More churches use “praise teams” than pipe organs these days, but that doesn’t mean the “king of instruments” or its vassals are disappearing anytime soon.
“It’s the ultimate hipster instrument just waiting to be discovered,” said Montreal-based filmmaker Stacey Tenenbaum, who spent more than half a year filming young organists for a documentary.
“It’s handmade, there’re lots of technical audio issues to geek out about, it’s very niche — it ticks off the right boxes,” she joked.
The organ’s history and current practice are still largely tied to religious institutions as many different faiths call for organ music. Yet there are plenty of secular recital series and competitions, and many organists don’t consider themselves religious.
At 10 p.m. Monday, PBS will air and stream Ms. Tenenbaum’s documentary, “Pipe Dreams,” which probes the quirky world of competitive organ playing at the 2017 Canadian International Organ Competition. More than $100,000 in prize money is doled out every three years in the competition.
“Churches still provide the stability,” said Nicholas Capozzoli, a Scott native who is featured in Ms. Tenenbaum’s documentary. “That’s historical — even Bach held a church job.”
(Johann Sebastian Bach is one of classical music’s most revered names and remains a bit of a patron saint for organ performance and composition.)
Competing in the 2017 Canadian International kicked Mr. Capozzoli’s performance career into a higher gear. He was scouted by an artist management company and began playing more high-profile gigs, though he continues to return home every summer to give recitals in Pittsburgh. This summer will be an exception due to COVID-19, as almost all recital series are on hold.
“It’s not really feasible to be a traveling, full-time solo organist,” he said.
Mr. Capozzoli, 26, said he’s currently looking for a full-time position with a church and hopes to find a teaching position at a university, as well. He’ll continue to tour and perform recitals on the side.
“In a church job, we perform services, conduct choir, teach, do administrative work and even compose,” said Chaz Bowers, dean of the Pittsburgh chapter of the American Guild of Organists.
Mr. Bowers is director of music for the combined South Hills parishes of St. Bernard and Our Lady of Grace, where he plays for weddings and funerals, and he teaches at Duquesne University on the side.
The American Guild of Organists has upward of 15,000 members around the world; the Pittsburgh chapter has about 300 active members. They’re a mixture of performers, technicians and people who simply like organ music.
The Steel City hosts a renowned collection of pipe organs, ranging from historic to cutting edge. They include the Heinz Memorial Chapel organ, a 1995 Reuters Opus 2176 with 4,272 pipes. There is a healthy recital culture at local churches, with small but dedicated audiences typically numbering 75-125 each.
Mr. Bowers said many church positions, especially those at larger and more urban churches, pay a full-time salary as well as health care and benefits. Part of the guild’s mission is to stump for better compensation for church organists.
“Churches have historically been notorious about not paying musicians as well as they should,” noted Anthony Thurman, director of development and communications for the American Guild of Organists. “This goes all the way back to [Dietrich] Buxtehude [a composer and mentor of Bach], who was also the bookkeeper for his church.”
According to Mr. Thurman, guild membership is down from roughly 20,000 members in the early 2000s, though not every organist is a guild member. He said Americans are less likely to join guilds and community organizations now and that church attendance is generally declining. The bigger concern for organists is more churches pivoting to nontraditional “hum and strum” groups, he said.
“This comes down to whether the leaders of a church have good musical taste, and unfortunately there aren’t very many seminaries that are training their pastors in music.”
Mr. Thurman said he believes modern praise music has a place in worship services, but he doesn’t think it fits traditional services aesthetically or acoustically.
“If you have a building with vaulted ceilings and stained-glass windows, a praise band might not really fit,” he said. “There’s a time to put real flowers on the church altar instead of plastic ones. There’s a time and place for different kinds of music.”
Organists with church positions sometimes do not share the same religious affiliation as their employer, which can lead to conflict between personal belief and occupation. Some organists have no personal religious affiliation.
“Some simply say they’re expressing their faith through music,” Mr. Bowers said.
Mr. Thurman said he finds it “a bit disingenuous to help others worship and share their faith if you don’t share that faith.” He has seen organists lose church jobs because they brought their atheism to work and others who were let go after coming out as gay. Some Christian denominations are supportive of same-sex rights, while others ban homosexuality for their leaders and members.
“It happens all the time, but it’s not talked about,” Mr. Thurman said.
Some organists belong to theater organ groups and play for historic silent film houses. The Pittsburgh Area Theatre Organ Society, which celebrates its 50th anniversary this year, notes that the city has only one functional theater organ. The rest, including the one in Downtown’s Heinz Hall, were destroyed in a 1936 flood. The society programs a handful of concerts per year.
Ms. Tenenbaum, the filmmaker, said she fell in love with the power and variety of the instrument and its subculture.
“Some of these kids had to practice alone in these huge, spooky churches at night,” she said, explaining that practicing during the day could be problematic because of an organ’s volume and proximity to church offices.
“Organ music itself can be a bit spooky,” she said. “But there’s an infinite range of sounds and some of the newer organ composers out there are just really, really cool.”
“Pipe Dreams” is also available to stream on Amazon Prime — $4.99 to rent, $12.99 to buy.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.