While Pittsburgh’s filmmaking scene still sometimes gets overshadowed by the competition, it has at least earned enough respect to remain on the national radar as a premier moviemaking destination.

Keep that in mind when considering Pittsburgh’s placement on Moviemaker magazine’s 2024 “Best Places to Live and Work as a Moviemaker” rankings. The Steel City has been a staple of this list for years now, mostly in the “Smaller Cities and Towns” category before MovieMaker decided to start pitting Pittsburgh against other “Big Cities” for the first time last year.

MovieMaker ranked Pittsburgh No. 3 in 2021 and No. 4 in 2022 among those smaller cities and towns. It hailed this region as the 10th-best big city for filmmakers to live and work last year. MovieMaker editor in chief Tim Molloy explained in his 2023 blurb that while “we used to list Pittsburgh as one of our best small towns,” Western Pennsylvania’s filmmaking community can now “hold its own against much bigger cities.”

This year, MovieMaker slotted Pittsburgh in at No. 13 among the 25 big cities that made this coveted annual list. That still put Pittsburgh ahead of major urban areas like Dallas, Boston, Baltimore and Cleveland. It does sting a bit, however, for Pittsburgh to have been beaten out by the likes of Philadelphia (No. 12) and Cincinnati (No. 11).

Advertise with us

The rest of this list was rounded out by, in order from No. 1-10: Toronto; Albuquerque, New Mexico; New Orleans; Austin, Texas; Vancouver, British Columbia; Atlanta; Miami; Calgary, Canada; Chicago; and Montreal.

MovieMaker excludes Los Angeles and New York City from its rankings due to their clear status as the United States’ two most prominent entertainment industry hubs.

“The Steel City has a modern sheen it’s hard to replicate elsewhere, but with its historic buildings, three rivers, sweeping bridges and nearby mountains, it can stand in for a wide range of other cities and time periods,” wrote authors Molloy, Deirdre McCarrick and Margeaux Sippell.

They went on to laud this region for generally being “more affordable than the U.S. average” and keeping film-industry spending steady at “about $150 million per year.” MovieMaker also cited Carnegie Mellon University’s vaunted School of Drama, Pennsylvania’s film tax incentive program and the recently launched CREATE PA: Film & Theater Works! workforce training initiative.

None of that is news to Pittsburgh Film Office director Dawn Keezer, who isn’t worried about this region’s minor fall in MovieMaker’s rankings. She largely attributed that slip to Western Pennsylvania’s film scene growing so rapidly that it’s now “being compared to much larger cities who have more amenities and more resources being offered.”

Advertise with us

Keezer pointed out that Pennsylvania’s film tax incentive lags behind those in other states represented on MovieMaker’s 2024 list. Pennsylvania’s is capped at $100 million a year, while New Mexico’s current $120 cap is set to become $160 million by fiscal year 2028. Georgia’s film incentive remains uncapped, which makes it a particularly attractive destination for large-scale Hollywood productions.

“We continue to work diligently with our union and film industry partners to continue to grow this economic generating work to the region,” Keezer said. “My hope will be to see our ranking rise in the upcoming years.”

As for Philadelphia ending up one spot ahead of Pittsburgh, Keezer couldn’t argue with MovieMaker’s assessment that it shares many advantages with Pittsburgh while also acting as “an excellent home base for East Coast filmmakers given its accessibility to New York City, Baltimore and Washington, D.C.”

It was more surprising to see Cincinnati usurping Pittsburgh after coming in at No. 11 on last year’s Best Places to Live and Work as a MovieMaker rankings. The authors gave Cincinnati props for Ohio’s 30% refundable tax credit, the city’s increasingly developed film ecosystem, and the way it “straddles the Midwest and South and reflects the flavors of both.”

Hollywood officially returned to Pittsburgh earlier this month when production began on season three of the Paramount+ series “Mayor of Kingstown.” Local film professionals couldn’t wait for films and shows to start shooting here again following last year’s lengthy work stoppage stemming from SAG-AFTRA and the Writers Guild of America’s concurrent strikes against the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers.

Advertise with us

Any Pittsburgh film workers fretting over Western Pennsylvania dropping a few spots on these 2024 rankings can take solace in part of MovieMaker’s reasoning for including Cleveland on this list: “The city is also a mere two hours away from Pittsburgh.”

The implication there seems to be that when it comes to filmmaking assets, Pittsburgh is Appalachia’s New York City. We’ll take it!

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.