It wasn’t going to be “The Last Waltz” or anything, but there was going to be a goodbye weekend at Altar Bar, highlighted by Pittsburgh pop-punk band Punchline celebrating its 10th anniversary at the Strip District club.

Fittingly, a metalcore band, I Prevail, was going to have the last word on July 31 before Altar Bar, after a decadelong run as a music venue, was handed over to new owner Orchard Hill Church as a satellite location for its Sunday services.

Unfortunately, an inspection on July 15 revealed a safety issue that shut down the venue immediately, making the July 10 show by Let Live the last act. Altar Bar now joins the Decade, the Electric Banana, Graffiti, Metropol, Club Laga and many more clubs as Pittsburgh things that aren’t here anymore.

Built in 1908 as the St. Elizabeth Church, it was desanctified and sold due to declining membership in 2001 and opened as the nightclub Sanctuary in 2002. Under the new ownership of Mike Pitterich, who made his money in steel, it became Altar Bar in 2006 and in its earliest days focused on tribute bands, which remained part of its lineup till the end.

Advertise with us

Along the way, the club, often disparaged for its murky sound and less-than-ideal sightlines, played host to such notable acts as Snoop Dogg, St. Vincent, Imagine Dragons, Twenty One Pilots, Leon Russell, the War on Drugs, Gary Numan, Public Image Ltd., The Struts and X (my personal highlight). It also served as the centerpiece of the Strip District Music Festival for two consecutive Januarys.

“There were so many shows that were special to me in different ways,” says Josh Bakaitus, of Drusky Entertainment, the exclusive promoter for the club. “I'd say though that the Imagine Dragons, The Struts, Grouplove, Hopsin and G-Eazy shows were some of the best. There was a special magic in the air at those shows. For each it was during a time when they were coming up, when the excitement was high and you could tell that they were going to be long-lasting staple acts.”

Some cool things happened there behind the scenes, as well. Bruce Springsteen rehearsed there before one of his Soldiers & Sailors Memorial shows with the Houserockers.

“Last month when FLAG played there,” Mr. Bakaitus says, “we were surprised with a last-minute Descendents rehearsal during the day, before the band went to Punk Rock Bowling the following weekend. Milo wasn't there but it was the rest of the band practicing those songs with me singing in the back corner of the room with six other people.”

There were nights when what transpired on stage at Altar Bar would have been a vision of hell for the former worshippers there. Chip DiMonick, of the metal band of the same name, recalls his first show there in 2007.

Advertise with us

“We were asked to play one song as part of the Elise's Playground fetish show. During our song, there would be a skit acted out. We didn't know what it would be but, hey, the opportunity to play in front of a built-in crowd was calling a young band. The skit unfolded between the two female performers. First, there was girl-on-girl groping. Then, whips and chains appeared. Spanking ensued, followed by a simulated stabbing murder. And, finally, flesh eating was acted out. All in the course of a three-and-a-half minute song and in a former church!”

A popular business practice was stacking the bill with opening acts, who would help with ticket sales, and that could be an adventure, too. Sean Styles recalls a gig with his band Walk of Shame, opening for Vanilla Ice.

“Sold out show, and it was great,” he says. “We got to play a ’90s rock set since Ice was doing a ‘harder’ live show. We were supposed to play a 45-minute set. Well, Ice had some bad sushi that afternoon and we got pushed to do an extra 30 on the fly. Ice came out, dumped a case of water on the crowd, did no more than 30 minutes total, and we were out.”

Along with fronting power-pop band Semi-Supervillains, Vinnie Pasquale was pursuing a pharmacology degree and thought he could cram for a test there before opening for Living Colour.

“Living Colour's road crew took up all of the dressing rooms; I had to study for a big psych and neuro exam the next day so I found this broom closet. Some janitor kicked me out of the broom closet so I went next door to study in McDonald’s. And that’s how I’ll always remember the Altar Bar. Having to study in McDonald’s because the local opener couldn’t sit in a broom closet to study quietly.”

Advertise with us

For drummer Jake Leger, formerly of Carousel, it was a career highlight to open for Black Star Riders.

“They put on an incredible show and it's as close as I'll ever get to seeing Thin Lizzy live. Got to shake Scott Gorham's hand and that was awesome.”

“The Irishmen had a lot of fun at Altar Bar,” says Ben Jaber of Bastard Bearded Irishmen. “We released a record there, played an awesome City Paper party, got to share whiskey with Mark Adkins of Guttermouth and swap stories with Mike McColgan of Street Dogs and Dropkick Murphys, partied for the first Strip District Music Festival. Owner Mike once announced us as The Drunken Beardish Bastards. Fitting.”

In terms of acoustics, Altar Bar was more like Metropol than Graffiti.

“The bass was always too heavy, and the balance was just way off in general,” says singer-songwriter Kristin Vasselo. “Half of the time, you couldn't hear the vocalists over the instruments. I don't know if it was the equipment itself or the engineers. Whatever the reason, it took away from a lot of talented performers. I had some really great times there despite that flaw, but that was always why it was never my favorite spot.”

Advertise with us

Concertgoer Rich Kulbacki saw his favorite band, The Darkness, there in October and says, “As always, the sound was awful, and although I loved seeing them for the fourth time, I couldn't help but wish it was at Stage AE like the previous show.”

Along with presenting people’s favorite bands, not always under the best conditions, Altar Bar did its part to serve the community. Jazz cabaret singer Phat Man Dee has happy memories of Altar Bar, saying, “Brian Drusky helped Pittsburgh Artists for Social Change produce two Unity concerts there and started a ticketing fund which benefitted the Afro-American Music Institute for over a year and donated over $13,000 to that wonderful school. The staff was lovely and competent and I’m sorry for their loss.”

Mr. Bakaitus acknowledges that Altar Bar had “ups and downs,” but says it was more up than down in recent years.

“Ten years of a constant uphill battle to improve the place, make it more comfortable and a better experience to have it all go away out of nowhere was definitely a disappointment. A ton of heart and soul went into that place. So many amazing people worked there, played there and rocked out there. I hope people can find something positive out of this. Mine lately has been hearing people refer to its closing the same way I felt about Club Laga closing years ago. Knowing that somebody was impacted in a positive way makes it an easier pill to swallow.”

Drusky will shift its shows to other venues, particularly the South Side’s Rex Theater (where Punchline will play its anniversary show in October) and the Carnegie of Homestead Music Hall in Munhall. For the Strip and the concert scene, especially on the metal side, it’s another major venue off the map.

Advertise with us

Then again, there will still be music there. Houserockers guitarist Danny Gochnour, noting that he “always had a good time there,” says, “Fortunately, I'm part of the Orchard Hill music team, so I'm sure I'll play there again. But as a rock venue in the strip, I'll miss it.”

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg.