It could well have ended in 2002, making it all a colossal waste of a pretty cool band name.
Having just released a third album that performed only marginally better than the first two, Death Cab for Cutie was at a crossroads.
“During ‘The Photo Album’ tour, we basically hit a wall where we had been touring and grinding for years. We just kind of burned ourselves out,” bassist Nick Harmer says from the band’s 2024 tour that stops in Pittsburgh at Petersen Events Center on Thursday.
“We weren’t really sure what we were doing, whether we liked what we were doing, whether we were good at what we were doing. We weren’t exactly sure.”
There’s tale of the indie-rock band from Bellingham, Wash., getting into “a massive blowout” at a tour stop in Baltimore on Halloween 2001, a week after playing at the now-defunct Millvale Industrial Theater.
In that wake of that album cycle, “We had this big kind of moment,” Harmer says, “where we were all like, ‘We need to take a break.’”
During what turned out to be a short hiatus, frontman Ben Gibbard traded DAT files via FedEx (imagine that) with electronic artist Jimmy Tamborello, aka Dntel. The exchange resulted in “Give Up,” the early 2003 debut album by The Postal Service on which Gibbard shared vocals with Jenny Lewis of Rilo Kiley.
“If you look back at the history of our band,” Harmer notes, “all of the members kind of moonlighted in separate side projects. In fact, we used to say, and still do, that the more we all love making music, in all its forms, and the more experiences we have outside the band where we’re learning from other people, it was all good information to bring back into Death Cab.”
The success of The Postal Service record was rather long and drawn out, during which time, Harmer says, “We realized that we love being in a band together, but we need to figure out a way to do it in a healthy way, a way that feels really inspiring.”
Step one was parting ways with their third drummer, Michael Schorr, who was replaced by Jason McGerr, a college friend and bandmate of Harmer’s. In late 2002, with their energy revitalized, they turned their attention toward a concept album that Gibbard was writing about loneliness and long-distance relationships.
“Jason was an instant cornerstone foundation for the band,” Harmer says, “and Chris [Walla], our guitar player, was our producer. We had some engineering help here and there, but a lot of the days were just the four of us in the studio playing around with sounds and talking about music and making a mess and then cleaning it up.”
“I don’t think we had any idea whether it was going to be received well or people were going to care, but we knew that was the first record we had made with a full-band experience that felt really great to us, and that felt like enough.”
“Transatlanticism,” with its melancholy-to-transcendent moments, was a lifeline for Death Cab, hitting at a time when grunge had faded and a new wave of nuanced indie rock was emerging with touches of emo, embraced by shows like “The O.C.,” which showcased the Washington band live in an episode.
“There was just a change, culturally, that was happening,” Harmer says. “There were a lot of bands that were suddenly getting exposure through TV and movies — bands like The Shins and Modest Mouse. There was a shift happening musically in a pop-culture way that we were a part of. I wouldn’t say that we were leading any charge, but we benefited from it.”
“Transatlanticism” only reached No. 97 on the Billboard 200, but it would go on to be their first gold album and the last album they’d release before signing with a major label, Atlantic, for “Plans.” It debuted at No. 4 in 2005.
“‘Transatlanticism’ changed everything for us,” Harmer says. “We were able to afford things on the road that helped with all kinds of things, with mental health things. Up until ‘Transatlanticism,’ when we went on tour, we would all stay in one hotel room, if we could even afford a hotel room. Or we would announce from the stage, ‘Could we sleep on people’s floors?’ We couldn’t afford any crew. We had a merch person sometimes, but we didn’t have a sound guy or a monitor guy or any of those things to help take our show to a more professional level.”
It was no small matter that they were able to rent a tour bus, so they could sleep at night and wake up refreshed for the shows.
“All of those things contributed to us being able to keep our spirits high, so we could focus on the better aspects of being in a band,” Harmer says. “It allowed us to quit our jobs and make the band the centerpiece of our lives and livelihood, which was beyond our wildest dreams. When we started the band in college, it was just a fun way for us to go out and see the world and meet some other like-minded and creative people, making music and doing things around the country. We never thought for a second we would make a living doing it.”
For the 20th anniversary of both albums, Gibbard pitched his bandmates on the idea of a tour where he would front both Death Cab and the Postal Service to play ‘Translanticism’ and “Give Up” in full, and they agreed.
“One of the things that takes some getting used to,” Harmer says, “is that for years, the song ‘Transatlanticism’ has been our standard set- and encore-closer. It’s just such a big cathartic moment, this big crescendo, and that happens in the middle of the record.
“So when we first got into this, it was like, ‘How is this going to work to play this big set-ending song seven songs into the set? Is it going to kind of kill the vibe for the back half?’ We thought, ‘Do we play the album from start to finish or do we just play songs from ‘Transatlanticism’ in any order we want?’”
“And then we said, ‘You know what? No, we’re doing the record start to finish. This is the thing that people have been listening to all this time. They know the order. Let’s do a faithful recreation of that’ and it’s worked really great.”
The show is at 7:30 p.m. Tickets start at $69.50; ticketmaster.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.