Rolling Stone may be called “the bible of rock ’n’ roll” by some people, but most will agree that it’s not the good-book of metal.

The magazine’s original stance on the genre can be summed up by Black Sabbath’s catalogue getting a straight run of one-star reviews (from Ken Tucker) in the first edition of the Rolling Stone Record Guide. If they were bad, they couldn’t all be equally bad, right? The review of that first Black Sabbath album in 1970, written by none other than Lester Bangs, gave it no stars, concluding “...just like Cream! But worse.”

Needless to say, there has been some revisionist thinking on Ozzy and the gang, as Black Sabbath is now No. 1 on Rolling Stone’s new list of “The 100 Greatest Metal Albums of All Time.”

This is a risky list for RS, as metal has been more the domain of mags like Revolver, Metal Hammer and Kerrang!, and now Loudwire, Blabbermouth and Metal Injection. RS admits in the intro that the list “contains a few records Rolling Stone either smeared in the review section in years past or outright overlooked, making this list a mea culpa.”

Advertise with us

Of course, few people seem happy with the list, which is the very nature of lists, and which makes them such great clickbait.

The biggest issue is with the parameters RS set for the list. Metal pioneers Led Zeppelin, Cream and Deep Purple are disqualified due to their “folky, bluesy detours.” AC/DC and Guns N' Roses are dispatched because they are merely “hypercharged rock & roll.” And Kiss, Alice Cooper and Grand Funk Railroad “in retrospect sound more like hard rock.”

But that didn’t stop them from including Van Halen, Def Leppard, Twisted Sister, Living Colour and even Motley Crue.

“[We] had endless discussions about bands like AC/DC, Guns N’ Roses, Kiss and Van Halen,” RollingStone.com senior music editor Hank Shteamer told metalinsider.net. “To be clear, by excluding some of these artists, we’re not trying to slight them or downplay their importance to the larger world of music that surrounds and feeds into metal; we were really just trying to get at what we felt was some essential spirit of metal that is very present in, say, Sabbath from the get-go and maybe less so in AC/DC. Where any listener draws that line is obviously a totally subjective thing – all we tried to do was decide on parameters that made sense to us and abide by them.”

If you’ve only ever dipped your toe into the metal scene, the list is not without its educational merits, and here in the age of Spotify and Apple Music, you can sample these headbangers like boxes of chocolates.

Advertise with us

Here are some reactions from Pittsburgh metal musicians and fans via social media:

Chip DiMonick (Chip DiMonick): While a good "best metal albums" list is a studded leather-clad unicorn, this list is certainly one of the worst. After the Top 5, it gets progressively ridiculous. Kudos for them to include some underground stuff -- that's kind of the spirit of metal - but shame on them for including such BAD underground stuff. So many influential albums were placed lower than their second generation, watered-down copycats. A Slayer album finishing higher than Ozzy's "Blizzard of Ozz?" A Celtic Frost album finishing higher than Metallica's "Kill 'Em All?" A Tool album finishing higher than Alice In Chains' "Dirt?" Sacrilege, man. Sacrilege.

John Roman (Microwaves): There's some truly great entries on here and some of my favorites, but they really drop the ball when they either stretch the genre too far (Living Colour, Evanescence) or include current mainstream trend bands like Avenged Sevenfold who really (to my ears) aren't too much different from stuff like Godsmack or ’90s Metallica. And, for what it's worth, I like "Torture Garden" and "Angel Dust" just fine, but I really don't think of them as metal albums. You can throw in other influences with hip-hop and it'll still pretty much be a hip-hop album, but just because you add some funky beats it doesn't instantly turn whatever else it was into hip-hop. It works pretty much the same with heavy metal.

John Katic: It would be cool if it was a list compiled by a publication that knew anything about metal.

Ted Williams (Volcano Dogs, Eviction): There are some serious major omissions and stuff in there (looking at you Loving Color and Faith No More) that should never been included.

Advertise with us

Matthew Reinhart: It is pretty much exactly what I thought it would be. No surprises at all which makes it pretty boring. I've done countdown lists for various publications and received death threats for certain placements, lol. Rolling Stone simply showed their lack of knowledge and respect for the genre. They should have done a list of "Top 100 Indie Artists that we have a hard-on for that you won't remember in 4 Years".

Brian Sandor: Not bad for a Rolling Stone list. But where is Obituary and Cannibal Corpse and Machine Head? And why is Black Sabbath's Sabotage higher than Heaven and Hell and Mob Rules or Sabbath Bloody Sabbath isn't on the list?

Sam Zets: Worthy list. Metal rules. Among the many things that make metal great are the countless genres, and the deep divisions among what a fan loves/hates. Omission: Spinal Tap (sure a parody, but the ultimate homage to the genre and it deserved a special spot at 100, 66.6 or 11.11). Undeserved: Pantera "vulgar display of overrated" (just never got it or converted, sure there are riffs but IMO songs and vocals just miss; it sounds like a parody, no disrespect rip dime).

Joseph Dello Stritto: Not having Iron Maiden's Piece of Mind on the list is baffling to me. Also the debut S/T Metal Church record is one of the best debut metal records ever.

Ben Smartniick (former Kim Phuc): Seems like they got four people together to make the list, one of them being a hair touching former Hot Topic employee. They allowed all of his suggestions onto the list, because they didn't want to be "too mean." Also, how is Megadeth "Countdown" on there? That thing is terrible.

Advertise with us

Steve Kalinsky: If you can make out the band's name in that silly overused Gothic like font, it's not metal enough.

Among the comments from Rolling Stone readers:

KISSman: You leave out KISS, but Def Leppard and Van Halen qualify as 'metal'??? Rolling Stone proves once again why it should never delve into metal because it never respected the genre and clearly knows nothing about it.

Hugh Mungus: Where are Candlemass, Bathory, Anvil, Led Zeppelin, Rammstein, Ghost, Saxon, Deep Purple, King Diamond, among others? Truly this list can't be taken seriously when avenged sevenfold and evanescence are on it.

bob: AC/DC is a glaring omission as well as Nine Inch Nails. you can't include Manson and omit the person who made his best album Antichrist Superstar. For NIN downward Spiral hands down.

Advertise with us

themocc: Any list that includes Evanescence that's not a "Worst of" list is a bad list.

Ryan: Metal is childish music. Grow up. If your taste in music hasn't changed since you were 12, you got problems.

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg