Meanwhile in Switzerland, researcher Wolfgang Tschacher strapped more than 100 concertgoers to body sensors while they listened to music be Beethoven, Brahms and Brett Dean. The findings? People “harmonized” — their breathing speeds, their heart rates, their skin conductance and more, all synchronized to each other and the music, thus adding a spot of scientific credence to the long-accepted notion that concerts are a wonderfully communal experience.
Extrapolating from here, I’m comfortable concluding that Friday night’s Pittsburgh Symphony performance set listeners hearts racing by the finale of Beethoven’s Symphony No. 7. With music director Manfred Honeck at the podium, the orchestra was as thrillingly explosive in the final movement as they were poised and fluid in the second movement, famously known as the “apotheosis of the dance.”
Here was some inspired, natural phrasing and some of the softest playing I’ve heard from the symphony. It was quite breathtaking.
Friday’s program opened with the brief but rambunctious “Short Ride in a Fast Machine” by the living American composer John Adams, cleanly delivered despite the complexity and speed of its interlocking rhythms. Plus, the orchestra’s newly minted concertmaster David McCarroll stepped to the front of the stage for his first concerto performance with his adopted orchestra.
McCarroll chose Schumann’s Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in D minor, a rarely heard work with a curious history. In brief, Schumann finished the work shortly before being locked up in an asylum for the insane, and the violinist for whom it was intended shied away from performing the work, fearing that it was tinged with Schumann’s madness. I covered the work’s history in more depth earlier in the week.
Typically, Schumann would have worked with a performer to adjust and revise the work in rehearsals. The piece, as it’s currently published, is akin to an early draft, and it shows. McCarroll handled the more sensitive passages with warmth and nuance, including some touching duets with principal cellist Anne Martindale Williams. Still, in the more exciting passages, he was often drowned out by the orchestra. (I attribute this more to the score being a bit thicker than McCarroll’s projection.) The work’s emotional range is limited, and though there are some inspired moments, it felt somewhat anticlimactic on Friday.
McCarroll’s playing isn’t as polished as some of the international soloists that pass through, but there’s something special when orchestra members perform such solos with their peers, a certain trust that can make for exceptional chemistry. The kind that sets hearts to pounding in unison, even.
This concert repeats Sunday at 2:30 p.m. Tickets start at $20 at pittsburghsymphony.org. There is also a more performance of Beethoven’s seventh symphony on Saturday at 7 p.m. as part of the PSO Disrupt Series. Tickets begin at $25.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.