In 2023, Western Pennsylvania film critics founded a new organization, the Pittsburgh Film Critcs Association, to establish a Pittsburgh-based voice in the world of cinema commentary.

On Thursday, the a 15-member voting block within the association revealed their top honors for 2024, highlighting movies they found most exceptional in 20 different categories. This year, they debut the first ever Mr. Rogers Kindness Award, to be awarded annually to films that exude the values of beloved Pittsburgher and television host Fred Rogers.

Director Coralie Fargeat’s twist on the body-horror genre, “The Substance,” took the PFCA’s spot for Best Picture, with Luca Guadagnino’s tennis-themed romantic drama “Challengers” taking the runner-up prize.

Colman Domingo, star of A24’s “Sing Sing,” took 2024’s Best Lead Actor Award, while Ariana Grande received the award for Best Supporting Actor for her role as Glinda in “Wicked.”  The Mr. Rogers Kindness award went to the entire cast and crew of “The Seed of the Sacred Fig,” a German-French political thriller that was reportedly shot in secret and smuggled out of Iran.

Advertise with us

“Western Pennsylvania is a thriving hotbed for both film production and film criticism,” the PFCA board said in a joint statement. “It’s our immense honor to be celebrating 2024’s finest films as a united collective of Pittsburgh-based film critics. Congratulations to all our 2024 PFCA Awards winners!”

Here are the winners and runner-ups in all categories:

Best picture

Winner: “The Substance”

Runner-Up: “Challengers”

Best Lead Actor

Winner: Colman Domingo in “Sing Sing”

Advertise with us

Runner-Up: Cynthia Erivo in “Wicked”

Best Supporting Actor

Winner: Ariana Grande in “Wicked”

Runner-Up: Clarence Maclin in “Sing Sing”

Best Featured Actor

(15 minutes or less of screen time)

Winner: Jesse Plemons in “Civil War”

Advertise with us

Runners-Up (Tie): Lamorne Morris in “Saturday Night” and Isabella Rossellini in “Conclave”

Breakthrough Performance

Winner: Clarence Maclin in “Sing Sing”

Runner-Up: Katy O’Brian in “Love Lies Bleeding”

Best Animated Voice Performance

Winner: Lupita Nyong’o in “The Wild Robot”

Runner-Up: Maya Hawke in “Inside Out 2

Advertise with us

Best Director

Winner: Robert Eggers for “Nosferatu”

Runner-Up: Coralie Fargeat for “The Substance”

Best Original Screenplay

Winner: Justin Kuritzkes for “Challengers”

Runner-Up: Sean Baker for “Anora”

Best Adapted Screenplay

Winner: Clint Bentley, Greg Kwedar, Clarence Maclin, John “Divine G” Whitfield for “Sing Sing”

Advertise with us

Runner-Up: Robert Eggers for “Nosferatu”

Best Cinematography

Winner: Jomo Fray for “Nickel Boys”

Runner-Up: Jarin Blaschke for “Nosferatu”

Best Editing

Winner: Marco Costa for “Challengers”

Runner-Up: Jerome Eltabet, Coralie Fargeat, Valentin Feron for “The Substance”

Advertise with us

Best Production Design

Winner: Craig Lathrop for “Nosferatu”

Runner-Up: Stanislas Reydellet, Cécilia Blom for “The Substance”

Best Score

Winner: Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross for “Challengers”

Runner-Up: Cristobal Tapia de Veer for “Babygirl”

Best Song

Winner: “Compress/Repress” from “Challengers”

Advertise with us

Runners-Up (Tie): “Starburned and Unkissed" from “I Saw the TV Glow” and “Harper and Will Go West” from “Will & Harper”

Best Sound Design

Winner: Emmanuelle Villard, Valerie Deloof, Victor Fleurant, Stéphane Thiébaut, Victor Praud — “The Substance”

Runner-Up: Lisa Pinero, Craig Berkey, Paul Carter — “Challengers”

Best Hair, Makeup and Costumes

Winner: Emmanuelle Youchnovski (Costume); Pierre-Olivier Persin (Makeup/Hairstyle) — “The Substance”

Runner-Up: Linda Muir (Costume); Traci Loader, Suzanne Stokes-Munton, David White (Makeup/Hairstyle) — “Nosferatu”

Advertise with us

Best Animated Feature

Winner: “The Wild Robot”

Runner-Up: “Inside Out 2”

Best Film Not in the English Language

Winners (Tie): “The Seed of the Sacred Fig”; “Flow”

Best Stunt Performance and Choreography

Winner: Keir Beck, Chris O'Hara — “The Fall Guy”

Runner-Up: Udeh Nans, Brahim Chab — “Monkey Man”

Advertise with us

Mr. Rogers Kindness Award

Winner: The entire cast and crew of “The Seed of the Sacred Fig”