If you attend a Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra concert, you might bump into a musician in the lobby of Heinz Hall before the show. They’re out there to talk to you, to answer your questions and chat about the music.
This is a recent development.
If you stay after the show you can enjoy a chamber music performance in the hall — a bit of extra music and a pleasant way to wait out the post-concert traffic scramble. This also is new.
There’s a new concert format, a new partnership with City of Asylum bookstore to present free concerts, a new Young Professionals Club for those ages 21 to 35 and more at the PSO this year.
It’s been a year since the musician’s strike ended, a year since musicians and management agreed on a new five-year contract and set about trying to demonstrate to Pittsburgh the value and relevance of having a top tier orchestra in the Steel City.The question is, have they been successful?
What happened?
The new initiatives are intended to preserve the orchestra’s future, both fiscal and artistic. The aim is to deepen the orchestra’s bonds with the Pittsburgh public and to increase attendance at Heinz Hall programming, which the PSO hopes will encourage more patrons to support their orchestra. These are standard goals for any orchestra, but the PSO’s need for community support was thrown into sharp relief by last year’s labor dispute.
In 2016, management developed a five-year strategic plan to enhance the orchestra’s community impact and fiscal stability and assessed the organization’s finances.
In examining audits and projecting five years ahead, symphony management came to believe that the orchestra’s retirement plan would lead the organization deep into debt in only a few years. This shortfall would be exacerbated by the loss of two significant revenue streams. Management projected multimillion dollar deficits in the coming years, up to $20.4 million over the next five years.
The initial contract proposal from management aimed to cut musician salaries by 25 percent.
The musicians — members of the Local 60-471 chapter of the American Federation of Musicians — disputed management’s projections. Strenuously.
The musicians went on strike on Sept. 30, 2016, only the second time in the organization’s 122-year history.

After management canceled six weeks of concerts, musicians and management jointly paid for an independent report from a guest scholar of the Brookings Institution. The report concluded that there was a financial crisis, but that the musicians weren’t overpaid. It stated that the PSO had been relying too heavily on large contributions from a few key donors.
“Both sides hated the report,” said PSO bassist Micah Howard, the orchestra committee chairman during the dispute. “What this all came down to was nobody was on the same page. I think I can say the report helped overcome that.”
Tony Bucci, vice chairman of the PSO’s board, concurred with the report’s assessment.
“There was always an expectation that an angel would come in and bail the symphony out, and I think the musicians, the board, management and even the community all shared that entitlement,” Mr. Bucci said. “But that’s no way to survive. Last year, right, wrong, agree, disagree, ugly or nice, we confronted our problems.”
Finances
The current contract cut the musicians’ salaries by 10.5 (reduced to 7.5 percent thanks to an anonymous, “angelic” donation) for the first three years with restoration to their 2016 base salary of $107,240 in year five. The contract also reduced the administrative budget by 10.5 percent.
“The musicians have sacrificed $3.8 million over the life of this contract, which has given us some runway to change the trajectory of the organization,” said Melia Tourangeau, PSO president and CEO.
The salary cut knocked the PSO’s base salary from ninth highest to 12th highest in the country.
Musical pay scales A base salary for an orchestral musician is only a starting point — principal players negotiate for higher pay. The Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra dropped from ninth to 12th place after last year’s strike. However, cost of living factors, such as median housing costs, directly impact how far a salary will go. Comparing our orchestra’s compensation to another’s should take into account more than just the base salary. TOP 15 ORCHESTRAL BASE SALARIES, 2017-18 SEASON
Created with Highstock 6.0.3$166400$166400$164476$164476$159016$159016$153400$153400$146815$146815$143208$143208$135096$135096$133737$133737$104728$104728$103314$103314$99527$99527$99197$99197$97240$97240$94308$94308$90600$90600$864300$864300$612400$612400$213300$213300$430200$430200$427300$427300$384500$384500$136400$136400$218800$218800$247400$247400$153900$153900$213000$213000$138900$138900$182100$182100$142200$142200$453100$453100Orchestral salariesMedian housing pricesSan FransiscoLos AngelesChicagoBostonNew YorkNationalClevelandPhiladelphiaMinnesotaCincinnatiDallasPittsburghHoustonDetroitSeattle$0$100000$200000$300000$400000$500000$600000$700000$800000$900000$1000000
*2016/2017 data Source: International Conference of Symphony and Opera Musicians, Zillow; Research: Jeremy Reynolds, Graphic: Ed Yozwick
All parties approved a $31.7 million budget for the 2016-17 in January that included a $1 million deficit. The orchestra came through slightly better than anticipated after achieving the second-best annual fund in the symphony’s history; Ms. Tourangeau estimated the deficit will actually be about $800,000.
Ultimately, the PSO needs to raise $75 million over the next five years to raise musician salaries to their 2016 levels, a 32 percent growth in the annual fund, according to Ms. Tourangeau.
“We’ve done it before,” she said. “We gotta do it again.”
The organization’s budget this year is $31.1 million with a $127 million endowment. The orchestra is reducing its draw by a 10th of a percent a year moving forward. The organization also has secured significant multi-year funding from local foundations this year.
Culture change
Emerging from the dispute, the PSO said it would renew its commitment to the Pittsburgh community and demonstrate the value and relevance of having a top-tier resident orchestra.
“We’ve always cared about the community; we’ve always been involved and active outside of Heinz Hall,” said Susanne Park, PSO violinist and chairwoman of the orchestra committee. “But we want to do more, and we want to show the community how much we appreciate them.”
In October, the musicians performed their second annual Day of Music, a smattering of free pop-up style concerts around the city. The first Day of Music took place during the strike last year, as musicians put on a number of concerts themselves.

In September, the musicians held a 5k run to raise funds for their education programs, and they’ve partnered for years with 412 Food Rescue.
The symphony also is adjusting the internal relationship between musicians, board and staff, so those three legs of the organization can work more closely together than prior to the strike.
Ms. Tourangeau has begun sending detailed weekly status updates to the entire organization about the activities and finances of the orchestra. Staff and board members will be occasionally invited to sit onstage during rehearsals to learn more about the musicians’ work.
While last year’s dispute damaged relationships between musicians and management, all sides said this increased cooperation, communication and accountability was a step to ensure that last year’s blindside wouldn’t be repeated.
“No one’s happy,” Mr. Bucci, the board member, said. “But everyone’s focused. Everyone’s in the game now.”
Management has added two new positions (a manager of digital marketing and a videographer) to help spread the word about the orchestra’s community endeavors.
Pittsburgh’s orchestra
The PSO experienced increased attendance after the strike last year — roughly 1,800 out of more than 2,600 seats per concert for the classical subscription series compared to roughly 1,400 in 2015. Last year’s numbers are somewhat artificial due to canceling concerts in the beginning of the season.
The symphony must raise a significant and increasing amount of money to bolster musicians’ salaries back to where they were in 2016 (a goal for 2021) never mind increasing those salaries in future years.
The independent assessment indicated that the requisite support necessary for a top-tier orchestra in Pittsburgh exists, that the money is indeed out there, if the PSO can only figure out how to raise it.
Fiscally, the orchestra is on track to meet its goals this year, and all parties are hopeful for the future. But the PSO will need more than a year to determine if their efforts are enough to increase their fundraising revenue to the levels needed to sustain one of the top orchestras in the world.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds’ work is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, the Getty Foundation, and the Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.