A book found in the University of Pittsburgh’s archives this summer that some thought would be the “smoking gun” in the battle to determine if a mega music cooperation owned the rights to the song “Happy Birthday to You” turned out to be irrelevant to the case when a federal judge issued his decision on Tuesday.
U.S. District Judge George H. King in Los Angeles ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, who argued that Warner/Chappell, the publishing arm of Warner Music, doesn’t own the copyright to the song. Warner claimed to own the song and has been charging at least $1,500 for its use since 1988 when it bought the Birch Tree Group, the successor company of the Clayton F. Summy Co., which copyrighted the song in 1935.
The plaintiffs, mostly small documentary producers, believed that the lyrics to “Happy Birthday” published in the 1927 edition of “The Everyday Song Book” — located at Hillman Library in Pitt’s Special Collections Department — was in the public domain because it was published in the book without a copyright. But it was unclear if the composers authorized the publishers to print the lyrics in that book, so the judge moved to other evidence to make his ruling.
“Once the court determines that there is a factual dispute, then the court stops and says ‘We’re not going to resolve that issue right now, and we’re not going to decide the case on that basis,’ ” said Michael Madison, faculty director of Pitt Law’s Innovation Practice Institute. “So for purposes of deciding the overall case right now, we’re just going to ignore the book.”
Instead of using the book discovered at Pitt, the judge examined where Warner/Chappell claimed its copyright came from.
Warner/Chappell bought the Birch Tree Group, which, as the Summy Co., received permission from the family of the songwriters to copyright “Happy Birthday” in 1935, according to the company.
Read More
Judge King, however, said that there was not enough evidence that the company ever received the copyright to the song decades ago and ruled in favor of the plaintiffs.
“The judge says that there no unambiguous evidence that the predecessor got the copyright,” Mr. Madison said. “Therefore, Warner/Chappell has nothing because it acquired nothing from its predecessor.”


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.