Across the Atlantic, the debate is much simpler — Beatles or Stones — with the edge usually going to the Beatles for getting there first, pushing more boundaries and not hanging around well past their prime.
But, as we approach another Fourth of July, the question in the States is still open-ended: What is the Greatest American Rock ‘n’ Roll Band?
After all, it was our music, pioneered in the late ‘40s and early ‘50s by the likes of Fats Domino, Chuck Berry, Little Richard, Bill Haley and Elvis Presley. They invented it and stepped aside while the form went to a new level with the next generations.
Band wise, there’s no American Beatles, so when the subject of greatest American band comes up, we’re all over the place. Just the other day, I came upon a Facebook post claiming it was Cheap Trick, touted on a Trouser Press cover in 1978 as “America’s Best Band?”
Cheap Trick? Um, probably not. But who is? I tossed the question out on social media and 450 comments later, there was nothing close to consensus. The bands that got the most mentions are in the poll below. Please take the poll and add your opinion in the comments section.
The Beach Boys: Predating the British Invasion, the Beach Boys are an American institution, celebrating the fun and freedom of life along the glamorous West Coast. Whether it’s surfing, cruising with the top down, going on a date or getting your heart broken, the Beach Boys have a song for it, delivered with Technicolor harmonies. Along with their endless summer hits, the Wilson clan boasts one of the most acclaimed albums of all time and the one that set the Beatles on the path to Sgt. Pepper, “Pet Sounds.”
The Grateful Dead: Not just a band but a freaking way of life. Few bands were able traverse everything from gentle folk-rock to violent avant-garde space jams, but the Dead did it, while blazing their own trail and speaking to the American experience, under the lyric guidance of Robert Hunter.
The Jimi Hendrix Experience: He didn’t headline Woodstock for nothing. Hendrix flipped the guitar upside down, literally and figuratively, showing the next generation of guitarists how to manipulate feedback and amps on overdrive. The Seattle native was the full package as guitarist, singer, writer and flamboyant rock star. We’ll have to overlook the fact that the other two guys were British.
The Doors: Few bands are more loved and hated, but you’ll have that with a messianic frontman who would declare “I am the Lizard King.” With his acid-laced poetry (“the scream of the butterfly”?) and Ray Manzarek doing Bach fugues, The Doors are far out on the pretentious edge of rock, but they had a rare combination of wholly unique sound, outstanding musicianship and a flair for hits while still having that element of unhinged danger to be found later in bands like The Stooges.
The Allman Brothers Band: Another case of a band inventing a genre, the Allman Brothers are the sound of Southern Rock, with an unrivaled two-guitar attack and one of the most soulful voices ever to come out of a gangly blonde kid. The range was hard blues jams to feel-good road tunes to gorgeous instrumentals like “Jessica” and “In Memory of Elizabeth Reed,” where every precious notes seemed to be in place.
The Stooges: It took a while for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame to get around to these Motor City madmen, generally regarded as the prototypical punk band. The Stooges brought it hard, back in 1969. It was rumored at one point that Iggy Pop might take over as frontman of the Doors after Jim Morrison died in 1971. His perfect reply was that he wasn’t going to do a “ghoulish impersonation.” “What’s wrong with me?” he said. “Why do you need Jim Morrison?”
Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band: Anyone who has seen one of its exhaustive three-hour shows would be hard-pressed to make a strong argument against “The heart-stopping, pants-dropping, hard-rocking, booty-shaking, love-making, earth-quaking, Viagra-taking, justifying, death-defying, legendary E Street Band.” I can say, having stood near Springsteen while he was on stage that I’ve never seen the mysterious power of rock ’n’ roll surge through anyone with such force. With the most versatile band in the land, that force is applied to everything from raucous garage-rock songs to elegant pieces of art-rock, with a focus on the joys, dreams and hardships of being American.
Aerosmith: Aerosmith is about the closest America got to having its known Led Zeppelin. And Rolling Stones. In one package. The Boston band combined the Stones’ bluesy swagger with Led Zep’s metal crunch. The group, still fully intact, went from being one of the most thrilling and dangerous arena-rock bands of the ‘70s to refashioning itself as more commercial hitmakers in the late ‘80s and ‘90s.
Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers: Try riding around some afternoon with “All Songs” selected on the Tom Petty page of Spotify. It is an amazing and seemingly endless run of hits from one of America’s quintessential heartland bands with a frontman who makes it look easy.
The Ramones: The Ramones took the Beach Boys, scrapped the harmonies and added an adrenaline rush of speed and power to rekindle the original spirit of rock ’n’ roll and usher in the punk revolution of the ’70s. They were too much ahead of their time (or were they behind it?) for radio to catch on. With a little help, the hits would have been endless and the Ramones, to most people, would be more than “hey-ho, let’s go!” and a cool T-shirt.
Talking Heads: Another band out of CBGB’s, Talking Heads were like the anti-Ramones, wearing polo shirts and playing angular art-punk. Of course, they evolved as much as any band possibly could, expanding into a formidable funk band employing African polyrhythms on “Remain in Light.”
Van Halen: You still can’t go into a Guitar Center without hearing what Eddie Van Halen wrought. He took wanky to new, ecstatic heights while howling frontman David Lee Roth was doing scissor-kicks off the riser. The original VH’s hedonistic heyday lasted for seven years, from 1978 to 1984, during which the band metalized The Kinks and Roy Orbison, wrote some killer radio tracks and made us think differently about the color of M&M’s. Then all hell broke loose, with DLR booted for Sammy Hagar. It couldn’t possibly work, right? No. But “Van Hagar” was a smash success, and this dysfunctional institution has been one of rock’s greatest soap operas ever since.
Nirvana: The Aberdeen, Washington, band’s great innovation was taking what some of the great post-punk bands like the Pixies, Husker Du and Meat Puppets did, cranking the sonics and turning it into something more commercially palatable. A little video shot in a high school for “Smells Like Teen Spirit” changed everything, and brought grunge to the forefront when people had had their fill of the hair-metal bands. Unfortunately, Kurt Cobain took the option of burning out rather than fading away, and we were robbed of seeing how he would develop as an artist.
Pearl Jam: You can’t really talk Nirvana without also including Pearl Jam, which followed close behind with 1991’s “Ten,” an album that blew up a year later with the singles “Alive,” “Even Flow” and “Jeremy.” With Eddie Vedder more equipped to cope with stardom, Pearl Jam eclipsed Nirvana as one of the most powerful live bands of ’90s, and has kept them on a relatively steady course ever since.
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.