Being a Matchbox Twenty fan has required a degree of patience this decade, during which the band bumped its tour a full three years.

The reward, however, is that the pop-rock quartet from Orlando known for such hits as “3AM,” “Push” and “Unwell” delivered a fifth album, “Where the Light Goes,” that wasn’t in the plans when they first decided to tour in 2020.

About four songs from the album will appear in the set when Matchbox arrives at The Pavilion at Star Lake on its first tour since 2017, when it reunited to mark the 20th anniversary of debut album “Yourself or Someone Like You.” Released in October 1996, that album sold 610 copies in its first week before going on to become 12-time platinum.

That was a few years after Paul Doucette, the band’s drummer and rhythm guitarist (at various times), left the Pittsburgh suburb of North Huntingdon for Orlando, where he answered an ad to join the band.

Advertise with us

Last week, the Norwin High School grad filled us in on that story and more MB20.

Tell me about what it was like growing up here from a musical perspective. What laid the groundwork for what you do?

I grew up, like a lot of places there, in a very neighborhood kind of area. So it was kids in the neighborhood who wanted to start a band, and that's how it started for me. Two guys that I was friends with were like, “Let's start a band.” I was gonna be the drummer because they both had guitars. That's kind of how the decision was made and then, just about every single day when we got home from school, we rehearsed at my house because my drums are there and my parents were just cool about it.

It just became everything, our whole life was built around the band and the idea of having a show and so the first show that we ever played, we rented out a VFW, then put together like a little festival, you know, for as much as a 14-, 15-year-old kid could put together a festival.

What kind of music were you playing?

Advertise with us

Oh, we played nothing but metal, my friend, nothing but metal. It was Slayer, Metallica, Anthrax. You know what? We might have had like an original or two. I'm sure they're incredibly terrible.

Were there any Pittsburgh musicians that mentored or inspired you?

I definitely was a fan of The Clarks back then and I met them through the years afterwards and talked about it. But, you know, we used to go to see them. They were like the local Pittsburgh band at the time. There was no one bigger than The Clarks.

What made you move to Orlando?

When I graduated from high school, my parents moved down to Orlando and I stayed in Pittsburgh for a couple of years. Then I decided I kind of wanted to go to school and there was a recording school down there. That's kind of what started it, but I ended up not having the money to go.

Advertise with us

So what happened when you went to Orlando? You answered an ad for a drummer?

I did, I totally did. I worked at a record store and it was not a record store that a lot of people shopped at. It was kind of out of the way, so I just had a lot of time to sit. There used to be a local music magazine called Jam magazine in Orlando. I answered an ad and then I met Rob [Thomas] and I met Brian [Yale], the bass player, that night.

Were you still into metal or had you sort of evolved a little bit?

First of all, once you're into metal, you're never not into metal. You’re all in. But no, I mean, I was into so many different things. Even when I was playing in that band, I wanted to play R.E.M, but none of the other guys did. So it was sort of like, “OK, well, I guess we're playing metal,” but I loved everything.

When you met those guys, did you have a vision for what you thought Matchbox Twenty would be like? How did the sound develop?

Advertise with us

When I got to the audition, and Rob wasn't there yet, the guys played me their demos and one of those demos was “3AM.” So that's really one of the first things I ever heard that he wrote. I don't think we thought about it that far, it's something that just sort of developed over time, like that was our starting place. So it was obviously a starting place that worked for us later.

We kind of just developed, I would say, and even up until this record, you don't really necessarily know what you're doing until you're about halfway through and then you figure it out and then you go, “I'm gonna lean into that” or “I'm gonna run from that.” And I think that's kind of how it's gone the whole time. Normally we would lean into it.

Were you impressed by that demo when you first heard it?

I remember thinking “That's a catchy song” and I liked his voice. Then, when I met him that night, we got along instantly. And so it was sort of a combo of those. But it was an undeniable song. I don't remember thinking that of the other songs that were on there, but I definitely thought of that one.

And then success came really quickly for you guys. You didn’t really have to grind it out.

Advertise with us

I guess. It depends on how you look at it. In the grand scheme of things, yes, it happened quickly. But that was 1993, so it was about three years. The first record came out in 1996. I guess we got a record deal in ’95. So I guess 2½ years. Then, you know, by the time we put out that record, nobody cared, so it took another year plus for anyone to even notice what we were doing.

Was there something in particular that broke you guys?

