It takes a village to produce a new opera — a village and more than $1 million for a major work.
Pittsburgh Opera has demonstrated a strong commitment to new works in recent seasons, but the opera has struggled to get its latest large project off the ground.
Back in 2017, when Pittsburgh Opera premiered its first major new opera, “The Summer King: The Josh Gibson Story,” general director Christopher Hahn said the opera company was “waving [its] flag proudly,” showing it could successfully produce a large scale new work.
The opera expected to deliver a second major new production, “Bhutto” — a dramatic treatment of the history of Pakistan’s Bhutto political dynasty — this coming November. However, “Bhutto” has been removed from next season’s lineup and put on hiatus primarily due to lack of funding, according to the opera.
At this stage, it is unknown whether “Bhutto” will ever appear at the Benedum Center.
Grande moolah
Pittsburgh Opera has a reputation for good fiscal sense and regularly operates in the black.
A major opera like “Bhutto” involves hiring vocal soloists, chorus and a large orchestra in addition to creating new sets and costumes. While premieres rarely translate into additional ticket sales, the reputational benefits of putting on new work are numerous, like additional funding opportunities, collaboration with other companies and national buzz.
“New work enlivens us, fights the stereotype that opera is old and stuffy and speaks directly to our time,” said Marc Scorca, president and CEO of New York-based service organization Opera America. “There’s a vitality at any opera company when doing a new work because you’re creating something.”

The 80-year-old Pittsburgh Opera, considered a “Budget 2” company based on its operating budget size of around $7.4 million, established a relationship with New York-based composer Mohammed Fairouz in 2015 when the company produced his chamber opera, “Sumeida’s Song.” That relationship led to the co-commissioning of “Bhutto.”
Funding for large new operas typically comes from donations and partnerships with other companies or producers. To develop “Bhutto,” Pittsburgh Opera joined with several individuals and Beth Morrison Projects, a New York company that identifies and develops cutting-edge new theatrical works.
In November 2018, the company scheduled a workshop and invited the composer, librettist, some press and a small group of potential donors.
A full read-through like this is a typical part of the creative process, but this workshop was more than just a test run. It was a chance to show “Bhutto” off to potential backers and raise public awareness of the project, something that Mr. Fairouz said he was not aware of until he arrived in Pittsburgh.
“The workshop was misrepresented to me,” he said in a phone interview.
He understood the event to be an artistic opportunity and said he was caught off guard when he was asked to sit for press interviews and fundraising events.
The opera, which began planning to produce the opera in 2015, had yet to raise the amount of money necessary to produce “Bhutto.”
Finding a fortune
Pittsburgh Opera’s first large production, “The Summer King,” focused on local baseball legend Josh Gibson of the Negro Leagues. That provided a Pittsburgh-specific funding hook to help raise the $1.2 million the production cost. The opera did not host a similar workshop/fundraiser for “The Summer King.”
“Bhutto,” an intimate portrayal of a divisive Benazir Bhutto, of Pakistan, did not have the same local pull.
“I was surprised we hit a wall,” said Beth Morrison, president and creative producer of Beth Morrison Projects. “It’s obviously extremely disappointing for Mohammed and me as largest contributor and creative producer.”

Ms. Morrison said that Mr. Hahn had successfully helped raise funds for major new works at other companies — he formerly worked for Los Angeles Opera and San Francisco Opera.
“I acknowledge Christopher’s challenge, and he was working very hard to make it happen,” she said. “But it’s not something he’s had a lot of experience doing in Pittsburgh.”
Shortly after the November workshop, Mr. Hahn told Mr. Fairouz that the opera might be delayed due to lack of funding.
Mr. Fairouz has been paid, but composers have vested artistic stakes in wanting the public to hear their work. He said he was working to identify funding through his own contacts, and that he had identified a funder for the opera. Mr. Hahn said funding did not come together in time to program the opera next season. The deadline was late December.
“We did discuss whether Momo [Mohammed] was able to identify any further funding, and he offered to do so, but the tight deadline passed without any funders being confirmed to me and we had to proceed with alternate plans to finalize the replacement in the upcoming season.”
In place of “Bhutto,” Pittsburgh Opera announced that it will produce Daniel Catan’s 1996 Spanish-language opera “Florencia en el Amazonas” next season.
Opera in progress
Mr. Hahn also said that the November workshop identified areas of the opera that needed additional development, and that this was also a concern.
Ms. Morrison, a seasoned shepherd of new operatic productions, said that the quality of the work is top notch, and that after hearing the workshop the creative team knew exactly what needed to be developed further.
“This opera will be absolutely spectacular,” she said.
Mr. Fairouz, a 33-year-old American composer based in New York City whose works receive regular performances around the country, also agreed that the opera needed revision and said that he had ample time to complete the necessary changes.
He is continuing to work on the opera, and he said that Pittsburgh Opera did not formally acknowledge that the premiere had been pushed back to him or his publisher after the funding deadline passed.
“I want to emphasize that I have not received, nor have my publishers received any communication from Pittsburgh Opera since the time of the workshop,” he said.
Mr. Scorca, of Opera America, said that while delays in premieres are not unusual, it is important to maintain clarity behind postponements so that people aren’t left in the dark.
“Thorough communication is essential,” he said.
Dramatic future
Delayed does not necessarily mean it is canceled. Pittsburgh Opera could still produce the opera in a future season, as the company still holds the premiere rights.
At this stage, it is more likely that another company will produce the opera, according to Ms. Morrison, who explained that the commission has been paid by her company, Pittsburgh Opera and the other developmental partners. She said that Beth Morrison Projects was having conversations with other companies about staging “Bhutto.”
“It’s fully developed, a very attractive thing for someone to pick up,” she said.
Mr. Hahn said that if Beth Morrison Projects had another company interested in premiering “Bhutto” he’d have the opportunity to decide whether to bow out or not.
“If additional development takes place in a timely fashion it’ll proceed here,” Mr. Hahn said. “If not, I’m not sure I can envision putting it on the Benedum stage, though I could see it in a smaller venue.”
Moving “Bhutto” to a smaller opera would reduce it to more of a chamber opera. While premiering chamber operas is laudable, it does not generate the same prestige as producing a major work.
“Premiering a new work is a special skill set,” Mr. Scorca said. “How do you structure workshops, how do you critique, how do you superintend the design of an opera that isn’t finished yet? There are some companies that acknowledge that they don’t have the skill set but will give a work that important second or third performance.”
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.