Bill Deasy has long been a singer-songwriter who takes both of those words very seriously.
With each new album, fans know to expect from The Gathering Field frontman a golden glow to the vocals and narrative and poetry running through the verses. On “If the Creek Don’t Rise,” his first new record in six years, Deasy once again delivers, offering a portrait of the sensitive rogue who comes to a reckoning with the album’s lush closer, “Rushing Water.”
The ninth solo album from the Pittsburgh native was recorded over four days in November at the Brooklyn studio of bassist-keyboardist Jeremy McDonald, with guitarist Chris Parker and drummer Dave Throckmorton, who have all played in Deasy’s solo band.
He went up there with about a dozen songs — three of which were co-written with Kim Richey or Maia Sharp, who both provide harmony vocals — and an open mind about how this tight group would bring them to life. Parker, he says, set the tone with his pensive playing on the first song they tackled, “Highway One,” which Deasy released on a live album with The Gathering Field last year.
By the time he and Throckmorton drove back, they had created yet another gem in an impressive catalog that started in 1994 with The Gathering Field’s debut album for Atlantic Records and has moved between band and solo albums since then.
Last week, Deasy talked about the album, which will be released on Tuesday and celebrated with a release show at The Oaks Theater on April 22.
The last time we talked was the live album, on which you had debuted the new song, “Highway One.” And now it turns up here.
Yeah, that song is kind of a good indicator of the whole process for this record. We weren’t really planning on doing that live album, so that just came out of nowhere. And when I decided to record new music, I wanted to include that song because I really liked it and I even thought we’d kind of cop The Gathering Field arrangement, which is a little more driving. We didn’t think too much about it. We just kind of soundchecked it and played it one night and it happened to end up on the live record. So, I sent that to the guys that I was doing this record with, thinking that we would kind of just do that arrangement, and that was the first song we recorded.
And it took a different direction?
Yeah, Dave Throckmorton and I drove from Pittsburgh to Brooklyn on a Wednesday in November, and that evening we just dug into that song. And from the very beginning, Chris Parker, who played guitar and keyboard and stuff, he just had a different thought for it. He grabbed an acoustic guitar and started to play it with a whole different feel and sensibility. And I respect Chris so much, and I’m so kind of open to new ways of doing what I've done forever, so he just took it to this different place and it became a much more vulnerable kind of raw, bare presentation of the lyrics, which I think works well for that song. So, it kind of set us off to the races.
It must be cool to have songs that you can perform in different ways. Makes me think of Springsteen, who does that a lot.
Yeah. I think in those terms partly because I perform so often with a band but a lot by myself. So I have a lot of songs like that. But, yeah, it’s a good sign for a song if it can hold up to different arrangements, not just playing it on acoustic guitar, but like a whole different kind of feel.
So, over what period of time were these songs written?
Well, that gets more confusing as I do this longer. Some of them were written a long time ago, like “Rushing Water,” which is the last song on the record. I wrote it with Kim Richey the first time I ever wrote with her, which was in, I think, 1999. She and I met in Nashville one night and had dinner and then the next day we wrote a song called “So it Goes,” which we both recorded, and then “Rushing Water.” Then every time she’d come through town or we’d play random shows, we would perform that song sometimes and we always loved it.
Strange that you never recorded it.
Well, there are a lot of songs like that, that for whatever reason, they didn’t fit in. But Kim and I just happened to play last October and it refreshed my memory of “Rushing Water” and another song I did on this record called “I Tried,” which was written many, many years ago also. I was starting to have this kind of arc in mind, thematically, and those songs really played into it. So, some songs were old like that and then some songs. … It’s been six years since my last record of new music, so a handful were just during COVID-19 in my basement when I wasn’t really leaving the house, but a few were before that, but it was all just kind of songs that I felt fit into this idea for what this record would be.
Let's talk about that. The narrator on this record is an interesting character. I get this feeling of the sensitive rogue, which is kind of an unusual album character.
That’s funny. That’s been my character. In a way, a song like “Lost in America” — the guy puts up his collar to the cold and he’s waiting for a sign and he’s kind of a poser, but you could call him a sensitive rogue. That’s kind of been a consistent character for me.
It’s kind of like you’re doing your woman wrong, but you feel bad about it.
For sure. Yeah. Yes. But I was meaning to start with that but then kind of evolve into some, like, personal growth, that kind of comes from this time of life that I’m in, when you’re kind of reckoning with your own demons a bit more, kind of like with mortality starting to become a real thing.
