Word that Twenty One Pilots would headline PPG Paints Arena in January felt a little like turning back time.

In the good old days, of rock ’n’ roll at least, young acts with hits, talent and charisma could move steadily from clubs to theaters to arenas.

These days, not so much.

Twenty One Pilots

Advertise with us

With: Jon Bellion.

Where: PPG Paints Arena, Uptown.

When: 7 p.m. Friday.

Tickets: Sold out; available only on secondary market.

But Twenty One Pilots have the flight plan and the ground support. When last in Pittsburgh back in June, the Columbus, Ohio, duo had teen fans camped out in front of Stage AE for three days to get a spot up front. Combine the hysteria with the high-energy show and it’s not a huge surprise that the duo, which blends hip-hop and electronic rock, is going the full 18,000 on the Emotional Roadshow Tour.

Advertise with us

It will be the first emerging rock act to headline the arena since Five Finger Death Punch did in May (sort of), and just the second since Imagine Dragons in June 2015.

There were 14 concerts at the arena last year, with just a few of the artists in the rock realm: Bruce Springsteen (two shows), The Who, Coldplay and 5FDP/​Shinedown (playing to a little more than half-capacity). The rest were a mix of pop, rap and country — Justin Bieber, Drake, Carrie Underwood, Blake Shelton and Dolly Parton — plus two Christian tours and Trans-Siberian Orchestra’s holiday production.

The KeyBank Pavilion (formerly First Niagara Pavilion) season was split evenly across classic rock and country — about eight shows each — along with three metal packages (Disturbed, Slipknot, Korn), two punk tours (Warped and Blink-182), the Wiz/​Snoop joint and Josh Groban.

In other words, Slipknot, which formed in 1995 and has a 43-year-old frontman, was the youngest rock band to headline the 25,000-capacity amphitheater. Country had one new headliner, Brantley Gilbert, on a schedule with regulars: Luke Bryan, Jason Aldean, Brad Paisley, etc.

The North Shore’s Stage AE, holding 2,300 inside and 5,500 outdoors, has been the better fit for young rock acts, from M83 to HAIM to Mastodon.

Advertise with us

“Once the viral age kind of took over, it’s hard to grow these bands past 6, 7,000, because there are so many bands, and kids are on to something now and on to something new the next week,” says Scott Stienecker, president of the Columbus-based PromoWest Productions, which manages Stage AE. “We haven’t been able to build these 18,000-seat sellers anymore. Your Tom Pettys can still do it, but the younger rock bands, they hit a plateau.”

With less radio impact and people streaming rather than buying music, there’s more niche listening, faster turnover and less commitment to an artist.

“Back in the old days,” Mr. Stienecker says, “we listened to the main rock station, and it told us what was good. They would play Aerosmith and Boston and Ted Nugent, and that’s how they became big. Nowadays, kids get their own music, and it’s a whole different world than when radio was king.”

Last year’s pop charts were dominated by established hitmakers like Bieber, Rihanna, Adele and Drake. Twenty One Pilots — whose frontman Tyler Joseph briefly worked at PromoWest’s LC Pavilion in Columbus before they became headliners there in 2011 — broke onto radio and cracked the Top 25 with the hits “Stressed Out,” “Ride” and “Heathens.”

X Ambassadors were one of the only other rock bands to creep into the Top 100, aside from Coldplay, but there were appearances by a few rock solo artists such as Ellie Goulding and Elle King.

Advertise with us

“I have a theory that only one rock band at a time can have big, mainstream, Top 40 success,” says Mikey Dougherty, co-host of the “Morning Freak Show” on KISS (96.1 FM). “We went from Imagine Dragons to Twenty One Pilots. At one time, Nickelback was that band. But only ONE rock band, for whatever reason, can have Top 40 success at a time. Usually it goes for a year or two and then switches to a new band.”

Over the past decade, Fall Out Boy, Kings of Leon, Arcade Fire and Muse have been among the young bands jumped to arena level.

“Kings of Leon was one we thought would be the next arena headliner, and they did for a while but their numbers tapered off,” Mr. Stienecker says.

The Avett Brothers drew 9,000 to the Petersen Events Center in Oakland in 2014 before returning to Stage AE level, and Cage the Elephant headlined the four-band Spring Fling fest at the Pete last year. Panic! At the Disco, which drew a more feverish reaction than headliner Weezer at Stage AE last summer, makes its Petersen leap on Feb. 28.

Given the difficult path for rock bands, though, a number of heartland-style rockers turn to Nashville.

Advertise with us

“Country is radio-driven,” Mr. Stienecker says, so it’s been easier for the Dierks Bentleys and Brantley Gilberts to break in there.

“There’s a constant stream of country acts that step up to that level,” says Gary Bongiovanni, editor of Pollstar. “How long they last is a whole other matter. It’s harder to break through on a mass level [in rock], and sometimes it can be a fluke, like a hit song coming out of a video game.”

One band on the fast track is — fitting name — The 1975, which sold out two nights inside Stage AE last fall and comes back in May to play outdoors. The British indie rockers haven’t been blessed with hits and radio play in the States, but their second album, “I Like It When You Sleep, for You Are So Beautiful yet So Unaware of It,” topped the Billboard 200 last year, so it was more of a grass-roots success. It could build from there, or fans could move on to the next big thing.

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg.