Billy Porter enlisted a fellow Carnegie Mellon graduate to help him out with his new movie shooting in Pittsburgh.

Renee Elise Goldsberry, most well-known for winning a Tony as the original Angelica Schuyler in “Hamilton,” was announced earlier this week as one of the stars of Porter’s feature directorial debut “What If?,” according to Deadline. Her casting was announced less than a week after both Goldsberry and Porter received Emmy nominations for their work in the Disney+ “Hamilton” film and the final season of FX drama “Pose,” respectively.

Porter and Goldsberry collaborated on the Pittsburgh native’s 2017 album “Billy Porter Presents The Soul of Richard Rodgers” along with fellow CMU alumni Leslie Odom Jr. and Patina Miller. Goldsberry most recently had a prominent role in Tina Fey’s Peacock series “Girls5Eva,” which was recently renewed for a second season.

Deadline’s Justin Kroll confirmed that “What If?” officially began filming around Pittsburgh Monday. He also reported that Yasmin Finney, a 17-year-old Black trans woman who was originally cast in the film’s lead role, was unable to obtain a work visa due to backlogs in her native United Kingdom and thus was unable to join the production in time.

Advertise with us

In addition to Goldsberry, the cast of “What If?” will be rounded out by Eva Reign (“Sideways Smile”), Abubakr Ali (“Katy Keene”), Courtnee Carter (“Pose”), Kelly Lamor Wilson (“Freaky”) and newcomer Grant Reynolds.

Kroll indicated that Reign, also a Black trans woman, will now be playing Kelsa, the film’s lead.

“The modern coming-of-age story follows Kelsa (Reign), a trans high school senior,” Kroll wrote of the film’s plot. “After Khal (Ali) posts online about his school crush, the internet encourages him to go for it. ‘What If?’ tells the story of Kelsa and Khal navigating a senior-year relationship that neither could have expected.”

It’s unclear what role Goldsberry will be playing in “What If?” The two CMU graduates working together again — in Pittsburgh, no less — gels well with Goldsberry’s view of both her alma mater and the local arts scene.

“When you are surrounded by people like Billy Porter, Michael McElroy, Donna Champlin, Virginia Woodruff, Rema Webb — some of them I didn’t even go to school with but the love of the arts in Pittsburgh, well!” Goldsberry told the Post-Gazette in 2015.

Advertise with us

“Outside of the fact that it’s a college town and there are so many performing arts schools and such wonderful performing arts training, the city’s love for the arts, and its celebration of the arts is amazing.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.