It may sound harsh, but the truth is that most students who study at music conservatories won’t wind up performing professionally.
Yet music schools including the one at Pittsburgh’s Carnegie Mellon University, which has around 300 undergraduate and graduate students each year, continue to churn out hundreds of students a year with bachelor’s degrees in music performance.
But change is in the wind. In May, the school announced a Head of the School of Music, Jonathan Bailey Holland, arriving fresh from Boston Conservatory to take the reins from Denis Colwell, who has led the school of music since 2012. Holland, a graduate of the Curtis Institute of Music in Philadelphia and Harvard University, is also a professional composer whose works are regularly performed by major U.S. orchestras.
The Post-Gazette recently interviewed Holland in his Oakland office about music education and more. It has been edited for length and clarity.
I’m going to start with the big question: Should music schools still train so many young musicians when it’s so difficult to find work playing music?
These questions are asked somewhat regularly. Yes, there are likely fewer opportunities than there have been. But I don’t think there have ever been a ton of specific jobs that people walked right into out of music school.
Read More
Arts careers are often not a straight line. Just because you come to school as a clarinet major doesn’t mean your end goal is to play clarinet in an orchestra.
As a trained clarinetist who writes for a living, I see your point.
Right. There are plenty of people who come and study music, who then become administrators or teachers or managers of arts organizations or become conductors later because they realized that even though they loved playing their instrument, they actually have a love of the entire orchestra and putting it all together. I think it’s always been the case that musicians have had to have the portfolio career.
OK, so are music schools getting better at training students for those portfolio careers?
I’d say so. I think that many schools have entrepreneurship or career skills types of classes available. I think it’s always a question of how do you fit those courses in. Should they be required? Are they extra? And, you know, undergraduates have different needs than graduate students. It’s an evolving calculation.
Schools are teaching more than just the instrument, then.
Yes. You come to music school on an instrument, and you get a degree in that. But you’re not coming out as just a specialist in that one area. You, hopefully, have a broad understanding of the field overall, or of the discipline to succeed, at least.
There are so many skills that you learn in that process that are transferable. Learning how to synthesize the context in which art is created and to function in the social dynamics that you learn while playing in a group — whether you’re leading the group, whether you're a member of the group — learning what it means to play first chair versus what it means to play second chair. That's universally transferable.
I think that’s nail on the head there. Musical training can prepare students for other careers.
Definitely. I think the idea that any of us are ready at 18 years old, to say, “Boom, this is it for the rest of my life,” is crazy. Some really do that. But the skills are transferable either way.
Did you expect to wind up teaching composition?
Both of my parents worked for the public schools growing up. So I had that “got to do a different thing than what my parents do,” mindset. But I think I found resonance in teaching.
Were your parents musical?
They weren’t, but they loved music. My dad actually taught auto mechanics at the vocational high school for the county. And my mom was a social worker, when I was younger, for various elementary and junior high schools in the school district.
I think I showed an interest in music early on, and they did all they could to make sure I had opportunities.
You specialized in trumpet at first but switched to composition in high school. What prompted the change?
My father is from Pittsburgh. And his father owned a baby grand piano, which I still have. When I was little, I would sit down and make up little songs on the piano. I remember writing some pieces for friends for brass quintet or some fanfares. So it was always there.
And then after my first year of high school, I think I pushed myself too hard and needed to step back from playing. “Well, I’ll do some composition,” I said. Then, when I was accepted to Curtis, that sort of sealed the deal. Something about writing just seemed to come more naturally. It also didn't involve practicing. [laughs]
So as head of the music school, what’s next on the docket? What’s the plan to help students develop the skills to succeed?
I'm walking in the door saying, “Wow, what's going on here?” Because I didn't really know all the great stuff that was here.
We have this great music and technology program that engages faculty from the computer science and engineering departments. It’s actually one of the top programs in the country. We also have a sort of newer electronic music program.
Is that the future, inter-departmental collaboration?
It’s one avenue. Here, you’ve got the music and technology, and that’s really about the applications and the software. And then you've got the electronic music, which is really more about the creative side of using those tools. So they have those things side by side with the great performers that come out of the music program. It’s really exciting stuff.
But the goal is to see the bigger picture, to make sure that the faculty have what they need in order to do what their specific area needs. I’m here to help facilitate.
So not missing the forest for the trees.
Exactly. Exactly. And not stepping on the trees as well.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; Twitter @Reynolds_PG. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.