So, this character, he’s doing what you said, but then he’s also kind of looking at himself in the mirror pretty honestly. And then about halfway through the record, on a song called “Changing Hands,” he’s sort of saying, “I need to try a different way of functioning. This hand is not working. I’ve really messed things up with this hand.” And then on “Better Angels,” it kind of takes a turn, and the emotional centerpiece of the whole thing is “A House Divided,” which is pretty deep introspection. It’s that character, and me, looking at myself and saying, “Why am I the way I am?” and just saying it out loud so I can start to change it more aggressively.
And then the last two songs on the record are a little more peaceful and hopeful, to where “Rushing Water” is kind of like this ideal that I want and kind of crave in myself and in my marriage and everything, where it’s just sort of like peace and comfort. A friend of mine recently called it “getting into the land of the long married,” and being in that peaceful place of the long married. And that’s kind of where I am.
Like the old couple that can sit in the diner and not talk to each other?
Yes, that’s exactly that. [laughs]
Only here, it’s a little more romantic, at a waterfall.
Yeah.
So, if you were, like, Jackson Browne or something, I would ask you how close to real life this all is for you or whether you’re writing fiction, but being that you're a local guy…
Really, to be honest with you, there’s no such thing as fiction for me. Even when it is fiction, it’s not fiction and it’s always kind of been that way. But, songwriting is tricky for me because I can sometimes, through my career, use songs as a way to kind of play a part, you know, not only in a song but also just in my real life. I can be that poser of the sensitive artist guy who’s really figured some things out. That’s a persona that I can inhabit and kind of exploit.
So, this record is kind of different in the sense that all that kind of pretense and confusion about who’s who, here this is more just a raw presentation of myself. I mean, there’s still stories. It’s always like a balance between stories and the literal truth of myself, probably leaning a little more on the story than the literal truth, but it’s more transparent — the wall between those two things is less cement now and more glass.
Obviously, there’s a real sense of craftsmanship to your songs. What is the balance, as they say, between inspiration and perspiration?
I’m a weird paradox, cause I’m very inspiration-driven, especially nowadays I don’t just sit down every day to write songs. So it kind of has to be something that forces its way out of me through the chaos of life. But, it’s a combination. I’ve gotten so comfortable with the way that I write and the way that I musically process my emotions that I can just be like an open channel when I’m in that mode.
So, a bunch of stuff might come out of me, and depending on the nature of the song, I can be very inclined to just not mess with it — ’cause I can just feel like I’m saying what I needed to say, so it’s not “crafted.” But then there's the other kind of song where that inspiration comes and that burst comes and then there is a lot of hard work to it after that.
So like a song like “Highway One,” for example, I had the idea for a song about a night that my new bride and I were driving on Highway 1, back when we were married. I had that idea for a while and little couplets or whatever would come to me, out of nowhere — and you have to honor them when they come. It's such pleasurable work when it’s leading to a satisfying place for me that I don't think of it that way. But it’s hard to even tell where the inspiration ends and the work begins ’cause it’s just all so thrilling and so satisfying when I get to a place that I feel so good about. “Highway One,” every word in that song I just feel very connected to and happy with.
Do you ever change lyrics in the studio or do you pretty much stick with what you have?
Oh, I absolutely do. I change lyrics in the studio and I’ll change them again 10 years after. Sometimes I’ll just have a nagging thought that something is a little bit off. But, like the song “Better Angels” on this record, I didn’t really have the chorus exactly right, and it was like, “Oh, man, we’re gonna do this now?” and I kind of just hammered out some words, which is a little unusual for me.
I was just reflecting today that it’s a different phase of life when you're in a touring band, and you’re making records, and you’re playing all the time with this band. The record is more like a document of where you are as a band and it’s a whole different dynamic when you know you’re going to be playing them out a thousand times and it’s going to change and whatever. But now that I don't tour so much and perform less than I used to, a record becomes a different thing. It’s like a piece of work that I have to think hard about because this is what I’m using now to express myself and it’s less about the live show.
Right. So, anything else that you wanted to say about it?
Oh, I just had one other thought recently. I was remembering the U2 song “Running to Stand Still.” For some reason that title just came back to me and I sing that song every now and then, and I was just thinking that that’s kind of what this record is. The first few songs are about, like, running and traveling and driving, like leaving and fleeing and being that rogue who did something wrong but feels sad about it, and then it ends with “Starting to Remember” and “Rushing Water.” And it just kind of hit me that that’s kind of what my life has been a little bit, running to stand still, and then I want to just, you know, be still now, so that’s kind of cool.
Deasy performs at The Oaks Theater at 7:30 p.m. April 22. Admission is $18; $75 table. Go to Deasy’s Facebook page for info.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.