One might think that one Steinway grand piano sounds much like the next.

One couldn’t be more wrong.

After a recent Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra rehearsal, stagehands wheeled three pianos onstage: the piano that has been a Heinz Hall mainstay for the past 20 years, as well as two shiny new 9-foot grands straight from the showroom floor in New York City.

The purpose of this performative piano pageant was simple: The PSO needs a new piano.

Advertise with us
Pianist Enamuel Ax plays one of two Steinway pianos under considered for use by Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra at Heinz Hall. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

It’s an expensive endeavor. The price tag for a new Steinway is a neat $198,000. They need to get it right on the first try.

Even pianos that are the same brand and size vary significantly in sound. Qualities like articulation and decay, clarity and balance, color and warmth, and numerous other difficult-to-define attributes give each instrument a unique “character” of sound and feel. These measurable and unmeasurable acoustic qualities are also dependent on the space they are played in.

Fortunately, last weekend’s orchestra concerts featured the unmeasurable talents of one Emanuel “Manny” Ax, one of the world’s great pianists. He graciously agreed to help the orchestra with its final selection, as the chosen piano will define the next generation of performances in the hall.

“I’m here to do what I’m told,” he called from the stage before performing the opening solo from Beethoven’s fourth concerto back to back on all three pianos.

“Manny!” called the orchestra’s music director, Manfred Honeck, who was seated amid a mix of employees and donors.

Advertise with us

“Ya?”

“Sounds wonderful!”

“What?!”

“Sounds wonderful! Can you play something more romantic next?!”

Like many events in the arts world, the piano selection was delayed by the pandemic. It was supposed to happen two years ago. In May, a contingent of symphony personnel visited Steinway in New York to hear six pianos. There, another superstar pianist and regular Pittsburgh Symphony collaborator, Yefim Bronfman, whittled the selection down to two.

Advertise with us

Fort Pitt Piano Co. in McCandless, the local Steinway dealer, brokered the sale. Joe Ravita Sr., the owner’s father, said that supply chain issues as well as high demand for grand pianos had the store backed up with more orders than they could fill in the immediate future. Smaller pianos remain plentiful.

“It’s a good time to be in the business,” he said.

Back onstage, Ax was playing a bit of Brahms on one of the new pianos.

“Well it’s certainly loud enough!” he called. “There’s more ‘ping’ to this one.”

As the afternoon progressed, Honeck and Ax debated clarity, warmth, attack, blend, brilliance and darkness. Ax played a variety of music from different styles and volumes to put the new instruments through their paces.

Advertise with us
Manfred Honeck, music director of the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, discusses the orchestra’s new Steinway piano at Heinz Hall. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Soon, a consensus emerged.

One of the two pianos had clear, sharp attacks and a booming quality that could easily be heard over the orchestra during a concerto. This was especially noticeable from seats higher up in Heinz Hall.

The other piano had more color and warmth in its tones, but articulation wasn’t quite as clear.

Because the piano is primarily used in concertos, where it must be heard unamplified over as many as 100 other instruments, the one with greater clarity emerged victorious.

“But no one can say how they’ll develop over the decades,” said Peter Stumpf, Pittsburgh’s premiere piano technician and the man who keeps the symphony’s pianos in tip-top shape.

Advertise with us

Stage hands wheeled away the loser to audible groans from listeners rooting for it. By Monday, that piano will be back in New York, ready for another trial. It’ll likely be snapped up in weeks due to the current high demand.

Even though the “old” piano at Heinz Hall is only 20 years old, Ax said that it wasn’t played out by any means. Having a second piano means that visiting soloists will be able to choose which instrument better suits their particular technique and the music they are playing.

“Think of it in terms of tennis,” he said. “Players bring a dozen supposedly identical racquets, which are much simpler than pianos. But on any given day each of those racquets has a slightly different ‘feel’ to it. They seem completely different from one another.”

Pianist Bronfman will debut the new piano in all its splendor in October with Mozart’s 22nd piano concerto, the final movement of which is featured in the famous classical music movie “Amadeus.”

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.