Chamber Music Pittsburgh has hosted some of the best concerts in the city in recent years, presenting Imani Winds, the Artemis Quartet and violinist Noah Bendix-Balgley in some wondrous displays of musicianship.
The organization has also presented a few ensembles that had me scratching my head as to why they were included in the series alongside such talent. The inconsistency in quality was jarring, but it turns out there is a reason: Chamber Music Pittsburgh locked itself into multiyear contracts with some string quartets for years. This was a mistake. While building up name recognition isn’t a bad idea, it began to feel repetitive and stale and didn’t allow the organization to evolve to meet the changing needs of the city.
Monday at the Carnegie Music Hall in Oakland was the last concert of the multiyear contracts. This is excellent news. First, it means that the leaders at Chamber Music Pittsburgh are now free to program fresh talent. Second, the organization is no longer beholden to chamber groups that may have passed their prime.
The Orion String Quartet is well loved in this city. The violinists are brothers whose father played with the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra for years, and Orion has returned often over the quartet’s 30-year history. But, with all due respect to the group’s impressive history and national renown, Monday’s concert of Haydn, Kreisler and Beethoven was not excellent.
It wasn’t bad either. The musicians often captured the spirit and enthusiasm of the music, and this is more important than the technical considerations. That said, their playing simply wasn’t in tune or perfectly in sync much of the time. The Haydn in particular felt lifeless, while the Kreisler and the Beethoven Viola Quintet (featuring guest violist Catherine Cho) were strong but not dazzling. Fast, technical runs were blurry, downbeats were just a few milliseconds off. Balances were top heavy and the cello sounded thin even in passionate solo moments.
The group’s recordings don’t have these issues, and Orion continues to perform in chamber music series around the country. Perhaps Monday was atypical for the group. (Then again, I had similar objections to their last appearance in the city in 2017.) But looking ahead to the Brooklyn Rider Quartet and a joint appearance by pianist Emmanuel Ax and Pamela Frank, the lack of precision on Monday seemed out of place.
Read More
Chamber Music Pittsburgh once programmed primarily string quartets on its subscription series. The organization is expanding beyond such strict programming and redefining the role of a chamber music organization in the city. Wind quintets, mixed ensembles, vocalists and even dancers are appearing, but there’s always another group to consider. Has Pittsburgh ever hosted the Kronos Quartet? Or the Gould Piano Trio? The Canadian Brass?
Also worth noting, the organization has in recent years begun programming local artists in unusual venues like Construction Junction for its “Pittsburgh Performs” series as well as a casual summer series at the Ace Hotel. Executive Director Kristen Linfante said it is exploring the possibility of moving the subscription series to a more intimate location. Carnegie Music Hall holds about 1,900 people and the chamber music concerts draw an average of about 650 listeners — a strong number for a chamber music series.
A final note, Chamber Music Pittsburgh announced Monday that it had quietly raised funds to purchase a new pair of instruments for a refugee family that lost a violin and cello in a fire.
Here is a forward-thinking organization trying to cast off from a traditional past by meeting potential listeners where they are.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.