Hip-hop and classical music go together like oil and water. It’s tough to mix a genre based on hooks and slam poetry with a genre built on abstract melodic and harmonic development.
It’s tough, but not impossible. Even oil and water can mix with the right third ingredient, an emulsifier, to get them to merge. OK, here endeth the chemistry lesson.
The point is, at Wednesday’s Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra concert, the rapper Frzy managed to “cook” with both oil and water, acting as a zealous emcee and star performer while highlighting the orchestra, his band and his guest performers.
The concert, “The Glorious Succession of Frzy,” was a tight 90 minutes of hip-hop tinged with classical instrumental inflections, a sprig of brass here, a pinch of woodwinds there, a dash of strings and a healthy dollop of guest vocal soloists adding to the dramatic zest of Frzy’s new album, “Success.”
As with any concert, there were high points and things that need work. We’ll start with the former.
What went well
Frzy delivered tight, clean lines. His rhythms were crisp and fiery and combined well with the orchestra’s harmonic punches, conducted here by the orchestra’s associate conductor, Moon Doh. There’s a satisfaction to intricate beats and lyrics lining up and landing that can’t be overstated. It may sound simple, but this is where the combination works best.
Singer and songwriter Megan Paullet, another local artist, was a standout in “I Got All Day,” weaving a breezy melody with Frzy’s rap. Saxophonist Jason Kush’s playing bent time with just the right amount of indulgence (couldn’t resist), and the pickup choir added a grungy gospel tinge to songs like “No Love.”
Hill District-born rapper Bird took the stage by storm, and Frzy’s band, The Faculty, delivered rock-steady grooves both with the orchestra and in their solo tracks.
The show was energetic and interactive. Around 1,000 listeners were on their feet dancing at times, making noise more loudly and more often than at a typical concert. And certainly, there was a fascinating cross section of the folks one typically sees in Heinz Hall as well as plenty of new faces.
That’s a win.
What needs work
Now the flip side.
First, let’s talk sound design. I’ve heard hip-hop artists perform with various orchestras and every time, it’s tough to hear specific lyrics. An easy fix might be to use supertitles and project the lyrics on screens so the audience can follow along. Or perhaps printing song lyrics as a program book insert. In the opera world, even works sung in English have supertitles — the musicality in such performances is about the blend of instrument and voice in a concert hall, and doing this well necessarily means some loss of linguistic clarity. Supertitles could be a simple fix.
Next, the arrangements. Wednesday’s charts (by local composer Christian Kriegeskotte) had flair and nuance, but the orchestra felt underutilized. Frzy repeatedly referred to the Pittsburgh Symphony as one of the great orchestras of the world — a song or two more that let them unleash and really strut would have helped demonstrate this. With so many guest artists onstage, it was curious that the orchestra was only rarely allowed to shine.
I’d also suggest that featuring more individual musicians in solos and duets with the rapper would have been effective. Hip-hop is generally fairly harmonically simple, creating a wicked snazzy violin or trombone solo line while Frzy drops bars would better balance the two elements.
Bottom line
The Pittsburgh Symphony is known for its passion and gusto around the world. The energy that Frzy and guests brought to the stage on Wednesday is comparable, but as it currently stands, the show is more of a hip-hop production with orchestra than a true merge.
Then again, this was a first foray, something new that needs refinement and development and polish. The team will continue to do so, but in the meantime, I’ll take a fun, high-key show with heart over something staid and rote any day. And as the orchestra world continues to make efforts to bring new listeners into the hall, the symphony shouldn’t abandon attempts to merge genres and styles without working through the kinks.
Here’s to the next glorious succession.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.