The band known for the single “Let’s Be Still” took the stage to “Let’s Dance” and a request from violinist/singer Charity Rose Thielen to get up out of the seats.
The Head and the Heart will never be mistaken for a dance band, but did prove to be worth standing for Wednesday night at the Benedum in its first theater show in Pittsburgh.
That single from the fall of 2013, when the Seattle band first broke out, suggests that “you can get lost in the music for hours,” and for a little over 90 minutes that’s what happened. There’s nothing remarkably innovative or adventurous about The Head and the Heart — it’s just another sweet take on folk-rock (although they don’t like the term) with pleasant guitars and rich harmonies from the three singers up front.
One of them is out for this tour behind third album “Signs of Light.” Josiah Johnson, the band’s most charismatic member, is in recovery for addiction, replaced for now by Thielen’s husband, singer-guitarist Matt Gervais. That meant moving the more reserved Jonathan Russell to center stage to handle lead vocals on all but a few of the songs. Still growing into the role, he’s a frontman that puts the spotlight on the songs rather himself. (I think you’re supposed to be doing backflips and stage dives these days.)
On a stage with colorful lighting, glowing orbs and a neon flamingo and “Signs of Light” logo, the band touched on the two Sub Pop albums and the latest Warner Bros. debut, the latter giving us energetic rocker “City of Angels,” and “All I Ever Knew” and “Rhythm & Blues,” songs with big “la-la, la-la’s” and “woo-hoo, hoo-hoo’s” that Americana crowds love.
Two of the favorites, “Another Story” and “Let’s Be Still,” both from that second album, were paired together to make up a strong core in the midset. Both rocked harder than the studio versions, driven by Thielen’s violin, Tyler Williams’ drums and a disco ball.
There’s not a ton of variety to this catalog, so the ragtime piano on “Ghosts,” Russell’s stripped-down “Oh My Dear” (reminiscent of Led Zeppelin’s “The Rain Song”) and Thielen’s pretty co-lead on “Library Magic” were all welcome. So was the joyful cover of Crowded House’s “Hey Now” that brought opening band Whitney back to the stage. Gervais had mixed results on “Your Mother's Eyes” -- lackluster on the verses, bolder on the chorus -- and then showed real chemistry with Russell, particularly in the encore, with a raucous version of the breakout hit “Shake.”
The Head and the Heart has built an adoring fanbase with placid songs that look inward: “Let’s Be Still,” “Take a Walk,” “Lost in My Mind.” It will be interesting to see how they hold up and where they go in this new era. Johnson’s re-emergence will definitely help.
Smith Westerns was a pretty cool indie/glam band, and when the Chicago group broke up in 2014, drummer Julien Ehrlich decided to step out front — with his whole drum kit! — in the new band Whitney.
There’s a good reason why drummers set up in the back and why they don’t tend to sing from behind the kit. It's not a good look, especially the way four other members were lined up in a row behind him.
Whitney hit a few 100-best lists last year for debut album “Light Upon the Lake,” which rose or fell depending on how much you like Ehrlich’s consistently high soul falsetto. Together, Whitney is a talented but pretty tepid indie-pop band that generates precious little excitement live, so the 45 minutes did drag a bit, and Ehrlich’s droll banter between songs about making out with the trumpet player and where to party after the show didn't help.
The wistful single “No Woman” (saved for last) and the swinging cover of NRBQ’s “Magnet” were highlights, but less would have been more.
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.