Erroll Garner might be the best jazz pianist you've never heard of.

A Pittsburgher who built a towering reputation playing clubs and riverboats before heading to the Big Apple, Garner was a giant of the industry in the 1950s and ’60s and the composer of the jazz standard “Misty.” Though he stood only 5 foot 2, he had enough stature to flip the recording industry on its head in a lawsuit for the ages. All the while, he worked his magic at the keyboard, sitting atop a pair of phone books.

In June, the Erroll Garner Project, an organization dedicated to increasing his standing in the music world, kicked off a yearlong celebration of the pianist's centennial year with a new box set called “Liberation in Swing” ($149.98). It includes some of his greatest recorded music as well as some previously unheard clips from the archive, which is housed at the University of Pittsburgh.

“Erroll Garner was the most famous jazz musician not named Louis Armstrong during his lifetime,” said Peter Lockhart, senior producer for Octave Music, which produces Garner's music.

Advertise with us

“He's able to hold you in the palm of his hand due to his level of control in a way that few have done since.”

Garner’s genius is not only recognized in the jazz world. Most recently, Adele, the wildly popular English singer/songwriter, included a Garner interlude in her forthcoming album, “30.”

Garner died in 1977 at age 55, yet his popularity is rising and his streaming numbers and album sales have grown significantly in the last few years, Lockhart said. He recommends the 2016 album "Ready Take One," available on Spotify, as a place for listeners new to Garner's music to get started.

Despite a complicated personal life, particularly his relationship with his manager, Martha Glaser, Garner's playing was described nearly universally as “joyful.” He was a master pianist who never learned to read music, an expert in multiple styles of jazz whose ears seemed directly connected to his fingers.

Famous as he was during his heyday, his reputation dropped off a cliff after he died, so much so that he didn't appear at all in Ken Burns exhaustive, nearly 20-hour documentary about jazz.

Advertise with us

What happened to this piano colossus?

Noteworthy career

Born June 15, 1921, Garner grew up in East Liberty and attended George Westinghouse High School along with other famous pianists Billy Strayhorn and Ahmad Jamal. A child prodigy, he started playing on the radio at the age of 7 and on riverboats at age 11.

“Some of the clubs he played couldn't accommodate a drummer and base player, so he wore cleats and banged his feet on the ground to keep time,” said Robin Kelley, a professor of history at the University of California, Los Angeles.

“This upset the owner, who put a rug under him. He just did it anyway.”

Advertise with us

Garner developed a rhythmic style of playing in his left hand that he maintained throughout his career. He struck out for New York City in 1944, quickly landing gigs with Charlie Parker and other big names due to his skill.

“What Garner does is he shows that there's joy in this music, even though he's serious as a heart attack,” said Kelley, who hosts the new podcast, “Erroll Garner Uncovered.”

“Joy is also about surprise, and the beauty of jazz is playing the unexpected. That element of surprise is baked into the way he improvised on a song.

“He'd improvise these introductions where you'd wait for the song to drop — it's better than being in Times Square on New Year's Eve — just BOOM! He hits the ground running.”

Kelley, who recommends the album “Feeling is Believing” as a place to start listening, said the inherent joy and melodic basis of Garner's music likely contributed to historians overlooking his contributions. The ’50s and ’60s were the height of America’s artistic modernist period, when critics and artists were turning toward more “serious,” avante-garde styles of music.

Advertise with us

Garner didn't shy away from the new, but his music remained rooted in melody.

His reputation was also diminished by the lawsuit he and his manager filed against Columbia Records in the late 1950s. Garner’s output was of a quantity and quality that he and Glaser decided he should start his own recording label, which is common now but was far rarer and riskier back then.

At the first breach of contract by Columbia, Garner and Glaser sued, starting an acrimonious, years-long dispute that ultimately wound up in the New York Supreme Court.

The court found in favor of Garner and Glaser, effectively wresting artistic control from a large record label and putting it in the hands of the artist for the first time. It was a David vs. Goliath battle that continues today, Lockhart said.

“It's really inspiring ... the commodification of art and ownership of someone's art. He was ahead of his time.”

Advertise with us

Garner and Glaser founded Octave Records in 1960, and after the court’s decision, the pair owned all of the masters from his recordings. Octave Records still owns Garner's music, allowing the Erroll Garner Project to continue remastering and releasing new material and recordings.

Erroll’s legacy

“I think part of his relative disappearance was payback from the label,” Kelley said. “Columbia didn't have the power to simply punish him singularly, but it earned the pair a reputation for being difficult to work with.”

He noted that music historians often treat jazz history as a linear progression, when sub-genres were in actuality evolving and developing simultaneously. Garner straddled many styles of playing — he doesn't easily fit into a single category.

“And if he doesn't fit, he fades,” Kelley said.

Advertise with us

Lockhart is working on reshape Garner's legacy by developing and releasing recordings. Kelley does it through historical essays and his podcast. In Pittsburgh, James Johnson, founder of the African American Music Institute and director of the University of Pittsburgh's Gospel Choir, has big ideas for celebrating Garner’s legacy in his hometown.

“My goodness, everybody and their mama knows the song ‘Misty,’” he said. “To highlight Errol Garner in Pittsburgh is a no-brainer. History has not done him justice.”

Johnson, who was instrumental in bringing the Garner archive to Pitt, said he's begun working to put together an Erroll Garner Festival with local high schools and bands.

“Pittsburgh needs to capture the essence of what Pittsburgh was,” he said. “There's a lot of history here that people don't realize.”

Garner is part of that history, and Johnson and the Erroll Garner Project are continuing to working to correct the narrative and restore him to his rightful position once more.

Advertise with us

“A lot of younger artists are discovering him for the first time and realizing that the way he was categorized was wrong,” Kelley said. “He's not playing standards the standard ways, and in many ways he was ahead of his time. This is why Garner’s always being rediscovered.”

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; Twitter: @Reynolds_PG. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.