That song [“3AM”] is definitely the thing that got us a record deal, without a doubt. But most of the songs that were on the record were written after we got the deal. We put the record out. Nothing was happening. And then a radio programmer in Birmingham, Alabama, started playing “Push,” and we were playing out, touring for like a year, playing to 10 people, 20 people, 50 people on a good night.

We got to Birmingham and there were a thousand people there. We were like, “Wow.” And so the label took notice of that and they were like, “Well, that song seems to be doing well. Let's put that song out.” Our previous single, which was a song called “Long Day,” was out, but no one really cared about it. And then “Push” happened, so “Push” is really what broke us. Then, “3AM” took us into a different world. We got played on pop radio.

You had more popular success than critical success.

Advertise with us

Oh, totally.

What was that like for you?

We were in our early 20s. No one wants to be criticized at that age, or at any age, really, but you also don't have the perspective of everything, and we were the popular band to sh-t on at that point. Luckily, other bands came and took that mantle from us, which is kind of nice.

You know, I think over time, the thing about us is, we've always been a pop band. We were a pop band wearing alternative band clothing. And we had to figure that out on our own. As we kept going, I think people started to realize that we were a pop band, and not that we became critical darlings, but we became sort of like, “OK, they're not our thing but they're doing their thing and that's fine.” It became less biting. And it also bothered us less. We were just like, “Whatever. We're doing our thing. We don't care. You like it or you don't like it.”

How did it reach its first conclusion the first time in terms of the band winding down?

Advertise with us

We had been going for a couple of years, so I guess we get up to our third record. Rob had done “Smooth” in between that, too, so that was obviously a huge success for him, and he wanted to go and do some stuff on his own and we were tired and wanted to take a break anyway. And so we did and that was 2003, I think, that was our last tour. Then we didn't do anything again until 2007. So we kind of got together and did a greatest hits that we kind of put new songs on and then we went dark again for another couple of years. I guess 2012.

During this time, you were doing some TV work. How did you get into that?

I originally got into it because my ex-wife went to film school and had to make a short for the class. I scored that and I liked doing it and then I sort of did a couple of things around then. Then I did a movie for Nickelodeon, like a kids movie. Then we went back and made “North” and then I did Matchbox again and then we went dark again, so I went back to scoring and it just sort of picked up.

I was doing little films here and there, documentaries here and there, I started ghostwriting for other composers and additional music writing and paying my dues in that world — starting from the bottom and working my way up and learning the craft of it.

You guys were going to tour and then kept postponing. What was going on?

Advertise with us

We have a couple of people in our family of the band that are immune compromised, so we just had to be safer and it became about people's comfort and how we'd be able to do it. People just weren't ready. That was what led us to do the record. We kind of felt like we were letting a lot of people down and so that started the conversation as well. We were gonna tour anyway, so we were gonna work. Why don't we just keep working and just do a record?

What was it like coming back together after all that time and working on this album together?

It's interesting. It's two different things. One, it's completely natural because we've known each other our entire adult lives, but we take a lot of time away from each other. You come back and the reality is, the person that I know also has all of these new superpowers that they've learned from working with other people. You sort of have to get used to that for a second because roles change, tastes change, work process changes. It's almost like you're starting a new band with people you've known your whole life.

When you were coming up with the music and the songs, did it fall back into a similar process?

No, the process was definitely different. The process was probably closer to how we made “Mad Season,” but not even really.  So much of it was done individually and then we'd come together in little spurts and we would be sending stuff back and forth in our own studios rather than all of us just sitting in a room playing. So it was a different way of making a record, which was interesting for us too because it was something that we hadn't done. It was a little bit more of a challenge to not just do the same old thing. It sort of took us out of our comfort zone a little bit.

Advertise with us

How are the new songs working into the set?

We started this tour before the record came out and we were playing songs that no one had ever heard before, which, you know, we haven't done since the beginning. So that was kind of fun and interesting. We didn't have the songs under our fingers yet. We were getting used to it, the audience was getting used to it, but now it's different. We're halfway through the tour, the songs are feeling great, people know them now. I think they're going over really well.

What is it like when you come back here? Do you have any family left here?

I don't, no. Most of the family is in Florida. My brother lives in Ohio. My extended family didn't live in Pittsburgh, only my immediate family did. So I didn't have a lot of family there to begin with. But, last time we were there, I definitely rented a car and took my wife to where I grew up and did all that stuff because I had a day off, which was great.

The show is at 7:30 p.m. with Matt Nathanson. Tickets are $30; ticketmaster.com.