern-tinged, questioning epics like "Who's Got My Back?"; anthems of personal accountability and unity like "My Own Prison" and “One”; and, of course, the unabashed Discman-rattling bangers “What If” and “Higher,” the Floridian foursome hit more than a few marks of their own.

First things first, though.

Advertise with us

Fellow heady post-grunge acts Three Doors Down and Finger Eleven set the tone early with a slew of hits also part of a rich, shifting and unpretentious — if moody — time in radio rock history.

After taking the stage to video game franchise Halo’s choral theme, Finger Eleven vocalist Scott Anderson performed his best cool dad routine (This is a compliment.) and coaxed the crowd into singing familiar tunes. The band’s performance climaxed with a version of their jaded club-story hit “Paralyzer” that began with Genesis’ “That’s All,” and melded into the band’s biggest single this side of “One Thing” before seamlessly culminating in its disillusioned vocal melody sung over AC/DC’s “Back in Black.”

Despite the unexpected mash-up, it was the Mississippi quintet Three Doors Down that deftly drew a sea of younger Gen-Xers, elder millennials and eager Boomers still happily discovering their kids’ music to their feet over the course of a dense set of radio rock hits before Creed graced the stage.

On a night when, mercifully, not a single directly modern political word was uttered (somehow, in the year of our lord 2024), the vocals of all three bands (prodigious pipes of Creed vocalist Scott Stapp included) were relatively underplayed in a wall-of-distortion mix that boasted enough bass to feel impactful.

And it was refreshingly abstract sentiment and nostalgia, rather than an ego or a specific agenda, that won the day.

Advertise with us

Taking home the night’s footballing award for distance covered and striking numerous exaggerated arena rock stage stances in front of sporadic pyrotechnic displays, Stapp took several occasions to level with a crowd he described as the band’s biggest on the Summer of 99 tour so far, in between nailing sturdily solid low-end hooks that left behind some of the heavier howling of his heyday.

“I’m feeling it,”  said Stapp ahead of the amped-up “Are You Ready?” “It’s coming right through you, and right through me.”

Before the simple, clean, low-end mourning of “My Own Prison, Stapp again addressed a crowd that frequently found itself in full-throated vocal unison with the band’s plethora of unavoidable hits from “My Sacrifice” to “With Arms Wide Open.”

“There are many types of prisons we create for ourselves,” he said “...Guilt and shame prevent us from growing, learning and becoming a better person. I call that finding purpose in the pain. It’s not about staying in the prison, it’s about reaching for something greater than ourselves.”

Ahead of “One,” a song that readily showcases the regal, minimalist riffing and righteous chord progressions of perennially underrated guitarist Mark Tremonti, came a poignant address that capped off a night that began with the heavy gun-imagery-bearing “Bullets” and saw a high water mark with the unity-seeking “One,” both brought to you by the makers of the human connection-breakdown chronicling “Who’s Got My Back?”  — all written between 1994 and 2001.

Advertise with us

“We live in a world that’s so divided. They want to keep us arguing about stuff that doesn’t really matter,” said Stapp. “We need to find the stuff that makes us similar.... Our only purpose in life is to come together, to unite. That’s what this next song is all about.”

Finger Eleven setlist

“Above”

“First Time”

“Quicksand”

Advertise with us

“Together Right”

“Adrenaline”

“One Thing”

“That’s All” (Genesis)/”Parayzer” / ”Back in Black” (AC/DC)

Three Doors Down setlist

Advertise with us

“Train”

“It’s Not My Time”

“Loser”

“Duck and Run”

“Here Without You”

Advertise with us

“Time of My LIfe”

“Away from the Sun”

“The Road I’m On”

“Never Look Down”

“Let Me Go”

Advertise with us

“Kryptonite”

“When I’m Gone”

Creed setlist

“Bullets”

“Torn”

“Are You Ready?”

Advertise with us

“Never Die”

“My Own Prison”

“What If”

“Weathered”

“Overcome”

Advertise with us

“Say I”

“Faceless Man”

“One”

“What’s This Life For?”

“With Arms Wide Open”

Advertise with us

“Higher”

“One Last Breath”

“My Sacrifice”