The Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra recently shelled out nearly $200,000 to purchase a new Steinway grand piano for Heinz Hall.
Selecting the new piano was a grand production that involved travel to New York City to the Steinway factory and a pair of world-famous pianists weighing in on which instrument would travel to the Steel City. The new piano debuted in October and...
It hasn’t been used much since.
Awkward. I’m hearing rumors, but I won’t speculate about the reason why until I learn more.
At the past several symphony concerts, including the one on Friday, soloists have opted to use Heinz’s older, trustier instrument. It isn’t failing them — on Friday, pianist Francesco Piemontesi delivered a spectacular account of Brahms’ first piano concerto, a tempestuous work of high drama. Brahms was a young man when he wrote this concerto, but its melodies and formal ingenuity are on par with his most mature offerings.
Piemontesi’s technique is flawless, and his rapport with the orchestra was something special, even by this orchestra’s high bar. A duet with principal French horn player William Caballero in the second movement stood out, but the entire work was spellbinding for its stormy, charging energy. Certainly the high point of the concert.
Read More
And the older piano holds up in spades; famous names like Lang Lang and Emanuel Ax (who helped pick the new piano...) have opted to use this older model in recent months.
The piano wasn’t the only substitution on Friday. Conductor Elim Chan, a rising star in the orchestra world in recent seasons, bowed out due to illness earlier in the week.
Daniele Rustioni stepped up to the podium at the last minute for an excellent debut. Rustioni led with a confident, splashy style. It was largely effective. Rhythms were tight, colors were inspired and vivid — particularly in the Brahms.
The second half of the program featured another weighty work, Rachmaninoff’s “Symphonic Dances,” another staple in classical repertoire. The first movement is forceful and militant and follows an A-B-A form. When this energetic first section reprises, there was a noticeable loss of steam — indeed, my only caution is that Rustioni not become overly bogged down in the details of the work, as such dense music needs a balance between propulsion and finesse. He tended to wave his arms a bit much for my taste in solo passages (a friend remarked he looked a bit like an inflatable advertising tube dancer), inserting himself unnecessarily into moments that should have allowed individual musicians to shine.
Finally, to open the second half of the concert, the orchestra played an homage to Beethoven’s music by composer Unsuk Chin, “subito con forza.” Frankly, it left little impression. There were a few Beethoven quotations and massive changes in character — but for what purpose? Such an effect is not enough to build a compelling work, to my ears. Without any formal unity, the piece, for all its brief six minutes, seemed a collection of moments rather than any sort of cohesive impact.
That said: I’d rather hear some new music thrown into the mix, regardless of its subjective quality. This particular swing simply didn’t connect, for me.
Besides, on Friday, the Brahms alone is more than worth the ticket and time.
This concert repeats Sunday at 2:30 p.m. Tickets begin at $20 at pittsburghsymphony.org.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; Twitter @Reynolds_PG. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.