So, you may remember the Elvis Costello fiasco of 2017.
The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame legend played Heinz Hall on the Imperial Bedroom Tour and the sound mix was so horrid it seemed at times as though Costello and the band were playing two different songs, or at least at different points in the same song.
Having gone in with great expectations and memories of his last Cultural District show in ’82 (at the Stanley, now Benedum), I was deeply disappointed in the cacophony, as I noted in the review. Later that day, I was surprised to see a long Facebook post from him taking issue with my complaints about the sound and contending that I did not understand the wild, free spirit of live rock ’n’ roll.
“You could also take the view that rock and roll must sometimes be distorted, confusing and even confounding for the practitioners and the audience alike,” he wrote. “I'm sure there are some nice calm records in your collection that you could listen to that don't talk back.”
On Saturday, Costello was back on Facebook once again talking audio quality, addressing a sound problem the Imposters had at Philharmonic Hall in Liverpool. He wrote, “To say it was my worst nightmare that things would go so badly wrong after we took the stage, would be a massive understatement. The Imposters and I had rehearsed at length in the afternoon to prepare a unique setlist for the Liverpool show.
“The sound was perfectly in balance…In the first part of the show, the band and I were blissfully unaware of the sound issues in the house, as we were moving swiftly from song-to-song. Unfortunately, the reason for the technical problem was not very easily determined but it was certainly nothing to do with the competence of our excellent sound engineer, who was working as hard as possible to fix the mystery glitch.”
Read More
Maybe we had the same mystery glitch.
He goes on to say, “When people start yelling at me at work — at first, incoherently — I tend to get a little testy. I’m sure you have known times at the Phil when people — perhaps befuddled by drink — have tried to insert themselves into the show but in this case I must apologize for my sharp and rather graceless reaction but adrenaline and emotion were running high.”
In one of the top comments on the post, a guy who was in the fourth row notes that he thought the sound was OK and that the vocals were helped by a mic switch after the fourth song. But, he also points out that he talked to other people at the show who were in fact befuddled and frustrated by the sound.
Getting back to Elvis’ attack on me: Over the last 30 years, I’ve likely seen more bands and more varieties of bands than he has, and they can be loose and sloppy (Replacements, Rancid, Neil Young) or note perfect (Steely Dan, Rush) but the bottom line is that without a decent sound mix, you got nuthin’.
It happened recently with Cloud Nothings and PUP at the Roxian. While PUP sounded great, Cloud Nothings was all drums and vocals, no guitar, and they could have brought out the ghost of Elvis Presley himself but nothing was going to overcome that.
All that said, I do like the fact that Costello is passionate about this and cares enough to take to social media with these intense and entertaining posts.
• Elvis’ longtime producer, Nick Lowe, promised a Quality Rock & Roll Revue here with Los Straitjackets — I almost typed Los Lobos (that would work, too) — and that’s what his devoted fans got Thursday night at Dollar Bank Three Rivers Arts Festival.
Playing to a crowd that was like an Electric Banana reunion — members of The Cynics, Frampton Brothers, Pleasure Heads, Spuds and more scattered about — the 73-year-old icon came off like the Mister Rogers of British rock ’n’ roll. It was as regal and gentlemanly as power-pop gets, while being truly endearing.
Classics like “So It Goes,” “Cruel to be Kind” and “I Knew The Bride (When She Used to Rock and Roll” were slowed down a notch, or two or three, and “(What’s So Funny ‘Bout) Peace, Love and Understanding” was like a lullaby compared to the Elvis version, but Lowe maintains a certain charm and comforting quality to his voice.
When he left the stage midway — jokingly noting that he was gonna “have a bath” — the Straitjackets straight up killed it with five surf-rock instrumentals, including their perfect take on Shocking Blue’s “Venus.”
The two great tastes made them a splendid choice for a festival like this.
One last thing: While it would be far more preferable to be chilling in Point State Park, with the shock of the 9th and Penn relocation having worn off, the location didn’t seem as bad on a return trip. And the sound was just fine.
• Sadly, the compelling Western PA bill of String Machine and The Homeless Gospel Choir hit a COVID glitch over the weekend.
One of the members of the String Machine crew tested positive for COVID, forcing the Butler indie-rock band to cancel five shows.
The tour is supposed to wrap at Spirit in Lawrenceville on Saturday, serving as the release party for the vinyl version of String Machine’s superb new album, “Hallelujah Hell Yeah.” As of now, that show is up in the air.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.