Six years ago, Justin M. Seaman would have never guessed there would be a sequel to “The Barn.”

The 36-year-old Claysville native had just spent two years putting together his indie horror film about a group of friends who accidentally awaken a powerful evil lying dormant in an abandoned barn. It was an intense shoot that essentially “broke me,” Seaman said, so he wasn’t in a hurry to make another. That changed once he realized “The Barn” had become a cult hit with admirers clamoring for more supernatural adventures in Helen’s Valley.

“We had such a good run with the movie and it grew such a huge fan base that I was like, if people really want [a sequel] and I can raise the money to do it, I’ll do it,” he said. “And I did.”

After four-plus years of production that included eight months of pandemic-induced delays, Seaman is finally back with “The Barn: Part II.” Both films were shot in Western Pennsylvania, and the sequel is set to premiere Saturday at Dormont’s Hollywood Theater. Tickets are $15 at hollywoodtheaterpgh.org.

Advertise with us

The first “Barn” centered around friends Sam (Mitchell Musolino) and Josh (Will Stout) fighting demons of all shapes and sizes. “Part II” picks up a few years later with Sam and Josh still missing after the events of Halloween 1989. Michelle (Lexi Dripps), the sole survivor of the original film, is elevated to protagonist status in “The Barn: Part II” as she tries to have a normal life while still maintaining hope that Sam may still be out there.

In the early 1990s, Helen’s Valley is divided over whether Halloween should continue to be banned in the wake of the boys’ disappearance. The two factions are led by the puritanical Sara Barnhart (Linnea Quigley) and flamboyant television host Dr. Rock (Ari Lehman). As those two bicker, Michelle and her sorority sister, Heather (Sable Griedel), host a charity haunted house at — where else? — an old barn crawling with monsters.

Seaman has been kicking around the concept for “The Barn” films since he was a child. In fact, he wrote the script’s first draft when he was just 8 years old and a rough treatment for a sequel a few years later. As someone with “a heart for horror,” he wanted to create a story that combined the spooky whimsicality of R.L. Stine’s “Goosebumps” novels with the schlocky ’80s horror flicks he grew up watching.

“It’s nostalgia from a kid’s point of view in the ’90s who watched ’80s films,” he said. “Getting a chance to make those movies is not only fun as a filmmaker, but it’s me getting to do something I never thought I would do as a little kid, turning these stories into live-action films.”

Most of “The Barn: Part II” takes place in a makeshift haunted house that Seaman and his crew built in Seaman’s Claysville studio. After the success of the first film, he decided “to double everything from the first movie” in terms of creepy monster designs and gore.

Advertise with us

Dripps was the first person Seaman auditioned for the role of Michelle in 2013. It was her first feature, and Seaman’s trust in his fellow Robert Morris University alumnus has now paid off in two “Barn” films. The Moon Area High School graduate had a lot of fun stepping into the spotlight in the sequel and getting to show what Michelle is truly capable of.

“It was much more of a Scooby-Doo ensemble piece in the first one with the spotlight on the boys,” she said. “Michelle was a little shy back then. After the trauma, she got to explore her badass side.”

Lexi Dripps as Michelle in "The Barn: Part II." (Justin M. Seaman)

You may be wondering how Seaman snagged Lehman, the first actor to portray horror icon Jason Vorhees in 1980’s “Friday the 13th,” for not one but two local indie projects. The answer: Seaman came across a leather jacket-clad Lehman chatting with fans at Steel City Con. He approached the actor about “The Barn,” and by the end of the weekend, the two had hashed out a date for Lehman to return to Pittsburgh for filming.

“You want to talk about ingenuity and somebody who is really going the full length to do what has to be done in order to create those effects,” Lehman said of Seaman’s work. “When all’s said and done, it’s all about what comes through that lens and is on that screen. People should know how much behind the scenes effort Justin and his team put in.”

Though Seaman isn’t quite as burned out as he was after filming “The Barn,” he currently doesn’t have plans for a threequel. That said, if fans want more “Barn,” he’s open to it down the road. Both Lehman and Dripps also said they’re down to reprise their roles if the opportunity arises.

Advertise with us

Seaman is way too busy getting ready for the Pittsburgh premiere to worry about a third outing. The film doesn’t currently have a distribution plan, though he’s had discussions with streamers and expects the Blu-ray and DVD to be available via screamteamreleasing.com in October. For now, Saturday’s screening is Western Pennsylvanians’ only chance to see “The Barn: Part II.”

“We know how much Pittsburgh loves zombies, so make sure you’re there!” Lehman said. “When we all come together at that premiere, it’s like a big family reunion. We want you to be part of the ‘Barn’ family, too.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.